Hard-edged look at Steve Jobs
By Steven Zeitchik Tribune Newspapers
NEW YORK — As the man who enabled phones to play music and laptops
to sing, Steve Jobs was beloved in ways few modern executives have been.
When the Apple co-founder died in October 2011, admirers around the
world were so moved they gathered in tearful vigil and created a range
of online and real-world tributes.
The documentary filmmaker Alex Gibney witnessed that sight. But
rather than join the mourners, he had a different reaction: He asked why
one stranger’s death prompted such an outpouring of emotion.
“Why do we idolize Steve Jobs? He didn’t write code, he wasn’t an
engineer, and it certainly wasn’t simply the fact that he made a lot of
money,” said Gibney, explaining both his personal feelings from the time
and his motivations to explore the subject cinematically.
“I didn’t make this film because I said, ‘Let’s look at Steve Jobs’
dark side,’ ” he continued. “It was ‘let’s try to understand something
very simple: Where did all this public grief come from?’ ” The film
is Gibney’s “Steve Jobs: The Man in the Machine.” Arriving in theaters
Friday, it kicks off a mini-season of Apple on U.S. movie screens, with
“Steve Jobs,” Danny Boyle’s dramatization of key moments in the tech
magnate’s life starring Michael Fassbender, coming to theaters a month
later.
Though Gibney may not have consciously set out to expose his
subject’s unsavory side, the question “what made Jobs so embraced by
strangers?” leads him inevitably to “what made Jobs so polarizing to
those who knew him well?”
As Gibney unsparingly shows, the Apple visionary transformed lives
with his relentless commitment to a future filled with cool, populist
technology. He also made a lot of individual lives difficult with that
relentlessness. (It is a subject, incidentally, that will seem
especially timely in light of the furor over Amazon’s treatment of its
employees.)
The engineer who helped create the Mac, Bob Belleville, can be seen
breaking down crying in the movie as he described the toll it took on
his marriage and other aspects of his life. Jobs’ daughter, Lisa
Brennan-Jobs, describes a father remote and lacking in generosity. Jobs’
reaction to a tech blog’s reportage on a new Apple product, meanwhile,
is depicted as a fierce overreaction.
“High-octane individuals like Jobs are not necessarily great
people,” Gibney said. “But as a society, we seem to have made a compact
that if they do great things we should let them off the hook. And that
doesn’t really seem like a good idea.”
Gibney was in his office overlooking the Hudson. The director, who
won an Oscar with his 2007 U.S. torture-centric documentary about Iraq,
“Taxi to the Dark Side,” was surrounded by about a dozen workers staring
intently at their screens. It was a fitting specter for a man who has
cranked out an eclectic mix of in-depth documentaries the way most
people whip up breakfast foods: the wide breadth of the river on one
side, staffers burrowing into the nittygritty on the other. Some of the
screens he and others pored over were, what else, of the Apple variety.
With this film, Gibney is again taking on a much-covered news
subject and finding unexpected angles, as he did in the recent
Scientology investigation “Going Clear,” the WikiLeaks movie “We Steal
Secrets,” the church-scandal documentary “Mea Maxima Culpa,” the Eliot
Spitzer exploration “Client 9” and the Lance Armstrong picture “The
Armstrong Lie,” (in which he found himself forced into a similar shift
in his thinking about an “icon,” this time well into production). All of
these films are essential, forensic investigations into subjects we
thought we knew.
“I’m drawn to these public stories that I think have been
inadequately handled,” said Gibney, whose vocal manner might be
described as thoughtfully declarative. “People make up their minds so
quickly on them, because they’re covered so quickly. I think it’s
important to go back.”
Gibney has been heading in a lot of directions lately. At 61, he has
the energy and prolific streak of a director half his age, tackling
exhaustive topics in a short time.
“Clear” premiered at the Sundance Film Festival in January and then
played on HBO several months later. “Jobs” debuted at SXSW in between
the two. They both followed “Armstrong,” which debuted just 16 months
before “Jobs” — and the same year as “We Steal Secrets.” He has also
found time in the past few years to make movies about the musicians Fela
Kuti and James Brown and a few others too.
“You know that kid in college who could study really fast and still
get an A?” said Sheila Nevins, the HBO documentary czar who has made
many movies with the filmmaker, including “Going Clear.” “That’s Alex.”
Gibney made his first film 25 years ago — “The Ruling Classroom,”
about a school experiment in self-governance that went terribly awry.
Though he followed it up with works about the likes of Jimi Hendrix and
the sexual revolution, he hit his stride in 2005 with the Enron movie
“The Smartest Guys in the Room,” an abuse-of-power story that helped
kick off his current streak of newsy exposes.
Nevins described him as a cool customer in the face of controversy,
a factor that came in handy when the Church of Scientology unleashed its
publicity firepower in the direction of the filmmakers. That both “Jobs”
and “Clear” are fundamentally about peeking under the hood of
institutions with cultish followings is not lost on Gibney.
Apple’s reaction has been more muted than that of the church.
Following a Silicon Valley code of silence, the tech firm made no major
statements, though it cast a long shadow during production; Gibney had
to go to some lengths to secure the participation of credible critics
who knew Jobs well.
That the executive could be a difficult person will not be news to
those familiar with coverage of Apple or who read Walter Isaacson’s
biography shortly after Jobs died. But the film goes further than the
book in isolating some of the ways Jobs could be unstinting while, as a
visual piece, offering a more concentrated punch to the hagiographic myth.
Among the more cringe-worthy stories are those of Lisa Brennan-Jobs’
mother, Chrisann Brennan, as she describes Jobs’ reaction to her
pregnancy — basically, to demonstrate abject anger to her and others in
the room. In “Steve Jobs,” Gibney asks whether the correlation between
genius and difficulty is not only strong but unavoidable.
The director’s starting point — about what made Jobs so liked — does
not yield a singular conclusion. But the director does see Jobs’ power
as coming from what he represented as much as who he was.
“Steve Jobs was a marriage broker between us and these devices; he
understood how to create a connection between us and machines,” Gibney
said. “And he was a performer, an evangelist, really. When you view it
that way, it makes sense that there would be an outpouring of grief, or
that some would say, as (former Oracle CEO) Larry Ellison did, that you
shouldn’t focus on anything bad because it’s important to have heroes
like Steve Jobs.”
Gibney said he realized that his smash-the-idols sensibility may not
be commercially palatable. Mainstream documentary audiences tend to want
investigations of known evils or a confirmation of decided heroes. The
idea of finding that our role models (Jobs) are neither as virtuous as
we thought, nor our villains (Spitzer) as culpable, could be unsettling,
to say the least.
But Gibney wants to keep making films like this, he says, because he
believes they could be a corrective to a culture that, despite all the
media — and perhaps because of all the social media — can be unwilling
to see subjects in shades of gray.
“Our media climate is often all good or all bad, all binary. It’s
this point-counterpoint view we have of the world and certainly of
public figures. It seems so misguided. If we think this way, we’re
either going to be radically misinformed or disappointed.
“I guess that I’m swimming upstream. But you’d hope people would
reckon with these ideas. Shouldn’t we begin making more distinctions?”
[email protected]
--
*================================================ Duane Whittingham -
N9SSN (ARES/RACES, EmComm, Skywarn & Red Cross) (Melrose Park Public
Safety & Homeland Security) http://www.mpdes.org
http://www.radiodude.info ================================================*
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net