Why you should look beyond the first Google result
By Caitlin Dewey The Washington Post
When you go to Google for anything, be it a weather report or a
phone number or an explanation of string theory, you assume that the top
results will always be the very best. Those are, at least, the only ones
you click: Studies suggest it’s a rare, rare Googler who bothers
scrolling past search result No. 5.
But according to a highly critical new paper out from legal scholar
Tim Wu, Harvard Business School professor Michael Luca and data
scientists at Yelp, many of us are totally missing out on the
information that’s most relevant, and critical, to our lives.
They claim, essentially, that Google manipulates local search
results to favor Google products. Meaning that, whenever you search a
restaurant, doctor or local business, Google will show you results from
its empire of sites … even if there are demonstrably better options out
there.
In a statement to The Washington Post, Yelp vice president of public
policy Luther Lowe uses this example: If a parent searches “pediatrician
NYC,” he or she will, in a prominent first-page listing, see the names
of seven pediatricians who happen to have Google+ or Google+ Local
pages. The parent will not, however, see the names of Melissa Varma,
Rebecca Farber or Julissa Baez — three New York pediatricians whom
Google otherwise ranks highly and who have really killer patient ratings
… but on the sites of Google’s competitors.
“The Google organic ranking algorithm does a great job at
identifying helpful content on the Web,” Lowe said. “But it’s sadly not
being deployed in the most common user behavior on Google: local search.”
According to Yelp, from one-third to one-half of all Google searches
are local.
They primarily involve something called the “Local OneBox” the
special, extra-prominent list of seven links that Google displays at the
top of local search results.
Local OneBox takes up a big chunk of first-page real estate,
frequently at the very top of the page, which means people are
disproportionately more likely to click into it than they are into
regular links. Local OneBox also pulls exclusively from Google’s
versions of specialized search sites, such as Google+ Local.
When data scientists from Yelp asked more than 2,500 people to
review the OneBox results, however, they found that users overwhelmingly
clicked pages from other review sites (i.e. TripAdvisor, ZocDoc, Yelp
itself ) over the ones from Google+ Local.
Moreover, Google’s own algorithmic system for rating and ranking the
quality of Web pages called, appropriately, PageRank usually places
Google+ Local results well below those from competitors, Yelp says.
“The fact that Google’s own algorithm would provide better results
suggests that Google is making a strategic choice to display their own
content, rather than choosing results that consumers would prefer,” the
paper claims.
You can actually see this for yourself with a little bit of
intermediate Googling. Try searching a term like “dermatologist” or
“mechanic” or “pancake house” on Google, and check the results. Then
open another tab and search the same thing, but put this parenthetical
at the end: (site: zocdoc.com OR site: yelp.com OR site:
healthgrades.com OR site: tri padvisor.com OR site: plus.goo
gle.com ).
Essentially, the first search shows you Google’s standard results,
with its own reviews given top billing; the second search shows you how
Google’s algorithm actually ranks the quality and relevance of available
reviews within that specific set of sites.
There is, as always, a lot of salt to be had with these findings:
chief among them, the fact that Yelp is competing fiercely against
Google for real estate in the local reviews space and has actually
joined with other reviews sites to lobby E.U. antitrust officials
investigating Google’s search practices. (The majority of the white
paper is actually about regulatory issues, like monopoly and consumer
harm though that’s a little above our pay grade over here.)
On top of that, the Google search algorithm is complicated: It
orders search results according to a wide and ever-changing array of
signals, some or many of which this research may have failed to capture.
Google has, predictably, called the research flawed.
“This isn’t new. Yelp’s been making these arguments to regulators,
and demanding higher placement in search results, for the past five
years,” a Google spokesperson said in a statement. “This latest study is
based on a flawed methodology that focuses on results for just a handful
of cherry-picked queries.”
Even if that’s the case, however which Yelp, of course, disputes
it’s worth taking these types of corporate motivations into account when
you conduct your next Google search. The majority of Internet users will
click the first or second or third link that Google serves up, whatever
it is; but when people are making decisions about their health or their
money or even their next meal, that type of uncritical clicking could
have consequences.
Our advice? Consider scrolling past that Local OneBox, or affixing
some kind of parameters like the above parenthetical to your next
important search. And remember that not even Google or Yelp, or
TripAdvisor or ZocDoc, for that matter, is necessarily looking out 100
percent for you.
--
*================================================ Duane Whittingham -
N9SSN (ARES/RACES, EmComm, Skywarn & Red Cross) (Melrose Park Public
Safety & Homeland Security) http://www.mpdes.org
http://www.radiodude.info ================================================*
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net