Aug 24, 2017 09:24 AM ET Broadband Redlining Complaint Filed Against AT&T
at FCC

Seeks hearing, investigation, damages; AT&T has said it does not redline,
period
<http://www.broadcastingcable.com/users/jeggerton>

By John Eggerton
Broadcasting & Cable

http://www.broadcastingcable.com/news/washington/broadband-redlining-complaint-filed-against-att-fcc/168100


Attorney Daryl Parks has filed a formal FCC complaint against AT&T on
behalf of three African American low-income residents of Cleveland alleging
digital redlining.

The complainants--Joanne Elkins, Hattie Lanfair, and Rochelle Lee--allege
that "wealthier and predominantly white areas have gotten premium
upgradable high speed broadband access at bullet speed," while the three
complainants "receive slow speeds at a rate as low as 1.5 mbps downstream
or less, although they pay AT&T for high speed access."

They say that is unjust and unreasonable discrimination in violation of the
Communications Act. They also allege that is part of a pattern of
discrimination by AT&T nationwide, relying on a study by the National
Digital Inclusion Alliance.

The parties say they met with AT&T in July, which "flatly" denies that it
is redlining, hence the suit. The complaint concedes AT&T offered to expand
a 5G wireless broadband pilot program, but says that is not sufficient.

The FCC's definition of high-speed broadband is 4 Mbps downstream.

Parks and company want the FCC to investigate the charge, including holding
a hearing, which would likely be before the FCC's Administrative Law Judge,
and they want damages.

The complaint is being hand-delivered to the FCC, according to Parks.

Back in May, the broadband access advocates at the National Digital
Inclusion Alliance (NDIA) alleged that AT&T has discriminated
<http://www.multichannel.com/news/broadband/att-accused-digital-red-lining-cleveland/411436>
against low-income Cleveland neighborhoods in deployment of home Internet
and video over a decade.

It said it was basing that "digital redlining" charge on FCC data from June
2016, as well as "city construction permits and other information" that it
says shows  the company "withheld fiber-enhanced broadband improvements
from most Cleveland neighborhoods with high poverty rates – including
Hough, Glenville, Central, Fairfax, South Collinwood, St. Clair-Superior,
Detroit-Shoreway, Stockyards and others."

NDIA said it began the six-month mapping analysis after some residents were
being told they were ineligible for a discount rate program because they
were not getting the minimum 3 Mbps speed needed for the discount.

"The report does not accurately reflect the investment we've made in
bringing faster internet to urban and rural areas across the U.S.," said an
AT&T spokesperson at the time. "While we are investing in broadband, we’re
also investing in technologies that will mitigate some of the
infrastructure limitations.”

An AT&T source speaking on background said that the company had invested
$135 billion on wired and wireless networks between 2012 and 2016,
including nearly $1.5 billion in its Ohio wireless and wired networks in
2013-2015, with more than $325 million of that in Cleveland.

Two weeks later Parks, unpersuaded by AT&T, pledged a multi-front campaign
against the telco and in behalf of Cleveland low-income residents. Parks,
who gained national prominence as the attorney for the families of Trayvon
Martin and Michael Brown, as denied a request to speak at an  AT&T board
meeting about the issue.

"[I] the near future," he said back in MAy, he planned to certify a class
for a class-action suit, bring a formal redlining complaint at the FCC, and
"raise with the nation’s governors the issue of AT&T’s suitability to
manage the emergency communications service FirstNet." That is the
interoperable communications network AT&T has a multibillion-dollar
government grant to provide and manage.

James Meza, AT&T senior vice president and assistant general counsel, said in
a letter to Parks in response
<http://www.multichannel.com/news/telco-tv/attorney-pledges-multi-front-campaign-against-att/413058>
that the company takes the complaint seriously, has invested $135 billion
over the past five years to ensure "Americans of all income levels" can get
internet service, will continue to expand its Ohio networks, and is
promoting broadband adoption by low-income customers.

As to the redlining charge, Meza said AT&T doesn't do it, period.
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net

Reply via email to