Broadcasting Bigness Raises Big Questions
By Harry A. Jessell
TVNewsCheck
May 10, 2013 3:00 PM EDT
http://www.tvnewscheck.com/article/67422/broadcasting-bigness-raises-big-questions/format/print
Perry Sook has had a vision. He knows what the broadcasting business
will look like after a few more rounds of station consolidation —
"rolling M&A thunder,'' he calls it.
At the top will be the four broadcast networks and their strings of
owned and operated stations mostly in the major markets — the same as
today, the Nexstar Broadcasting CEO told securities analysts this week
after peering deeply into his crystal ball. But right below them will be
a half dozen mega-groups holding most of the other stations worth
owning, each with a reach of more than 20% of TV homes and up to $3
billion in annual revenue.
Of course, Sook sees Nexstar, which has been an active buyer of late,
among the six. And Sinclair is in there, too. Nobody has been more
aggressive in bidding for stations lately than David Smith's acquisitive
Baltimore operation. Smith seems to know something about the value of TV
stations and their spectrum that nobody else does.
Sook may be right. Hey, he got the whole retrans thing right, didn't he?
The industry is consolidating at what appears to be an accelerating
pace. Looking at last year's TVNewsCheck-BIA/Kelsey Top 30 Station Group
list, I see that two of the groups are gone (Newport and Fisher) and two
others soon will be (Local TV LLC and Allbritton). By this time next
year, I expect several more to be missing.
Consolidation is the nature of business. Scale is a powerful economic
force. As industries mature, the number of players invariably and
naturally shrinks, even as the market grows. At one time, there were
dozens of car manufacturers in the U.S.
In broadcasting, the hot station trading market is being fueled by
sharply rising retrans revenue, cheap money and a permissive government.
Right now, the FCC ownership rules have never been more liberal.
For all practical purposes, there is no national cap. Because the FCC
never updated its rules following the digital transition when most
stations flipped from the VHF to UHF band, a single broadcaster can now
own Big Four affiliates reaching up to 78% of the TV homes. That's 203
stations, one in every market from Boston to Glendive, Mont. Or, if it
starts in New York, it could own 73 stations, one in every market down
to Spokane, Wash.
The FCC's local ownership policies have also loosened up, allowing
groups to double up or even triple up with stations in single markets
through direct ownership in some cases and through contractual
arrangements — SSAs and JSAs — that stop just short of ownership in others.
Outgoing FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski made a run at banning the SSAs
and JSAs, but couldn't bring the proceeding home. I can't predict what
Tom Wheeler will do when he succeeds Genachowski later this year, but I
can't believe broadcast ownership would be high on his agenda.
So, would consolidation to the degree Sook envisions be good thing?
John Hane, one of the more thoughtful communications attorneys in
Washington, makes a good case for it. In a column he wrote for us last
month, he argues that government should not interfere with the national
workings of the marketplace and its tendency toward fewer, bigger companies.
"If independent (non-O&O) broadcasters aren't permitted to achieve a
scale large enough to negotiate effectively with upstream programmers
and downstream distributors you won't long see high-cost, high-quality,
high-value programming available for free to those who choose to opt out
of the pay TV ecosystem," Hane writes.
"It’s much better to have two, three or four strong competitors in each
market, owned by companies that can compete for rational economics in
the upstream and downstream markets, than to have eight or more weak
competitors, few of which can afford to invest in truly local service or
negotiate at arms-length with suppliers and distributors."
Hane is on the mark. The second-tier station groups need bulk to deal
effectively with the networks and cable and satellite operators and,
perhaps, in the not-so-distant future, online and mobile distributors.
But a world where a handful of groups control most of the full-service
TV stations would not be good news for program syndicators and
technology vendors. The bigger groups already have considerable leverage
in the negotiations and it grows with every station they add.
And what about station groups that choose to stay small, and standalone
stations? How do they compete against multiple stations in their markets
belonging to mega-groups with their cost advantages, lucrative retrans
deals and first dibs on the best syndicated programming?
For Washington, the concern is how consolidation impacts viewers. You
would hope that bigger, stronger companies lead to better news, better
public affairs and better entertainment. But those benefits do not
necessarily follow. Consolidation surely hasn't yielded much good in radio.
To a large degree, whether consolidation is good for the public will
depend on who is doing the consolidating. Nexstar and Sinclair don't
have the best reputations for news, but as they get bigger and move into
bigger markets they will have chance to improve their product, to grow
up. Let's hope they do.
Who will be the other consolidators, the other mega-groups? Hearst?
Tribune? Belo? Raycom? Cox? LIN? Scripps? Media General? Gray? Meredith?
We will soon get some idea. Allbritton put its seven ABC affiliates on
the block two weeks ago, and among them is WJLA Washington, a strong
news station in a top 10 market that also happens to be the nation's
capital. Such properties don't come along often.
This offering will smoke out the real broadcasters, those who are not
just playing out the string or looking to sell, but who believe in the
upside of broadcasting and want to be a part of it -- who want to be one
of the Sook six.
Harry A. Jessell is editor of TVNewsCheck. He can be contacted at
973-701-1067 or [email protected]. You can read earlier
columns here.
Copyright 2013 NewsCheckMedia LLC. All rights reserved. This article can
be found online at:
http://www.tvnewscheck.com/article/67422/broadcasting-bigness-raises-big-questions.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net