Telcos, cable companies face off over TV franchises
By Marguerite Reardon
News.com
http://news.com.com/Telcos%2C+cable+companies+face+off+over+TV+franchises/2100-1034_3-5723368.html
Story last modified Fri May 27 13:34:00 PDT 2005
A conflict in Texas between cable companies and phone companies will come
to a showdown this weekend over a new bill that would allow phone companies
to offer television services without negotiating contracts with local
governments.
The controversial bill, which is being considered by the Texas Senate and
has stirred up lobbyists on both sides of the debate, is now in a Senate
conference committee. The measure's fate will be determined this weekend,
as lawmakers try to bring it to a vote before the legislative session ends,
on May 30.
Earlier this month, the provision, which would grant statewide franchises,
was tacked onto a bill at the last moment in the Texas House of
Representatives. The legislation, which along with the franchise provision
is intended to renew the Texas Public Utility Commission, passed in the
House and is now being considered by the Senate.
If the bill is passed with the contested provision intact, it will have
sweeping implications for the television market in Texas and could be held
up as a model for other states, such as California and New Jersey, which
are considering similar changes to their public utilities laws.
The battle over whether phone companies should be required to get local
franchises to offer TV is critical for SBC Communications and Verizon
Communications as they move forward with their plans to deliver television
service to consumers later this year.
The proposed law is especially important to SBC and Verizon because it
would streamline the franchise process and drastically reduce the time it
would take to roll out service in a particular community.
"We will be able to offer competitive video service to consumers much
faster if we can get a statewide franchise instead of knocking on every
city's door," said Bill Kula, a spokesman for Verizon. "A franchise can
take anywhere between six to 18 months to negotiate. The network itself
only takes about 18 months to build."
Specifically, the bill in Texas would allow Verizon and SBC to apply to the
Public Utility Commission for statewide approval to deliver television
services to cities throughout Texas. The current law requires companies to
negotiate franchise contracts with individual cities.
The cable companies, such as Time Warner, Comcast and Cox Communications,
oppose this approach because, they say, it unfairly favors telephone
companies. For example, under this law cable companies would still be
subject to the old rules for securing local franchises. The cable companies
would also still be required to provide free access channels to communities
and free access to municipal buildings, while the phone companies would not
be required to make either accommodation.
Cable companies also accuse the telephone companies of pursuing statewide
franchises because they don't want to provide access to poorer residents.
They say that Verizon and SBC will build out their networks only in
affluent neighborhoods, a contention the phone companies dispute.
"They are pushing for statewide franchises to get special advantages," said
Morris Wilkes, a spokesman for Cox. "Under this law they would be able to
bypass communities and only build in neighborhoods they want to build in.
They wouldn't be required to provide full service to residents, like we're
required to do."
But the cable companies aren't the only ones in Texas opposed to the bill.
Several cities in Texas believe the new law, if passed, would strip their
authority to regulate and tax new services, costing them much-needed revenue.
"I'm not opposed to the concept of statewide franchises," said Frank
Sturzl, executive director of the Texas Municipal League, a nonprofit that
provides legislative, legal and educational services to cities in the
state. "I have no particular fondness for the cable companies. I'd like to
see good competition as much as anyone, but not at the expense of our cities."
The sentiment is echoed in New Jersey, where similar legislation has not
yet been drafted. The New Jersey State League of Municipalities says it is
working closely with Verizon and state legislators to come up with a bill
for statewide franchises that fits cities' needs. The league's priorities
include collecting taxes and access fees for whatever TV services are
delivered, and free access to community broadcasts.
"If Verizon agrees to giving us everything we ask for, I don't see what the
disadvantage could be to a statewide agreement," said Michael Darcy,
assistant executive director for the New Jersey State League of
Municipalities. "Nobody thinks the negotiation process is a pleasurable
experience. It's time-consuming, and it costs a lot in lawyer fees. I think
if the terms are right, everyone can benefit from a shortened time frame."
While SBC and Verizon are both looking to enter the television market as
quickly as they can, their fundamental strategies for dealing with
franchises are different. Verizon is trying to change state law, while at
the same time seeking local franchises throughout the country. Already it
has six agreements--four in Texas, one in California and one in Florida.
Verizon also is building a new fiber network, which extends directly into
homes. Its initial television offering will use traditional broadcast
technology to offer service.
SBC is not seeking any local franchises. Instead, it is taking the legal
stance that it should not be subject to any franchise laws because the
television service it plans to offer is transmitted over its existing
copper telephone lines using Internet protocol technology.
But opponents say SBC's legal footing is questionable. They argue that the
means of delivery has little to do with how a service should be regulated.
Rather, SBC's TV service should be subject to the same rules that apply to
similar services offered by cable providers. SBC so far seems undaunted.
"Our view is that a more streamlined process is preferred and favors
consumers," said Kevin Belgrade, a spokesman for SBC. "The TV market today
is void of any real competition. Big cable companies have a lock on
consumers, which has resulted in double-digit price increases."
For Verizon, the battle in Texas is especially critical, since if it loses
there it will have to wait two more years before it can introduce a similar
bill to the reconvened state legislature. What's more, Texas is one of the
states where Verizon is furthest along in its deployment of the Fios
fiber-optic network.
It has already completed building the network in eight Texas cities and
expects to start offering television service to residents in Keller, Tex.,
by the end of the year. It also has construction under way in about two
dozen other cities, which it expects to complete next year.
While it has already managed to get four franchise agreements in Texas,
Verizon still has many more to get. And because of the many months it takes
to secure franchise agreements, Verizon says current franchise rules could
seriously delay the rollout of new services.
"We're already lobbying in Washington to take a federal approach to
franchising to replace the labor-intensive city-by-city approach," said
Verizon's Kula. "And we will continue pursuing franchises."
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu
Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_______________________________________________
MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]