Blind advocates: Hollywood lobbying threatens deal for accessible books
Disputes between blind groups and content companies could kill copyright
treaty.
by Timothy B. Lee
Ars Technica
May 10 2013, 8:04am CDT
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/05/blind-advocates-hollywood-lobbying-threatens-deal-for-accessible-books/
For the last several years, negotiators at the World Intellectual
Property Organization have been working on a copyright treaty that would
make it easier for blind people to get accessible versions of books,
like well-annotated audio books or large-print editions. But aggressive
lobbying by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), the
Association of American Publishers (AAP), and other US copyright
interests threatens to derail the negotiations, according to several
advocates for the blind who spoke to Ars.
"The main sticking point has been whether to try to use the treaty as a
vehicle for enhancing copyright protections or whether the treaty should
remain clearly focused on carving out an exception to allow works to be
produced in accessible formats for the blind," said Frederic Schroeder,
a blind academic who has represented the National Federation of the
Blind at recent negotiations. "We don't want this treaty to result in
weaker copyright protection or strengthened copyright protection," he
said. The blind community just wants easier access to books.
US rightsholders have other ideas. In a Wednesday phone interview, a
spokesman for the AAP told us that any treaty that enhances access for
blind people must be coupled with provisions that shore up the rights of
copyright holders. His organization has also pushed for additional
restrictions on when non-profit organizations would be allowed to
produce accessible versions of books.
These groups have the ear of the Obama administration, and as a result
the demands of rightsholders have dominated recent rounds of
negotiations. Treaty advocates warn that fights over these provisions
could put the entire treaty into jeopardy.
Spokespeople for the MPAA and the Obama administration declined to
comment for this story.
Two steps forward, three steps back
In principle, the digital revolution should have dramatically improved
blind peoples' access to the world's information. Converting
old-fashioned paper books into accessible formats was an expensive and
labor-intensive process. Not only do digital technologies such as
text-to-speech make it easier to produce accessible editions of books,
but the Internet also makes it easier to share accessible digitized
versions of books across borders.
Unfortunately, copyright law often stands in the way. Legal restrictions
on circumventing digital rights management (DRM) technologies can limit
the accessibility of e-books. And in some countries, libraries and other
non-profits must seek permission from the creator of each work before
producing accessible versions of books in other formats. Getting
permission is a laborious process that, in practice, means that only a
small fraction of available works is ever converted into accessible formats.
Some countries do include copyright exceptions to help blind people. In
the United States, the 1996 Chaffee Amendment allows nonprofits to
produce accessible versions of books. But even in these countries it's
still not legal to share accessible editions of books across
international borders. Accessible books produced in the United States
can't be shared with blind people in New Zealand or South Africa, for
example. As a result it's especially hard for blind people in smaller
countries to get books in accessible formats.
The pending WIPO treaty would change that. It has two core goals that
everyone we talked to supports in principle: requiring countries to
enact an exception for blind people similar to America's Chaffee
Amendment and allowing nonprofit organizations that help blind people to
share accessible works across international borders.
In 2011 the negotiations seemed to be proceeding smoothly. An early
draft was just six pages long and negotiators seemed to close to
reaching a consensus. But then major copyright holders raised concerns
about a provision of that draft that could be interpreted as conflicting
with a legal principle beloved by content companies called the
"three-step test." In a nutshell the three-step test says that
exceptions and limitations to copyright protection shouldn't unduly
interfere with the right of copyright holders to make money from their
works.
"There are some countries that have not signed on to the various
international instruments and don't necessarily recognize the three-step
test as the overarching principle," Frederic Schroeder told us. "And so
from the standpoint of blind people, we want to say whatever a country
is bound to currently as far as copyright protections, we don't want
those to change."
But to Schroeder's exasperation, the three-step test turned into a major
focus of treaty negotiations.
"We tried to paraphrase the three-step test to try to make the rights
holders happy, without alienating the people who didn't want the
three-step test included," Schroeder told us. "The rightsholders said
'that's not good enough. That compromise language could be used to
weaken the three-step test.' Other countries said 'we're not going to
accept the three-step test being imposed in this treaty.'"
According to Schroeder, almost the entirety of a five-day negotiating in
February was focused on this issue, leaving no time to discuss other
provisions.
Commercial availability
Schroeder told us that the next negotiating session, held in April,
focused on another priority of rightsholders: prohibiting the creation
of additional accessible copies if an accessible version of a work is
already "commercially available." In other words, if Barnes & Noble was
selling an audio version of a book, a library could be barred from
creating a text or audio file of the same book to serve its blind patrons.
That sounds reasonable in principle, but Chris Danielsen of the National
Federation of the Blind warned that the requirement could hamper the
production of accessible works. "If I'm a small nonprofit and I can't
produce something in an accessible form that's commercially available,
how do I know if it's commercially available? There's no uniform way of
checking," he said.
