http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/politics/scotus/la-na-scotus29may29,1,663830.story?coll=la-news-politics-supreme_court
High Court to Decide Prickly Cases Soon
By the term's end, the justices are expected to rule on several hot-button
issues, including religion and file sharing.
By David G. Savage
LA Times Staff Writer
May 29, 2005
WASHINGTON � The Supreme Court justices usually leave some of the hardest
cases for the final month of the term, and this year is no different. The
high court is due to decide 29 cases by the end of June, including
nettlesome issues surrounding medical marijuana, the Ten Commandments and
the Internet.
But this year, the term's end could be overshadowed by the retirement of
Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist. Since October, he has been treated for
thyroid cancer. And though his voice has sounded stronger in recent weeks,
he is widely expected to announce soon that he will step down at the end of
the current term.
On Tuesday, the high court will meet to hand down rulings, and it is likely
to issue decisions on one or two days each week for the rest of June. Here
are key issues awaiting decisions:
Ten Commandments � Can government officials prominently display the
biblical commandments at public buildings or in courthouses to demonstrate
the nation's religious heritage? Or does this official display amount to
the government's promotion of religion in violation of the 1st Amendment?
The court will rule on two cases: a Ten Commandments monument outside the
Texas state Capitol and plaques featuring the commandments posted in
Kentucky courthouses (Van Orden vs. Perry; McCreary County vs. ACLU).
Medical marijuana � Can federal agents raid the homes of California
patients who grow marijuana for their own use? Though the medical use of
marijuana is legal in California and nine other states, federal authorities
contend they can override those state laws. The U.S. 9th Circuit Court of
Appeals said the federal officials had exceeded their constitutional power
(Gonzales vs. Raich).
File sharing � Can film studios and record labels go to court to shut down
Internet-based companies that help computer users download free copies of
music and movies? This is a multibillion-dollar question of copyright law.
The movie and record industries contend unchecked Internet piracy threatens
to make copyrights meaningless (MGM vs. Grokster).
Internet access � Must cable and phone companies allow outside firms, such
as Earthlink, to offer broadband Internet service to customers, or may they
instead reserve their lines for their own broadband service? A divided
Federal Communications Commission said cable companies could keep exclusive
control of their lines. If the FCC prevails, it plans to adopt the same
rule for phone companies. The outcome may determine how much choice
consumers will have in Internet access (National Cable and
Telecommunications Assn. vs. Brand X Internet; FCC vs. Brand X).
Property rights � May cities seize private property to make way for
business development? This Connecticut case could limit the government's
power of eminent domain. The Constitution says officials may take
possession of private property for public use, and the homeowners who are
fighting the city of New London say that private development does not
constitute public use (Kelo vs. New London).
Restraining orders � Can the police be sued for failing to enforce a
restraining order? The case before the court involves a mother whose three
daughters were murdered by her estranged husband. During the oral argument
the justices were skeptical of the claim that the police could be held
liable for not acting in time (Castle Rock vs. Gonzales).
Religion in prison � Can Congress require state prisons to make special
accommodations for the religious needs of their inmates? Five years ago, a
bipartisan group of lawmakers won passage of a law to further religious
liberty, but prison officials have opposed it (Cutter vs. Wilkinson).
Juries and race � What should judges do if prosecutors remove several
blacks from the jury pool? The high court has said the Constitution forbids
racial bias in selecting jurors, but justices have struggled on how to
enforce that rule. Two cases raise this issue (Johnson vs. California;
Miller-El vs. Dretke).
Drug research � Can scientists make use of patented drugs and devices while
researching new drugs? A 1984 law exempted such research from charges of
patent infringement, but that law had been read narrowly to cover only
research data to be presented to the Food and Drug Administration.
Scientists at the Scripps Research Institute of La Jolla were hit with a
$15-million judgment for patent infringement (Merck KGaA vs. Integra
Lifesciences).
Cruise ships � Does the federal law that protects disabled Americans from
discrimination apply to passengers who travel on foreign-flagged cruise
ships? This case tests the reach of U.S. law (Spector vs. Norwegian Cruise
Line).
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923 Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu
Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_______________________________________________
MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]