http://openchannel.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/02/19/17010355-lights-cameras-
reaction-resistance-builds-against-red-light-cameras?lite


By Lisa Riordan Seville and Hannah Rappleye
NBC News
Drivers dread it -- that flash as they try to speed through a yellow
traffic light. It's a red light camera, and a signal that a ticket is on
the way.

A rarity 15 years ago, red light cameras have become ubiquitous in many
U.S. cities. Communities in 24 states and Washington, D.C., now use the
cameras to try to decrease illegal -- and sometimes deadly -- traffic
violations. Supporters say it's worked.

"In the last five years we went from 54 traffic fatalities to 19," said
Cathy Lanier, police chief in Washington, D.C., which began using the
cameras in 1999. "I mean, that's dramatic!"

Red light cameras are one piece of a growing network of automated
traffic enforcement. Cameras now monitor speed, bus and
high-occupancy-vehicle lanes and intersections with stop signs.
Proponents like Lanier say they help to deter accidents, nab violators
and allow states and municipalities to keep an eye on the roads for
less.

But critics of red light programs worry about the Big Brother aspect of
using cameras instead of cops. Many also say cameras, which are
generally run by private companies, have spread not because they make
streets safer, but because they mean profit for cities and companies.

"What the issue really comes down to is these companies are ripping
people off by hundreds of millions of dollars, in the name of caring
about our safety and our health and our kids," said New Jersey
Assemblyman Declan O'Scanlon, who has introduced anti-red light camera
legislation to the state Legislature.

Recent news stories have fueled opposition. In Chicago, an alleged
pay-to-play scandal led the mayor to ban one company from bidding for
future contracts. Millions were spent on pro-camera lobbying in Florida
and other states. In Iowa, doubts about the constitutionality of using
cameras as traffic enforcers led a state senator to introduce a bill to
ban red-light cameras - a move already taken by at least nine other
states.

What does science say?
Red light violations were associated with some 700 deaths and nearly
90,000 injuries in 2009, according to a study based on data reported to
the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Fatalities and
injuries have decreased in recent years, the study shows.

Researchers, however, are divided on how much red light cameras increase
safety.

In 2011, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, a nonprofit
research group funded by the insurance industry, released a study that
found red light cameras decreased fatal accidents by an estimated 24
percent in large cities that use them.

But a 2005 Federal Highway Administration study painted a more nuanced
picture. Data from seven jurisdictions showed a decrease in
front-into-side crashes at intersections with cameras. But it also
showed an increase in rear-end crashes. The researchers said that
apparently was the result of drivers hitting the brakes to avoid a
ticket. Overall, however, the research showed the cameras saved money by
both decreasing the most serious accidents, and generating revenue.

However, the FHA says that red light cameras shouldn't be a knee-jerk
traffic enforcement option. The agency issued a number of
recommendations regarding the implementation of red light cameras,
saying cameras should be considered only after engineering solutions
have failed in problem intersections. Among the possible solutions, it
says: Give drivers more cushion. Increasing yellow time by one second,
it found, can result in a 40 percent decrease in crashes in
stoplight-controlled intersections.

"It all hinges on proper yellow light time," said John Bowman,
communications director of the National Motorists Association, a drivers
advocacy group. "If yellow lights are set properly, based on established
traffic engineering, red light cameras are unnecessary because you
almost automatically have low numbers of violations and low numbers of
accidents. If you shorten those yellow light times beyond bare minimums,
that's when you start to generate more accidents and more violations."

Problematic cameras
A yellow light in Cary, N.C., had Howard Bond seeing red.

Last year Bond's son was issued two different tickets for turning left
on a red light at an intersection. But when Bond watched videotape of
the alleged traffic offenses, he saw that in both instances his son had
legally turned left on a flashing yellow light. The town had recently
switched to a flashing yellow at the intersection, but Redflex, the
private company running the cameras, kept treating it as a red, Bond
said.

Each time, Bond, who lives in nearby Chatham County, went to the office
that issued the tickets to complain. Each time, he said, his tickets
were dismissed but the larger issue was ignored.

"I just basically stood there and said, 'No sir, you're going to look at
the video,'" Bond told NBC News. But law enforcement officials told him
he would have to attend a hearing to contest it.

"I said 'We're not going through all that,'" Bond said. "He started
hee-hawing around. Then he looked at the video and said, 'This is
wrong.'"

After a local television news station approached town officials with
Bond's tickets, details emerged about tens of other tickets wrongfully
issued in Cary by faulty red light cameras last year. A review of its
red light cameras found that cameras in one intersection had generated
at least 31 false violations, many of which led to $50 tickets.

Town officials told the Raleigh News and Observer that Redflex had
failed to report the error to the town. 

But Jody Ryan, spokesperson for Redflex, said the company took action as
soon as it discovered the wrongful tickets.