He argued that not all accessible works are created equal. For example,
an audiobook is more accessible than a traditional paper book. But to be
truly accessible, an audiobook needs to be annotated with chapter and
section headings for efficient navigation. Most audiobooks don't come
with those annotations out of the box.
"I would argue a work is not accessible unless it's got the navigational
features I need," Danielsen said. "That's where it starts getting
complicated. Am I going to be afraid to take an audio file and mark it
up for fear of violating the commercial availability requirement?"
Compatibility problems could also create headaches, blind advocates say.
For example, an accessible version of a work may only be "commercially
available" on Apple's iOS-only iBooks store. They argue it's
unreasonable to expect blind readers to buy an iPad just to get access
to a particular work.
But Allan Adler, general counsel for the Association of American
Publishers, told us that the commercial availability requirement is
needed to create a market for accessible works. He noted that blind
groups themselves have said that their first choice would be to purchase
accessible works in the commercial marketplace. Without a commercial
availability requirement, he warned, commercial publishers would have
little incentive to introduce accessible works to the market.
"We're trying to make sure the incentives for producers of those works
to build in accessibility aren't disincentivized by a regulatory scheme
that says if you're a disabled person you get the works free,'" he said.
Schroeder disagreed with that analysis. The non-profit organizations
creating accessible works for blind people have extremely limited
resources, he said, and creating accessible versions of books isn't
cheap. So if a work is already available in the commercial marketplace,
"there's no motivation to use limited money to produce it over again"
just to save the modest cost of a commercial copy. In Schroeder's view,
the commercial availability requirement would just create additional
legal headaches for libraries without enhancing the market for
accessible works.
Hollywood throws its weight around
Treaty advocates told us that the Motion Picture Association of America
has become increasingly active in the negotiations in recent months,
pushing for changes similar to those sought by the AAP. Negotiators had
already excluded audiovisual works from the treaty to placate the movie
studios. But to the frustration of treaty advocates, Hollywood has
gotten involved in the negotiations anyway.
"The motion picture lobby have waded into this debate at a high
political level," said Dan Pescod of the Royal National Institute of
Blind People in the United Kingdom. They've been "talking to people in
Congress and elsewhere and encouraging them to block the treaty or put
in a whole lot of references to other treaties or other clauses that
have the effect of making the treaty very difficult to follow and
potentially unworkable for people to follow."
As a result, the treaty has ballooned to 22 pages. "It's a monster. It
has something like 80 bits of square bracketed text, indicating bits of
text that are still not agreed by the negotiators."
Adler agreed the draft text has become a monster, but he placed the
blame primarily on negotiators who he said have tried to weaken
copyright protections. "Member states, particularly the African group,
began loading up the document with all sorts of additional provisions,"
he told us. "There were also a lot of issues that were added about
translations and public performances. There were disputes over how
technological protection measures should be addressed." As negotiations
dragged on, parties raised "many different issues, some of which were
extraneous and unnecessary to achieve the two basic objectives" of the
treaty, he told us.
Reached by phone, a spokesperson for the MPAA pointed us to a recent
article by MPAA Chairman Chris Dodd. In that article, Dodd claims that
"some groups" had advocated "provisions that would establish lower
thresholds for copyright protection and weaken certain means used for
protecting copyright works." But he didn't elaborate on his concerns,
and our MPAA contact wouldn't go into detail either.
When talking with Ars, Schroeder struck a conciliatory tone. "I think
the negotiations are going on in good faith," he said of rightsholders
like the MPAA and AAP. "They've got clout but I don't feel like they're
trying to run roughshod over us or bully us."
Others weren't so charitable. "They're willing to screw all these blind
people because it might have some theoretical policy significance in
some other forum," said Jamie Love, the director of the advocacy group
Knowledge Ecology International. "The Obama administration has been
caving to these guys. The administration doesn't even stand by its own
positions [from previous rounds of negotiation] because Chris Dodd made
a few phone calls."
Time is running out to resolve disagreements over the treaty. A
diplomatic conference in Marrakesh, Morocco in June is slated to
conclude the negotiating process. Both sides expressed concerns that
parties may be too far apart to reach a consensus in time. Disputes over
the three-step test, commercial availability, and other arcane details
of copyright law may be too thorny to resolve in a single meeting. So if
the parties don't come to Marrakesh ready to compromise, blind people
could wind up with no treaty at all.
Reader comments 40
Timothy B. Lee / Timothy covers tech policy for Ars, with a particular
focus on patent and copyright law, privacy, free speech, and open
government. His writing has appeared in Slate, Reason, Wired, and the
New York Times.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net