People need cable TV to watch most debates. Is that a modern-day poll tax?
By Janell Ross
Washington Post
August 24 at 2:15 PM
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2015/08/24/people-need-cable-tv-to-watch-most-debates-is-that-a-modern-day-poll-tax/
A large share of the presidential primary season debates will not be
aired on over-the-air broadcast networks "free" of charge. In fact, of
the 15 primary season debates, all but five will air on cable TV.
That pattern led Susan Crawford, a Harvard University Law professor, to
question whether there is something terribly wrong here. Crawford
published a piece last week in Medium calling the cable subscription
fees necessary for interested voters to watch the debates in real time.
She also said it amounts to nothing short of a poll tax.
That's a big, bad claim in a country in which poll taxes were deployed
uniformly to keep black and Latino voters away from the polls in the
Deep South and Southwest in the decades before the 1965 Voting Rights
Act. And with opponents of voter ID laws describing fees associated with
obtaining identification needed to vote as the most recent vintage from
this same political vine, any implication that people must pay to
participate in the American democratic process draws attention.
Still, in many ways the comparison is overwrought.
Cable subscription fees and the programming available represents but one
route or method by which Americans can learn about the candidates, their
policy ideas, their temperaments and their talents. Americans can still
read about the candidates, listen to them on the radio and, when the
cable networks make it possible, stream the debates live or in the hours
and days after the event actually takes place. Learning about the
candidates might be an important part of participating in American
democracy, but it's the actual voting that decides who holds elected
office, whose political needs and interests become policy and whose are
ignored.
Poll taxes weren't a matter of inconvenience — some hurdle that people
could clear by other means. They were an instrument of oppression, total
and illegal domination of one group over others. Poll taxes quite
literally impeded the ability of millions of Americans to engage in the
core act of citizenship in a democracy. For some Americans, voting
itself was subject to a tax.
Now, Crawford makes some solid points about cord-cutting and the
ostensibly growing share of the public that does not have cable TV. The
primary process might have brought us candidates not constitutionally
qualified to serve as president (like Deez Nuts).
But just one GOP debate in, the significance of debates is pretty clear.
As experts told me before the debate, no matter how much show happens on
that stage, debates are a major part of American political culture. They
rank among the ways that ordinary Americans who have never been anywhere
near a debate stage evaluate intellectual chops and who should even be
considered for important leadership roles. That's why there's often a
debate for sixth-grade treasurer and multiple debates when you run for
president. Debates matter; and so too does access to them.
CLEVELAND, OH - AUGUST 06: Republican presidential candidate Donald
Trump participates in the first prime-time presidential debate hosted by
FOX News and Facebook at the Quicken Loans Arena August 6, 2015 in
Cleveland, Ohio. The top-ten GOP candidates were selected to participate
in the debate based on their rank in an average of the five most recent
national political polls. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump participates in the first
prime-time presidential debate at the Quicken Loans Arena, Aug. 6, 2015,
in Cleveland. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Those who got to watch the debate in real time could see quickly and
clearly which candidates wilted under pressure or seemed to manage it
well. They could make their own early evaluations before the punditry
really began. Those who didn't have cable subscriptions (or the log-ins
made available to cable subscribers so that they can watch cable
programming online) had to wait for Fox to post the full video. And with
the primary debates arranged between the interested parties — the
Democrats, the Republicans and each of the networks — it's unlikely that
anybody can make CNN or CNBC do things differently. It's totally up to them.
There's no question that this puts some Americans at a distinct
political disadvantage.
But Crawford, the law professor behind the cable poll tax claim, focuses
much of her attention of those who have opted not to subscribe to cable
on frugal principle or some sort of inherent anti-establishment,
mistrustful instinct that runs strong among millennials. Those who can
not afford cable are not a big part of Crawford's equation.
But perhaps they should be. Cable costs are climbing at a rate that far
outpaces other things. The average monthly price of expanded basic
service (the most common package) excluding taxes and fees, increased by
5.1 percent in 2013, to $64.41, according to a May 2014 Federal
Communications Commission analysis. By comparison, the other goods that
make up the Consumer Price Index grew an average of just 1.6 percent.
Still, a quick look at a long-running Gallup survey of technology use in
the United States shows that in 2005, about 68 percent of American
households had cable. In 2013, the same year that that FCC report found
cable rates jumped an average of 5.1. percent, that figure remained
unchanged.
Home Tech Use
That's not to say that no one is cutting the cord. In 2013, it just
hadn't outpaced the share who still subscribed or started doing so. And
all of this probably brings us to the real reason that so many of the
primary debates will appear on subscription cable networks this year.
Cable networks — particularly news networks wrestling with ratings
free-falls — would very much like for people to regard their network as
a near-essential, or at least something for the concerned and informed.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net