06.10.2013 04:16 PM
FCC Seeks More Info on Receiver Performance Policy
Comment period extended
Deborah D. McAdams
TVTechnology.com
http://www.tvtechnology.com/news/0086/fcc-seeks-more-info-on-receiver-performance-policy/219784
WASHINGTON —Receiver performance may have spiraled a $3 billion venture
into bankruptcy, but it’s getting nary a peep out of the public. The
Federal Communications Commission has thus far received one comment in a
seven-week period on a white paper suggesting the use of harm-claim
thresholds as a measure of receiver performance. The deadline for the
initial round of comments has now been extended from June 21 to July 22,
with replies due August 7.
“It is the commission's policy… that extensions of time are not
routinely granted. In [this] case, however, we find that extending the
comment and reply comment periods for remarks on the TAC white paper,
its recommendations, and questions posed in the public notice more
broadly on receiver performance, will serve the public interest by
allowing commenters additional time to review the technical contents and
unique policy proposals outlined in the white paper.”
The paper was issued by the FCC’s Technical Advisory Committee in
February. It focuses on defining interference limits as an alternative
to receiver performance standards, which are opposed by the Consumer
Electronics Association. The CEA says performance standards will
escalate the cost of devices. The CEA, along with the National
Association of Broadcasters and the GPS Innovation Alliance requested
the extension. The three lobbies said the white paper has significant
implications across their industries.
“Many of their members are involved in the specification and/or purchase
of reception equipment; others are involved in its design and/or
manufacture,” they wrote in the joint request. “All are vitally
interested in, and their businesses depend upon, the clear reception of
desired signals.”
The methodology described in the white paper involves establishing
signal power levels referred to as “harm-claim thresholds” that one
service would be expected to tolerate from another before filing a claim
of harmful interference.
The commission’s Office of Engineering and Technology asks if the
methodology is a valid approach, if it’s viable for all types of
services across the radio frequency spectrum, and what considerations to
make for various coding and modulation schemes.
The sole comment filed on the docket, No. 13-101, is from James E.
Whedbee, a ham and commercial radio operator in Gladstone, Mo.
“Redefining what constitutes harmful interference may resolve a semantic
conflict, but does nothing to change realities on the ground,” he wrote.
“In point of fact, if existing interference complaints aren’t resolved
and then the subject spectrum is packed with even more competing users,
the commission is effectively diminishing the value of that spectrum and
decreasing likelihood of innovation. Redefining interference, even with
a corresponding improvement in receiver performance, is a dubious
approach to regulating unless the goal is to abrogate regulating
altogether, leaving the competing parties to hash out their differences.”
The subject of receiver standards rose to the level of Congressional
scrutiny following the bankruptcy of LightSquared. The start-ups
proposed LTE network was sunk by GPS receivers in the adjacent band that
were unable to reject the associated interference. LightSquared filed
for bankruptcy in May of 2012. The company is now looking to share
spectrum with federal users.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net