http://techland.time.com/2013/06/24/aol-reader-is-a-slightly-better-slig
htly-worse-version-of-google-reader/

It's a superior version of Google Reader that's missing a few important
features.

What do you want from an RSS app? Bells? Whistles? Extra "features"
(whatever those might be)? RSS's efficacy over the years has been its
simplicity (it technically stands for Rich Site Summary, but the
alternative, Really Simple Syndication, seems more appropriate). It's a
way for people to keep tabs on news sites, blogs and the like without
having to manually scrutinize each one for new content periodically.
When an RSS-enabled website updates, it generates an RSS-specific view
of said update that an RSS tracker can scrape, proactively letting you
know there's something new and possibly of interest - a curated form of
web-pulling.

For years I used Safari's built-in RSS scraper, mostly because if you
dropped RSS links into Safari's Bookmarks bar, it displayed unread RSS
counts beside the bookmarks while keeping the experience inline to the
browser. Decoupling RSS readers from browsers never appealed to me,
though I can understand why snapping the experience out might be
preferable if you like to compartmentalize things or view RSS
aggregation as something that warrants more nuanced organization.

When Apple yanked RSS from Safari 6 last summer, at OS X Mountain Lion's
debut, I forced myself to give Google Reader a shake. It wasn't as
elegant from my vantage, adding steps to my personal consumption
process: You had to first click over to Google Reader's app page, log in
if you weren't already, then poke around using Google's
less-than-graceful navigation layout. That said, Google Reader was
dependable and, importantly, broadly supported: third-party notification
utilities flourished, including a few that almost gave me back the
experience I'd had using Safari. I wasn't smitten - I couldn't bypass
Google Reader's app page in the third-party tools to go straight to the
web link - but satisfied? Sure.

Then Google dropped its own bomb: Google Reader would shutter on July 1,
2013. Why? Because "over the years usage has declined," wrote Google - a
sadly deficient epitaph for an app that probably cost Google little,
resource-wise, to sustain. But there it was, and the app's remaining
user base nonplussed and eventually furious (albeit not enough, it
seems, to push this save Google Reader petition to its required 200,000
signatures).

I considered Feedly, of course, the most visible of the post-Google
Reader readers, but didn't care for its hover/pop-up web interface or,
for me anyway, its superfluous organizational features. I'm an RSS
minimalist: I want unread story counts and linked titles, nothing more.
I don't monitor RSS feeds on my smartphone or tablet and don't care
about rolling my own magazine-like online info-garden. RSS for me is a
transport mechanism, not a destination. (That said, TIME Tech editor
Doug Aamoth thinks highly of Feedly, and it frequently shows up on best
apps lists, including our own.)

I even gave Twitter Lists a shot, but they're still too capricious - too
far behind the information curve for the sort of story-watching I do,
since even the most prominent news sites (including TIME) don't reliably
link website updates to tweets, which might not appear until hours after
whatever story goes up. Many of the more obscure websites I track hardly
use their Twitter accounts, in some cases never bringing a story over.
RSS, however un-hip it seems, remains the only dependable mechanism for
consistently tapping published information flowing from sites in
near-real time.

Which brings me to AOL Reader, AOL's attempt to capitalize on Google
Reader's forced exodus. It's launching today in public beta, and while I
can't name a single AOL product or service I've used in recent years, if
I had to select a browser-specific RSS interface at this point, I'd
probably choose this one.

AOL's take on RSS feels elegant and uncomplicated from the start,
eschewing "features" like Feedly's pop-ups for a static, standard
interface that stacks nested sources in a lefthand column that includes
"Home" and "Starred" views. Feed content appears in the wide center
column, bracketed by a weirdly empty righthand column, apparently
designed to offer symmetric balance to the lefthand one. [Update:
There's apparently supposed to be an advertisement here, but between
AdBlock and ClickToFlash, it's been dutifully scrubbed.]

