The citywide Wi-Fi reality check
By Marguerite Reardon
News.com
http://news.com.com/The+citywide+Wi-Fi+reality+check/2100-7351_3-5722150.html
Story last modified Fri May 27 04:00:00 PDT 2005
Philadelphia is venturing into the Wi-Fi frontier and liking what it sees.
The big question is, will it feel the same way two years from now?
The city's experiment to blanket its 135 square miles with wireless
high-speed Internet access has been hailed by supporters as one of the most
innovative projects in the country. But some experts caution that
significant technical and business issues must be hammered out before
citywide wireless networks can become a reality.
Large cities such as Philadelphia and San Francisco see wireless broadband
technology as a low-cost solution to providing broadband access to
low-income residents.
They also believe that these Wi-Fi networks can help them save millions of
dollars in operational costs by providing broadband connectivity for
public-safety and other agencies within city government. Many believe the
networks will help boost economic development by drawing more people to the
city.
Philadelphia, which plans to have its citywide Wi-Fi network up and running
by summer 2006, is the poster child of the municipal wireless movement.
While several smaller cities, such as Chaska, Minn., have deployed citywide
Wi-Fi, the technology has not yet been tested in large metropolitan areas.
Philadelphia will be the first major city to complete its network. Other
large cities, including New York and San Francisco, are also looking to
build their own Wi-Fi networks.
While supporters applaud Philadelphia for its vision, some experts warn
that deploying Wi-Fi in dense urban areas may not be as easy as it sounds.
"Setting up a citywide network is definitely not as easy as putting up
access points all over the place," said Doug Schremp, chief technology
officer of BTS Partners, a consulting firm that designs and deploys
networks. "There are some technical issues that need to be addressed, and
cities really need to look at the operational and business issues that come
with building and owning their own network."
Building a do-it-yourself network
The idea of municipalities providing broadband service has been catching on
nationwide for the last couple of years, despite pushback from local
telephone and cable providers who view city-owned broadband networks as a
threat to their businesses.
Some cities are digging up streets to run fiber-optic lines directly to
every home and business, which will increase broadband capacities well
beyond those available from cable-modem and DSL service today. But these
networks are very expensive to build, and many communities are looking at
lower-cost, wireless technology instead.
While it would cost about $2,000 to $3,000 per household to run fiber,
wireless can be deployed for about $20 to $25 per household. Philadelphia
has about 590,000 households, according to the 2000 Census. Using that
number, the city figures it will cost roughly $10 to $15 million to reach
every household, according to its business plan.
Wi-Fi uses unlicensed broadcast spectrum, or airwaves, to deliver
high-speed Internet access through a series of antennas positioned on
telephone poles and other locations. Those antennas, in turn, are connected
to the Internet. Depending on its location, each antenna can provide a
coverage area with a radius of about 1,000 feet.
The spectrum crunch
Even though a wireless network can be built relatively inexpensively,
experts say there are many challenges to providing reliable service.
One of the biggest technical issues that cities face in deploying municipal
Wi-Fi is that it can suffer interference from other wireless devices trying
to transmit signals in the same channel. Because wireless networks run on
unregulated spectrum, many devices can interfere with transmission. For
example, microwave ovens, hand-held phones, garage door openers and devices
using Bluetooth applications all use the same 2.4MHz frequency used by
Wi-Fi networks. What's more, thousands of computer users have installed
their own Wi-Fi networks in their homes.
"The 2.4MHz spectrum is already very crowded," said Lindsay Schroth, a
senior analyst at The Yankee Group. "When you have a large deployment such
as Philadelphia also using that spectrum there's a lot of potential for
overcrowding and interference."
Interference is a problem because it can greatly impact performance on the
network by causing packets of transmission data to be dropped. The dropped
packets have to be retransmitted, error rates increase and the routers that
send the packets slow down their transmissions to compensate for the losses.
Cities such as Philadelphia say that they don't believe interference will
be a big problem.
