May 06, 2006

Stressed out by satellite taxes

By MECHELE COOPER
Kennebec [ME] Journal Staff Writer

http://kennebecjournal.mainetoday.com/news/local/2706954.shtml


AUGUSTA -- With costs escalating for almost everything to do with daily 
life, Susan Gadberry didn't need to be overcharged $1.50 a month for her 
satellite TV service.

But that's exactly what has been happening to as many as 126,000 satellite 
customers in Maine since the state began taxing satellite services on Oct. 
1, 2005.

Gadberry, who lives in Manchester, said companies such as Dish Network and 
DirecTV have been charging subscribers a 5 percent "service provider tax" 
on their entire bill, instead of applying the tax to only "extended 
services," as required by the new state law.

A basic satellite plan is tax-free, but if customers have an upgraded plan, 
the difference is to be taxed.

"The problem seems to be that the Legislature was not very specific in its 
language about what is taxed and what isn't," Gadberry said Friday. 
"Anything beyond the basic level of service is what is supposed to be 
taxed, but apparently the satellite TV providers are unable to determine 
what that basic level is. I estimate that I've been overcharged $1.50 per 
month, the tax on $30, which is the lowest level of service I could have 
obtained from Dish Network when I signed up for service last September."

State officials have been in contact with the two satellite companies about 
the problem for the past few months, Gadberry said.

In December, after trying to unsuccessfully reach anyone at Dish Network, 
she complained to Eileen Bemis, deputy director of the Maine Revenue Service.

Bemis sent her an e-mail on Jan. 20 that said: "You'll be happy to know 
that I was successful at reaching the appropriate staff at Dish Network to 
straighten them out about the service provider tax. They were very 
understanding and indicated that they intended to refund their customers."

But three months later, Gadberry said Dish Network continues to overcharge 
her -- and, very likely, thousands of other Maine subscribers.

"Perhaps if more subscribers complain to Dish Network and the Maine Revenue 
Service, this problem will be resolved," she said.

Peter Beaulieu, director of the Sales, Fuel and Special Tax Division of 
Maine Revenue Service, said resolving the problem could be more difficult 
than it would seem.

He said it is the responsibility of retailers to remit to the state 
everything they collect in taxes.

If there is an overcharge in taxes, he said, the state would send that 
amount back to the retailers. But first, the retailers would have to show 
proof that they refunded the money to the customer.

And that hasn't happened.

"I'm not certain where we are with Dish Network at this point, but we have 
had some issues in the past with DirecTV," Beaulieu said. "I know 
personally, on my own bill, their basic fee had a price increase, and they 
included that price increase in the tax base. I meant to check on my 
current bill to see if they corrected that or not."

Jerome Stanhope of the Economic Research Division of Maine Revenue Service 
said the tax on satellite TV is an extension of what the state currently 
has for basic cable television service. If a person orders anything over 
the basic package, such as HBO or Showtime, that extra cost is taxable, he 
said.

He said the new satellite service tax is expected to bring the state 
$485,667 in 2006 and $721,562 in 2007.

"All sales and income tax revenue, under the current law, goes to the 
general fund and into a fund for municipal revenue sharing," Stanhope said. 
"So municipalities will benefit from this (tax)."

If Maine Revenue Service is unable to resolve the issue -- get the 
satellite TV companies to understand what the tax applies to, recalculate 
what they should be charging, then give their customers a refund or credit 
-- Beaulieu said he would turn to the Office of the Attorney General to see 
what action the state should take.

He said the satellite TV companies may have misinterpreted the tax, or it 
could be as simple as the software they're using.

Attempts for comment from Dish Network and DirecTV spokespersons were 
unsuccessful Friday.

An Office of the Attorney General spokesperson said it could be a consumer 
protection issue or, if the companies are overcharging sales tax, a 
violation of the Unfair Trade Practices Act.

And while the state has gone about seeking redress from the satellite TV 
providers for Maine consumers, Gadberry worries that may not be enough to 
resolve the issue.

"The only injured party is the thousands of Maine satellite TV customers," 
Gadberry said. "I do believe that the state has tried to get Dish Network 
and DirecTV to stop overcharging the tax. But this is bringing thousands of 
extra dollars a month into state coffers. To the extent that this money is 
not refunded, that represents a windfall to the state."


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu



Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_____________________________

MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to