Why Israel’s Interceptors Can Stop Syrian Missiles — And Why It Attacked
Anyway
By Noah Shachtman
Wired.com
05.07.13 6:30 AM
http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2013/05/israel-syria-missile-defense/
Israel may have attacked targets in Syria — and risked a wider war — to
stop ballistic missiles from falling into the hands of Islamic
extremists. But current and former Israeli missile defense officials
insist that if Hezbollah militants ever got the Fateh-110 weapons,
Israel could shoot the missiles out of the sky.
“We are now able to cope with all the missiles that are threatening
Israel right now, including the longer-range missiles in Iran and in
Syria,” Arieh Herzog, the former director of the Israel Missile Defense
Organization, tells Danger Room.
Unless, of course, the extremists fired off a whole lot of the weapons
at once.
Israel’s missile defense calculus and the decisions it makes based on
that calculus have repercussions far beyond its own borders. The more
vulnerable Jerusalem feels to indirect fire, the more likely the Israeli
military is to hit missile stockpiles in places like Syria, as they
reportedly did over the weekend. And the more that happens, the higher
the chances that the already gruesome Syrian civil war escalates into a
region-wide — or even global — conflict. (Already, President Obama under
intense pressure to intervene more directly in the conflict.)
Israel’s Iron Dome interceptor system kept hundreds of crude, unguided
rockets from hitting Israeli towns during 2012?s mini-war with Hamas.
After the weekend’s airstrikes on Syria – attacks that the Syrian regime
vowed to avenge – the Israel moved a pair of Iron Dome batteries to its
north, in order to counter the low-tech threat. But Iron Dome would be
useless against the 27 foot-long, Iranian-made Fateh-110s, which can
come crashing down on a targets hundreds of miles away at three and a
half times the speed of sound. The missiles give Hezbollah the ability
to blast Tel Aviv and nearly every other major Israeli city. Oh, and
they might be capable of carrying chemical warheads, too.
Right now, Israel’s missile defenders say they can counter the
Fateh-110s, thanks to a different interceptor system called the Arrow-2.
But that defense, like any defense, is imperfect. (“Rockets and missiles
will hit us,” says Col. Tzvika Haimovitz, who commands the Israeli Air
Force’s active missile defense wing. “My job is to minimize this number,
to minimize the damage.”) And unlike the Iron Dome, the Arrow-2 has
never been tested in combat.
The Arrow has been in the works since the Missile Command era, when
Washington and Jerusalem agreed to co-develop the interceptors as part
of the Reagan administration’s “Star Wars” push. Saddam Hussein’s Scud
missile attacks during the first Gulf War only heightened the need for
some sort of protection. The first Arrow battery went operational at the
turn of the millennium, and was designed to stop Scuds in the final few
seconds before they strike. But it wasn’t until a series of tests in the
mid-2000s in California that upgraded Arrow-2s began to show that they
might be able to handle the job, working with Green Pine phased array
radars to find and detonate against a real Scud-B missile flying in from
nearly 190 miles away.
Further improvements followed: a better ability to discriminate real
weapons from fakes; an upgraded “Super Green Pine” radar; a single,
nationwide system for controlling all of the country’s Arrows;
integration with Iron Dome and with the country’s batteries of Patriot-3
anti-missiles. Today, the system can handle a weapon like the Fateh-110,
Herzog says: “Basically, its range and typical trajectory is quite
similar to the Scud B. The trajectory is similar, the size is similar,
the warhead size is similar. Therefore you can imagine that the system
designed to stop the Scud-B could be able to intercept it.”
Which begs the question: Why chance a broader war in order to stop the
weapons? After the airstrikes, Syria’s cabinet declared that it had a
duty “to defend its people by all available means,” and UN Secretary
General Ban Ki-Moon expressed his “grave concern” over the attacks.
“Israel’s alleged airstrikes in the Damascus region play nicely into the
hands of Assad and the Syrian regime,” Haifa University professor Kais
Firro tells Al Monitor, because the Assad regime can now label the
rebels as tools of the Jewish State. “In fact, they’re celebrating. It’s
exactly what they needed.”
But the worry in Israel is that too many simultaneous attacks —
especially simultaneous attacks from different directions — will
overwhelm the Arrow-2. “It’s quite easy to stop a single point of
threat. Unfortunately, the battlefield situation is more complicated,”
Haimovitz tells Danger Room.
And a single Fateh-110 getting through could have devastating
consequences if it hits a major city. It’s one of the reasons why in its
2006 invasion of Lebanon, the Israeli military immediately targeted
Hezbollah’s missile and rocket launchers, destroying 59 in the first 34
minutes of the war.
“Basically the Fateh 110 is a long-range, guided, accurate rocket with a
big warhead. Therefore it’s a much more important rocket than the others
Hezbollah has. Being accurate, they need to have a much smaller amount
of rockets fired against a single target,” Herzog says.
“Of course, there is a defense and we can intercept them,” he adds. “But
always interception is limited and there are always chances that the
other side will be successful and penetrate the defenses. If they’re
accurate, it’s much more problematic than an [unguided] type of rocket.”
And while Arrow-2?s test record is broadly successful, there have been
glitches along the way, like the 2009 drill that was aborted when a
Super Green Pine radar couldn’t transfer targeting information to an
older model.
A separate system, dubbed Arrow 3, is designed to serve as a kind of a
back-up to — and improvement on — the current interceptors. It aims to
hit a ballistic missile far earlier in its flight, while it’s still
flying through space. An initial stage is designed to to take the
anti-missile past the atmosphere, and then a second stage interceptor
maneuvers to crash into the target.
The first ”exo-atmospheric” test of the Arrow 3 was held in February,
and was promptly proclaimed a success. The U.S. has already invested
nearly $250 million in the new system — part of an estimated $1 billion
sunk by Washington into the overall Arrow project. Israel is expected to
ask for another $680 million for additional Arrow-3 batteries in advance
of an initial deployment that’s set for 2016. And even then, Israel is
unlikely to stop the airstrikes if it sees another missile shipment it
can hit.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net