Color scheme-wise, I prefer AOL Reader's mutable light/dark box tones
and default smaller (and on the left menu, narrower) fonts to Google
Reader's chunkier, less interesting gray/white scheme. The way AOL
Reader divvies up sections also feels cleaner, with a less busy top bar
(just AOL's search box, a few icons and a link to your account info,
versus Google's asymmetric link-bar on top of its search bar and account
buttons on top of the Google Reader area - notably lower than AOL
Reader, which can display more stories on page at once). Yes, I realize
no one uses Google's web apps for their scintillating aesthetic panache,
but AOL Reader's cleaner, tidier layout just illustrates what seems an
increasingly visible creative deficit in Google's visual approach to its
entire suite of web apps.

Another perk: AOL Reader comes laden with keyboard shortcuts just like
Google Reader and Feedly. I don't use shortcuts for web apps in general,
but if you do, AOL has you covered: The settings button - which,
interestingly, lives in the lefthand sidebar - leads to a "shortcuts"
link that pops up a hotkey overlay with dozens of navigation options.

One area AOL Reader falls behind Google Reader: expanding and collapsing
story views. In Google Reader, you just click a story's title to expand
or collapse it. In AOL Reader, you also expand a story by clicking its
title, but clicking the title again does nothing - you have to move the
mouse over to an "X" icon at right to collapse it.

Once a story's open, you can make it a starred item, share it to the
usual social networks and/or email it, or drop in a tag that manifests
as a new sort-by category in the lefthand sidebar. The default "list"
view displays stories as single-line items, but an eye icon that sits
next to the "mark as read" button lets you toggle the view between
cards, full stories (titles and sub-headings) and a pane view that
splits what you're drilling on into two screens, though the latter feels
superfluous, since the full view does this better, and you're seeing
roughly the same number of stories on screen simultaneously in each.

While you can't pull your Google Reader feeds into AOL Reader directly,
AOL provides simple instructions for exporting from Google Reader using
Google Takeout, a process that's as straightforward as this sort of
thing's always been. If you're coming from another RSS reader, AOL lets
you add feeds with search, URLs and OPML files, and organizing feeds is
just as straightforward, whether creating folders, adding tags or just
drag-and-dropping feed names in the stack. Unlike Google Reader, AOL
Reader neither auto-alphabetizes nor offers an alphabetization button;
if you hand-tweak everything, no problem, but if you like to eyeball
your feeds (or folders) in alphabetical order, you'll have to organize
them manually.

What else? AOL Reader won't let you look at all your feeds in a single
date-sorted view, which seems odd. Click the "All" view and you'll see a
list sorted first by feed, then by date, meaning you'll see the last
several days' worth of updates from one source before you see the next
source's items ("sorting by newest first" doesn't fix this). That may be
a deal-breaker for some - I never use the "All" view in RSS readers
myself - though it seems like an obvious and easy problem to solve.

The greater omission, however, is an option to search your feeds. Where
Google Reader's search box lets you comb through everything and sort
results by read items, starred items, recommended items or specific
feeds, AOL Reader's search box lets you search the web and that's it.
Again, it's another feature I never used in Google Reader, since I was
just scanning and relegating "marked as read" stories to the dustbin,
but if you rely on search to find specific stories, this one's a
definite deal-breaker; hopefully AOL addresses these deficiencies soon.

Sidenote: If you're looking for the sort of unadorned, just-the-facts
RSS experience I was and you're running a Mac, consider RSS Bot, a free
app by FIPLAB that sits in OS X's menubar and displays unread feed
counts and stories in a drop-down menu; you click the stuff you want to
read, or mark what you don't want to as read - no fuss, no muss. I've
been using it since Google notified us of Google Reader's demise, and
it's the happiest I've been since Apple scuppered Safari's RSS reader.



Read more:
http://techland.time.com/2013/06/24/aol-reader-is-a-slightly-better-slig
htly-worse-version-of-google-reader/#ixzz2X9oYow2d

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net

Reply via email to