Internet by Satellite Is a Space Race With No Winners
*Klint Finley**
**Wired.com **
**
**Date of Publication: 06.12.15. 7:00 am.*
http://www.wired.com/2015/06/elon-musk-space-x-satellite-internet/
SpaceX's Crew Dragon spacecraft undergoing tests.<javascript:;>*SpaceX's
Crew Dragon spacecraft undergoing tests. SpaceX*
*
Another space race is **on.*
On one side: Elon Musk, founder of SpaceX (and Tesla Motors), backed by
Google <http://www.wired.com/2015/01/google-spacex-investment/>. On the
other: Musk’s friend Greg Wyler, founder of OneWeb
<http://www.wired.com/2015/01/greg-wyler-oneweb/>, backed by Virgin
Galactic parent company The Virgin Group and its eccentric billionaire
founder Richard Branson.
The prize: the chance to sell high-speed satellite internet connections
to the billions of people throughout the world who don’t yet have
access—and in the process become a global telecommunications company to
rival giants like Comcast and Verizon. And, in Musk’s mind, the
opportunity to sell internet access to Martian colonists
<http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2015/06/09/elon-musk-mars-spacex/28768361/>,
when the time comes.
Late last month, as first reported by DCInno
<http://dcinno.streetwise.co/2015/06/03/spacex-satellite-details-specs-from-fcc-application/>,
SpaceX filed an application with the Federal Communications Commission
to begin testing such a system. Unfortunately, the idea of cheap,
ubiquitous high-speed satellite Internet may be just as science
fictional as Musks’s dreams of planetary migration.
Sky-High Ambitions
Satellite internet has been around for years, but extreme latency
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latency_%28engineering%29>—the gap in time
between the satellite receiving a request and responding—is a problem,
making it impractical for real-time or near real-time applications such
as online games or teleconferencing tools like Skype. Both Musk and
Wyler plan to eliminate that latency by placing their satellites in
what’s called low Earth orbit
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_Earth_orbit>, which ranges from
roughly 100 to 1,250 miles above Earth. By bringing their satellites
closer to home than other satellites, SpaceX and OneWeb could cut
latency from 500 milliseconds to 20 milliseconds, which is about what
you’d expect from a fiber optic home internet connection in the US.
The catch is the signal from those satellites won’t be able to cover as
much of the planet as satellites in geosynchronous orbit
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geosynchronous_orbit> some 22,000 miles
up. That means the companies will have to launch far more satellites to
make up for the difference. Wyler told /Business Week/
<http://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2015-01-22/the-new-space-race-one-man-s-mission-to-build-a-galactic-internet-i58i2dp6>
earlier this year that OneWeb plans to build a network of around 700
satellites to blanket the earth. Musk, on the other hand, told the
magazine
<http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-01-17/elon-musk-and-spacex-plan-a-space-internet#p2> SpaceX
is planning a network of 4,000 or so.
That may sound ambitious, and it is. But humans have been sending
satellites to space for decades. The real trouble with these plans is
that they could be astronomically expensive.
The prize: the chance to sell high-speed satellite internet connections
to the billions of people throughout the world who don’t yet have access.
Musk and Wyler are far from the first to propose low Earth orbit
constellations as a way to provide high-speed internet. Several
companies launched with that mission in the 1990s, the most famous of
which was Teledesic <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teledesic>, funded by
Bill Gates, early cellular service entrepreneur Craig McCaw, and Saudi
prince Alwaleed bin Talal. The much hyped company planned an
840-satellite constellation but was plagued with setbacks until it
suspended operations in 2002 and relinquished its wireless spectrum
rights to the FCC in 2003
<http://www.satellitetoday.com/publications/st/feature/2003/07/14/teledesic-relinquishes-license/>.
The failure of Teledesic and its contemporaries has left many observers
cynical about the prospects of the latest crop of would-be satellite
providers.
“These large constellations are very inefficient,” says Roger Rusch, a
satellite communications industry analyst. He acknowledges that the
small satellites SpaceX and OneWeb hope to use are less expensive today
than they were in the 1990s, but says they’re still too costly. “They’re
cheaper, but you need 4,000 of them, so they need to be 1,000 times
cheaper,” he says.
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg mentioned the possibility of providing
satellite internet service via the Internet.org initiative—a non-profit
he co-founded to expand internet access throughout the world — is a blog
post <https://www.facebook.com/zuck/posts/10101322049893211> last year.
But he’s already shelved the idea due to its cost, according to /The
Information/
<https://www.theinformation.com/Facebook-Dumps-Secret-Plan-to-Build-Satellite>.
A Matter of Control
Controlling costs is especially important since SpaceX and OneWeb will
be going after people in developing countries, not wealthy entrepreneurs
and executives who want to check their email while vacationing in exotic
locales. That means everything from the subscription cost to the
satellite dishes must be cheap. Plus, Rusch says, both fiber optic
internet connections and wireless mobile data plans are spreading
rapidly throughout the world. It could end up being far cheaper to
connect these billions of unserved people with an old-fashioned wire.
Even if SpaceX and OneWeb can make the pricing work, they’ll have to
contend with the earthbound politics of telecommunications. And that’s
one area where OneWeb has an edge: Wyler owns Teledesic’s old slice of
the wireless spectrum. And Virgin’s Branson says there’s not enough to
go around.
“Greg has the rights, and there isn’t space for another network—like
there physically is not enough space,” he told /Business Week/. “If Elon
wants to get into this area, the logical thing for him would be to tie
up with us, and if I were a betting man, I would say the chances of us
working together rather than separately would be much higher.”
Musk has floated the idea of using laser-based transmission—another
unproven technology—to avoid licensing, though last month’s FCC
application makes no mention of such a scheme.
Internet, Grounded
But if anyone knows the costs of trenching fiber optic pipe and building
satellite networks, it’s Wyler. After selling his first company, a
computer parts outfit called Silent Systems, for $100 million in 1999,
he founded Terracom, an Internet service provider in Rwanda that had to
build much of its own network infrastructure, including fiber optic
pipes and cell towers. After selling that company for $20 million, he
started satellite Internet company O3b <http://www.o3bnetworks.com/> in
2007.
O3b provides Internet service via mid-Earth orbit satellites. By
compromising between low Earth orbit and geosynchonous orbit, the
company is able to provide a reasonable 150 millisecond latency without
the need for hundreds of satellites. But instead of providing service
directly to end users, as SpaceX and WebOne want to do, it sells
connectivity to Internet service providers in places like the Cook
Islands, which in turn provide their customers with service via cellular
networks or fixed line connections.
Wyler, who left O3b last year before working briefly at Google, has some
specific ideas to to deal with costs. He told /BusinessWeek/ that
instead of having every user buy their own dish, he expects them to be
installed in public places like schools and hospitals, which will then
provide WiFi connections.
And as for SpaceX, the company’s entire purpose is to find ways to make
space travel less expensive. It’s possible that Musk and company could
find ways to manufacture and deploy satellites more cheaply than anyone
has ever expected.
The real problem, though, is that it might not be possible to predict
how much the system will cost until it’s too late. “It’s really
difficult to test the concept without building out the network,” says
William Ostrove, an aerospace and defense analyst at the firm Forecase
International <http://www.forecastinternational.com/>. “That’s going to
be extremely expensive.”
Sure, it’s possible that one or both sides in this race will succeed in
creating an affordable satellite Internet service and bringing the
entire world online. But it’s just as likely that they will burn through
billions in a competition that’s as much about astronomical egos as
innovation.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net