"We did a radio-frequency survey and didn't find any showstoppers," said
Dianah Neff, chief technology officer for the city of Philadelphia. "We
have 430 registered Wi-Finetworks in the city of Philadelphia, and we
didn't find any problems with interference."
BTS Partners' Schremp, whose firm has surveyed Boston for a potential Wi-Fi
network, says he is surprised to hear that Philadelphia hasn't talked about
interference as a potential challenge.
"I know Philadelphia has said they haven't seen any problems with
interference," he said. "But in Boston, we see it everywhere. We've got a
ton of schools and businesses already using Wi-Fi--MIT, Northeastern,
Harvard. We have to be careful if we move forward with this project that a
citywide network won't impact them."
Most experts agree that interference is an issue that needs to be
considered. But they emphasize that every city and every community is
different, and that with proper engineering the network can overcome
potential problems, even in urban areas.
One solution to overcrowding and interference problems could be for cities
to share spectrum that is already available from other sources. Schremp
suggests cities partner with area universities and research institutions
that already have widely deployed Wi-Fi networks so that citizens in the
surrounding neighborhoods can tap into the networks and share bandwidth.
He said that many institutions in Boston are willing to cooperate on such a
project. But once a system has overcome interference problems, the biggest
concern is how to handle network abusers, such as spammers, illegal
file-swappers and people launching virus attacks.
Security and business challenges
In general, operational issues, such as dealing with network abusers, could
become more challenging for cities than the initial task of engineering and
deploying a citywide network, Schremp said.
While most wireless products today offer adequate security to help keep
viruses and attacks on the network to a minimum, managing day-to-day
operations of the network could be daunting for a city that has little
experience running one.
"Building the network is the easy part," Schremp said. "Cities also have to
find a way to fund the operation of the network. That's the piece many
people overlook. If an access point goes out, who will go out at 2 a.m. to
climb the light pole to fix it? How much tech support do you give users?
These are questions all ISPs and telcos have to face."
Cities also face the challenge of developing viable and sustainable
business models. Some cities, such as Philadelphia, plan to sell access to
the network on a wholesale basis to Internet service providers,
telecommunications companies and nonprofit organizations. ISPs and other
providers will handle all billing, marketing, customer service and the
at-home equipment needed to pick up the signals.
But wholesale business models are not without risks. For example, the
quality of the network infrastructure needs to be solid enough for other
service providers to rely on it. And because wireless is relatively
inexpensive to install, at some point it will become more economical for
service providers leasing the city's infrastructure to build their own
Wi-Fi networks.
Then there are cities that would like to provide some or all of the access
to their networks for free. For example, San Francisco, which is still in
the early stages of developing its plans, would like to provide wireless
broadband service for free to all its citizens.
Experts in the industry say that these plans may be a little na�ve.
"The free model is not sustainable," said Amit Paunikar, a software
engineer at Nomadix, a maker of wireless access gateway products. "Someone
has to pay for the construction and operations of the network. I don't
think that a lot of cities get how many issues will come up."
City organizers say they understand that the money will have to come from
somewhere. Many cities are cooperating with local businesses and technology
companies to provide free access in public places. They plan to use
advertising on splash pages and local portals to drive revenue.
San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom "really wants us thinking of new ways of
doing things," said Chris Vein, senior technology advisor in the office of
the mayor of San Francisco. "The goal is to create a service that's free to
all citizens. But I don't know yet how we will do that. Some funding could
come from partnerships or advertising, or some could from taxes. My job is
to figure that out."
To be sure, the challenges of deploying citywide networks have given some
cities pause. Earlier this month, a study group in Pittsburgh, Pa.,
recommended to the city council that the city wait to consider deploying
Wi-Fi until officials have studied deployments in other cities.
"Using Wi-Fi to provide broadband to an entire city is still pretty new,"
said Alex Thomson, a local lawyer who chaired the 25-member committee
examining this issue. "Our thinking was, do we really want to be the guinea
pig? Philadelphia is getting a lot of great press out of this, but we still
have to wait and see if the network really gets built and if it works like
they hope it will."
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu
Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_______________________________________________
MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]