Why Does Broadband in the U.S. Lag Behind Many Other Countries?
By Jeff Vance
Wired.com
05.07.13 1:57 PM
http://www.wired.com/insights/2013/05/broadband-lag-behind/
Are today’s media conglomerates the railroad robber barons of the first
Gilded Age?
It’s a dirty little secret that U.S. carriers and telcos don’t want you
to know: Networking in this country is terrible. U.S. broadband speeds
lag behind South Korea, Japan, the Netherlands, Denmark, Latvia, and
many others.
The country that is the home of Silicon Valley, which has created so
many computing advances, is also home to a dysfunctional political
system, one that has buckled to the fierce political lobbying largely
responsible for our second-class networks.
In her recent book Captive Audience: The Telecom Industry and Monopoly
Power in the New Gilded Age, Susan Crawford finds numerous parallels
between today’s media conglomerates and the railroad robber barons from
the first Gilded Age. More than 30 years of deregulation and a recent
spate of mergers has been driving up prices for consumers, while
technology is actually making it cheaper for carriers to deliver those
services.
Of course, businesses get hit by the perfect storm of high costs and
sketchy service even harder than consumers. One silver lining is that in
an entrepreneurial economy networking roadblocks inevitably spur
innovation. Businesses are better positioned than consumers to deal with
our underperforming networks because they can lean on dedicated MPLs
lines, Content Delivery Networks and WAN Optimization equipment to help
them overcome the Internet’s limitations. However, these come at a steep
price.
But does it have to be so complicated and expensive? Are business-class
service providers simply taking advantage of the pathetic state of our
public Internet to gouge businesses? Or are they solving real problems,
problems that would exist independent of industry political meddling?
In the coming weeks, I’ll be attending two influential networking trade
shows, Interop and CTIA, to see what ideas networking thought leaders
have for overcoming these problems. One trend I’ve seen percolating for
a few years that I want to check back in on is using the cloud to solve
networking issues.
Actually, this trend isn’t new. Clear back in the dotcom era, plenty of
service providers (ASPs, MSPs, etc.) emerged to tackle complex computing
challenges, delivering their solutions as services. It didn’t pan out in
the dotcom era; the same trend limped along during the early cloud era,
but now real business-class services are being delivered directly from
the cloud, often obviating the need for any end-user-side hardware.
“One thing I’ve always loved about Interop is that you can see the
future of networking now. That may sound like a cliché, but for any
networking challenge you are having, you’ll usually find numerous
solutions,” said Ajit Gupta, CEO of Aryaka Networks. He should know, as
the founder of Speedera Networks (acquired by Akamai for north of $500
million in 2005), Gupta helped pioneer the Content Delivery Network
(CDN) concept.
Now, Gupta believes that the best way to boost the performance of
enterprise-class WANs is to turn to the cloud in order to improve the
Internet – while also pushing down costs in the process.
“At the most basic level, moving data across a network is simple. It’s
just packets. But once you take into account things like QoS, data
caching, data synching, congestion, dropped packets – I could go on and
on – the simple becomes almost mind-bogglingly complex. That’s why
you’ll see all of these complicated, expensive WAN optimization boxes
everywhere. As with so many cloud providers, what we’re trying to do is
abstract complexity, so businesses can shift their focus away from
complicated networking configurations and back to their business goals.
We’ll handle the complicated WAN acceleration part. All you need to do
is set the parameters of the service you want.”
As with so many other cloud service providers, Aryaka intends to
transform complicated business systems into a simple service. This
approach – in theory anyway – drives down costs, making the service
available to the mid-market. Targeting the mid-market is an important
strategic decision. These companies can’t afford expensive, dedicated
hardware, nor can they hire the specialized IT personnel needed to
maintain and manage it.
At Interop, I’ll also meet with Aryaka and a few of its competitors
(Riverbed, Ipanema Technologies, Blue Coat Systems) to see what the
industry consensus is. Is something as complicated as WAN Optimization
really going to be hardware-free in the near term? How will this change
the nature of broadband in coming years?
Looking ahead to CTIA later in the month, I’ll demo 4G LTE handsets to
see if we may just leapfrog over our underperforming wired broadband
networks with such wireless technologies as Muni WiFi, WiMAX and 4G LTE.
In other words, is carrier competition going to improve wireless
broadband while wired broadband continues to underperform in all but a
few lucky markets (Kansas City, Austin, Provo)? Of course, these are
often the same players responsible for many of the ills outlined in
Crawford’s book, so I don’t want to get ahead of myself discussing the
promise of wireless broadband.
A lot of innovated networking technology is hitting the market this
year. Hopefully, industry lobbyists won’t muck it up. Stay tuned.
------------------------
Jeff Vance is a journalist who has been covering tech trends for more
than a dozen years.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net