FCC to examine “unauthorized” cell snooping devices
Meanwhile, FCC won't give stingray documents to ACLU, saying they're
classified.
*by Cyrus Farivar**
**Ars Technica**
**
**Aug 12 2014, 2:40pm CST*
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/08/fcc-to-examine-unauthorized-cell-snooping-devices/
*The 15 states in which the ACLU knows that police use cell phone
tracking devices.ACLU
<https://www.aclu.org/maps/stingray-tracking-devices-whos-got-them>*
The Federal Communications Commission said it will investigate the
“illicit and unauthorized use” of cell phone tracking and interception
devices, commonly known as IMSI catchers or stingrays.
A newly published
<http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2014/08/11/feds-to-study-illegal-use-of-spy-gear/> letter
from FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler to Rep. Alan Grayson (D-FL) states
<http://www.scribd.com/doc/236612502/Grayson-Wheeler-Letter> that
Wheeler has created a task force that recently took “immediate steps to
combat the illicit and unauthorized use of IMSI catchers. The mission of
this task force is to develop concrete solutions to protect the cellular
networks systemically from similar unlawful intrusions and interceptions.”
Relatively little is known about how stingrays are used by law
enforcement agencies nationwide, although documents have
surfaced showing how they have been purchased and used in some limited
instances.
<http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/how-florida-cops-went-door-to-door-with-fake-cell-device-to-find-one-man/>
Worse still, cops have lied to courts
<http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/legal-experts-cops-lying-about-cell-tracking-is-a-stupid-thing-to-do/>
about the use of such technology. Not only can stingrays be used to
determine location, but they can also intercept calls and text messages.
Grayson seems primarily concerned with stingray use by criminals,
terrorists, and foreign government agents.
Grayson’s office did not immediately respond to further requests for
comment.
The FCC didn't have much to add, either.
"I don’t have a lot to give you right now," Bartees Cox, an FCC
spokesman, told Ars. "As the announcement was made only yesterday, but
the task force will draw on expertise from across the agency."
“I am disturbed”
Grayson appears to have only been made aware of stingrays recently
<http://grayson.house.gov/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=314:grayson-asks-fcc-to-protect-privacy-of-americans-phone-calls&catid=14&Itemid=141>.
The congressman does not seem to know that the best-known manufacturer
of stingrays, the Harris Corporation, is based in Melbourne,
Florida—just 70 miles from the congressional district that he represents.
Last years, Ars reported on leaked documents showing
<http://arstechnica.com/security/2013/09/the-body-worn-imsi-catcher-for-all-your-covert-phone-snooping-needs/>
the existence of a body-worn stingray. In 2010, Kristin Paget famously
demonstrated
<http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9179959/Hacker_snoops_on_GSM_cell_phones_in_demo>
a homemade device built for just $1,500.
“Americans have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their
communications and in information about where they go and with whom they
communicate,” Grayson wrote to Wheeler on July 2, 2014. “It is extremely
troubling to learn that cellular communications are so poorly secured
and that it is so easy to intercept calls and track people’s phones.
“I am disturbed by reports which suggest that the FCC has long known
about the vulnerabilities in our cellular communications networks
exploited by IMSI catchers and other surveillance technologies.
According to the Associated Press, the FCC licenses to American
companies that manufacture such interception technology.”
Foxes guarding the henhouse
Christopher Soghoian <http://www.dubfire.net>, a technologist with the
American Civil Liberties Union and one of the nation's experts on
stingrays, told Ars that he applauded the FCC task force.
However, he also pointed out on Twitter
<https://twitter.com/csoghoian/status/498934051575980032> that the FCC
partially denied a Freedom of Information Act request filed by the ACLU
to learn more about prior FCC discussion and actions pertaining to
stingrays.
"They're still suppressing public discussion and debate about these
issues and that combination is troubling because what it shows is that
the FCC and many other parts of our government still consider it to be a
secret technology even though graduate students and others have shown
that they can build them themselves," Soghoian said.
"It was a secret 20 years ago; it's not a secret anymore," he continued.
"What's happening is that the government wants to have its cake and eat
it too. It's pretty unrealistic that this thing will remain a secret
forever. Our view is that once you can buy these things online, once
there are PhD dissertations describing the stuff in detail, and once you
can download stuff from the Internet, then it's not a secret anymore,
and the FCC should stop treating it as one."
Stephanie Pell, a professor at the Army Cyber Institute at the West
Point Military Academy told Ars that she believed the task force is a
"positive first step."
"Ultimately, however, a solution that is only focused on further
'outlawing' the unauthorized, unlawful use of the IMSI-catcher
technology is not a strong, or likely successful solution," she said.
"The FCC will need to examine the vulnerabilities in cellular networks
that allow the technology to intercept our communications. Chinese spies
and tech-savvy criminals won't be deterred because their use of the
technology is illegal—they will be deterred and hopefully thwarted if
cellular networks aren't vulnerable to IMSI catchers."
As far as the task force is concerned, Soghoian said he was not aware of
the details of what precisely it would entail. He hoped that it would
include bona fide technical experts who have well-known credentials in
mobile security and privacy.
"If the task force is just NSA, FBI, and the Secret Service, then that's
like asking a group of foxes to guard the henhouse," he said. "Really
what we would hope that the task force would include the Federal Trade
Commission, the Department of Commerce, the National Institute of
Standards and Technology, and agencies that have a more protective
mission with regard to protecting consumers from hackers and other
threats to their privacy. What's clear is that the FCC has known about
these things for 20 years. The only way you will protect members of
Congress, journalists, lawyers, or doctors is through encryption. Any
effort to go after the devices is futile."
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net