"In this situation, changes were made by the Town of Cary to the traffic
light phases without Redflex Traffic Systems, Inc. knowledge," Ryan
said. "Because we were unaware of these changes, our systems triggered a
set of false positives.  Once we were notified of the issue Redflex
either dismissed or refunded all the affected citations on behalf of the
Town of Cary."

While major cities can make millions off red light cameras, in some
contracts red light camera companies keep the majority of funds paid by
violators. Redflex's contract with Cary, for instance, allowed the
company to keep 88 percent of the money generated by red-light camera
tickets in Cary. Between April 2004 and July 2012, ticketed drivers paid
$5.7 million to the company, and $646,000 to the Wake County Public
School System, which received the city's proceeds.

The controversy led town officials to abandon its red-light camera
program altogether.

Cary is one of a number of communities, including large cities such as
Houston, that have recently abandoned their camera programs amid
opposition from residents.

Dollars and cents
About 700 municipalities in the country have cameras. One of the most
prominent companies, Redflex, had about 2,000 cameras in operation
around the nation in 2011, bringing in over $92 million in revenue,
according to its annual report. American Traffic Solutions, another big
player in the industry, reports more than 3,000 road safety systems
installed in the U.S. and Canada, which include red light cameras.

Red light cameras can also pull in big revenues for cities. An
investigation by NBC 4 in Washington, D.C., found the Capitol region
drivers received tickets with at least $18 million dollars in fines in
one year attributable to the cameras. NBC 5 in Dallas found a single
camera in Arlington, Texas, generated $2.5 million over four years.

Communities continue to adopt the technology. In 2011, East Cleveland
residents voted to keep red light cameras. Last year, New Jersey's
Pohatcong Township voted to extend its contract with Arizona-based
American Traffic Solutions.

"The bottom line is that those who oppose cameras are the minority,"
said Charles Territo, spokesperson for American Traffic Solutions. He
added that American Traffic Solutions doesn't issue tickets: a police
officer reviews each image before issuing a violation. According to ATS,
about 50 percent of traffic "events" each year are rejected before a
violation is issued.

"The majority of voters around the country know the dangers of red light
running," Territo said. "Nobody likes to get a ticket, but cameras are
used in a number of places around the country and the world. They're
used to help police officers do their job."

But cameras have faced increasing opposition from drivers who object to
the automated systems for many reasons, including the inability to
confront their accuser in court. Facing pressure from constituents,
local and state politicians in Iowa, Florida, New Jersey and other
states have recently introduced measures to change or end the camera
programs.

Other controversies have raised questions about red light cameras.
Problems with short yellow lights, which may increase the number of
tickets issued, have surfaced in cities from California to Tennessee.
Judges in Baltimore have castigated the city and thrown out tickets
after finding the city had shortened yellow lights below recommended
limits. Last summer, the New Jersey Transportation Department ordered 21
red light programs suspended after finding yellow-light timing issues.
Meanwhile, camera companies have sued, or threatened to sue, cities who
back out of contracts. And they've been investigated for possible
pay-to-play schemes with local governments. 

"They're very aggressive in terms of lobbying for favorable legislation
or favorable court cases," said Bowman of the National Motorists
Association. "It's big business, and there's a lot of money at stake."

Last October, Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel barred Redflex from re-bidding
on the city's red-light camera contract after a Chicago Tribune
investigation found that Redflex company executives and lobbyists had
paid for hotel rooms and spent thousands on entertainment for the city
official overseeing the red light program.

Chicago's red light cameras raised big revenues for the city. Redflex
has operated a red-light program in the city since 2003, generating
about $300 million in fines for the city and $97 million in revenue for
itself. Redflex. Residents in the city have long complained about
discrepancies between yellow light times in the city and its suburbs.

"We authorized an internal investigation and, though the inquiry is not
complete, have learned that some Redflex employees did not meet our own
code of conduct and the standards that the people of the City of Chicago
deserve," said Ryan, Redflex spokesperson, of the Chicago case. "We will
take corrective action and make additional information public."

Automated traffic enforcement companies spend millions persuading local
and state lawmakers to expand programs, using lobbyists, municipal
partners and nonprofits to advance the cause. After spending $1.5
million lobbying Florida lawmakers over four years, American Traffic
Solutions became the main-red light camera supplier in the state,
winning contracts in more than 65 cities.

Territo, the spokesperson for American Traffic Solutions, defended
efforts to expand red light camera programs, which he emphasized are
above all about safety. "Just as opponents of red-light safety cameras
fund efforts to remove cameras, we expend resources on efforts to defend
them," he said.

Recognizing growing opposition to red light enforcement technologies,
companies are looking to new markets. Both Redflex and American Traffic
Solutions have active speed cameras in various markets, though 12 states
have banned the technology. Both companies have also started programs to
enforce rules prohibiting drivers from going around stopped school
buses.

Redflex recently became the nation's largest provider of school bus arm
cameras, which catch drivers who speed past the stop signs that swing
out from the side of school buses. The company has launched 10 pilot
programs in six states.

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net

Reply via email to