TiVo's trial against EchoStar set to start
Lawsuit involves DVR patent issues

By Joyzelle Davis
Rocky Mountain News

October 10, 2005

http://www.rockymountainnews.com/drmn/technology/article/0,1299,DRMN_49_4145549,00.html


The question of who owns the rights to technology that revolutionized the 
way people watch TV goes to trial this week in a Texas courtroom.

TiVo Inc. alleges that EchoStar Communications Corp., operator of the Dish 
Network satellite- television service, infringed on a patent central to 
digital-video recorders, devices that allow viewers to pause live TV and 
skip commercials.

At stake for Douglas County- based EchoStar are unspecified monetary 
damages and the risk that it might be forced to modify many of its 
receivers. That's if the company is found liable for infringing on TiVo's 
"time warp" patent, which allows viewers to record a program while 
replaying another. For TiVo, which pioneered the DVR technology - only to 
see satellite and cable companies create their own versions - the case 
could set a precedent as to whether it can sue other companies that have 
introduced competing products.

TiVo, founded in 1997, introduced the first DVR as a stand- alone product 
and quickly gained a cult-like following, introducing the term TiVo'd into 
the lexicon. But TiVo sales didn't ignite until it reached a distribution 
deal with a pay-TV service - DirecTV Group - in 2000.

In 1999, EchoStar began offering its own version of a DVR, the first cable 
or satellite provider to do so. EchoStar made the technology a key selling 
point and for several years has offered DVRs free to new customers. More 
than a million EchoStar customers had DVRs by September 2003, beating TiVo 
to that mark by two months.

"EchoStar saw the opportunity and moved quickly," said Adi Kishore, an 
analyst with the Yankee Group. "EchoStar helped solidify the success" of 
bundling a DVR with its service, "which DirecTV and other cable companies 
are now replicating."

Marc Lumpkin, a spokesman for EchoStar, said the company doesn't comment on 
pending litigation.

Jeff Weir, a spokesman for Alviso, Calif.-based TiVo, also declined to 
comment.

EchoStar said in court papers that it didn't infringe on the patent and 
that TiVo's asserted claims are invalid because the invention is "obvious" 
and "not new."

In regulatory filings, EchoStar has said it is not possible to "determine 
the extent of any potential liability or damages" if it loses the case.

Barring a last-minute settlement or postponement, jury selection is set to 
begin Wednesday in U.S. District Judge David Folsom's courtroom. The trial 
is scheduled for Oct. 24.

EchoStar earlier this year filed its own suit against TiVo, claiming TiVo 
and a unit of South Korea's Humax Co. violated its patents related to 
recording and storing TV shows. Those claims aren't part of this trial.

TiVo sold most of its recorders in the past five years through DirecTV, 
EchoStar's largest competitor. But DirecTV today is introducing a $30 
million advertising campaign to promote its own DVR, in an effort to 
distance itself from TiVo.

Of DirecTV's 14.7 million customers, 2.3 million subscribe to TiVo. DirecTV 
pays TiVo a monthly fee of $1.13 per TiVo subscriber and hopes those users 
will switch to its own service.

Cable companies were much slower than satellite providers in introducing 
DVRs, and the models they've offered in recent years are made by Motorola 
and Scientific-Atlanta rather than TiVo.

TiVo hasn't sued anyone other than EchoStar, but the company said in its 
news release announcing the suit that "we've invested in building a 
comprehensive patent portfolio to protect our intellectual property and as 
the DVR category grows, we will be aggressive in protecting those assets."

TiVo, however, has made some inroads into the cable industry. Comcast 
Communications Corp., the largest cable provider in Colorado and the 
nation, in March agreed to offer TiVo services to customers as an option 
next year.

Comcast already offers a DVR to digital cable customers for $9.95 a month 
and will charge customers an additional fee if they choose TiVo.

DVRs store dozens of hours of television programs on a computer hard drive 
rather than tapes, making it easier to record programs and fast-forward 
through commercials. Users also can record an entire season of a show with 
the touch of a button.

DVR use is not widespread. Less than 5 percent of people surveyed last year 
by Forrester Research said they have one in their home.

But those who use DVRs "love them with unbridled passion," wrote Forrester 
analyst John Bernoff in a report issued this year, with half saying the 
devices improved their enjoyment of life. People who have one DVR often buy 
or lease another, and less than 2 percent no longer use their machine, 
according to the survey.


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu


-- 
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.0.344 / Virus Database: 267.11.13/126 - Release Date: 10/9/2005



Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.

_______________________________________________

MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]

To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to