May 7, 2006

Someone Has to Pay for TV. But Who? And How?

By RANDALL STROSS
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/07/business/yourmoney/07digi.html?_r=1&oref=slogin&pagewanted=print


THEY will take my remote control away only when they pry it from my cold, 
dead hands.

This thought followed my first reading of a patent application for a new 
kind of television set and digital video recorder recently filed by a unit 
of Royal Philips Electronics at the United States Patent and Trademark 
Office. The design appears to threaten the inalienable right to 
channel-surf during commercials or fast-forward through ads in programs 
you've taped.

A second, calmer reading of the patent application revealed that the 
proposed design would uphold the right to avoid commercials, but only for 
those who paid a fee. Those disinclined to pay would be prevented from 
changing channels during commercials. If the viewer tried to circumvent the 
system by recording the program and skipping the ads during playback, the 
new, improved recorder would detect when a commercial segment was being 
displayed and disable the fast-forward button for the duration.

As a business proposition, the concept appears dead on arrival: what 
consumer would voluntarily buy a television designed to charge fees for 
using it? When I spoke last week with Ruud Peters, the executive in charge 
of intellectual property at Philips, to learn how it would be pitched to 
consumers, he explained that the patent application had no connection to 
any Philips products in the pipeline. And, he explained, the notion of 
temporarily crippling the remote control to protect advertising is already 
out there and did not originate with his company.

But limiting remote controls is a possibility that could be realized in a 
new technical standard — M.H.P., for multimedia home standard — that the 
television industry is contemplating for the future. Neither broadcasters 
nor television manufacturers, whose joint cooperation would be necessary, 
have yet to adopt the standard. If the television industry embraced M.H.P., 
broadcasters could insert special signals to immobilize the remote control 
during commercials. If this came to pass, Mr. Peters said the Philips 
technology would "give consumers the freedom of choice" — "freedom" defined 
as exercising the option to pay a fee in order to regain the use of the 
remote control.

Philips's pay-to-surf proposal may be the first of its kind, but we should 
expect to see other ideas that would not have appeared in days past, when 
advertising-based television thrived. Today, the digital video recorder is 
slowly, but surely, tunneling through the television industry's foundation. 
Ten million homes had DVR's in 2005, according to Forrester Research; the 
number is expected to jump to 15 million this year, 30 million next year 
and 42 million in 2010. Scientific-Atlanta, which supplies set-top boxes to 
all the major cable companies, reports that fully half its boxes going out 
today are equipped with DVR's.

What this means for traditional advertising can be divined in data 
collected by TiVo, which has 4.4 million subscribers. Davina Kent, a TiVo 
vice president, said that when its customers watch recorded programs, they 
skip 70 percent of the commercials.

This has not escaped the notice of advertisers. Josh Bernoff, a principal 
analyst at Forrester, predicted that "next year, you'll see significant 
decline in TV ad spending as a result of digital video recorders."

The television industry has not figured out how best to respond. Four years 
ago, Jamie Kellner, then head of the Turner Broadcasting System, remarked 
in an interview in CableWorld magazine that viewers who used DVR's to 
fast-forward past commercials were committing "theft," then a moment later 
described it as "stealing the programming." He did allow trips to the 
bathroom as a noncriminal exemption.

The remarks brought instant criticism outside the industry. But he 
anticipated the adoption curve for DVR's when he said in the same interview 
that broadcasters needed to come up with a "new model" for collecting 
revenue from consumers who used recorders to skip commercials.

CBS OnDemand, which rents commercial-free episodes for a modest fee as low 
as 99 cents, but which must be viewed within 24 hours of downloading to a 
PC, is one experiment. (Those CBS downloads reveal just how much time 
commercials occupy in the traditional broadcast: with commercials stripped 
out, a 60-minute program may run as short as 41 minutes.) The abundant 
network program offerings at iTunes, which cost $1.99 but do not go poof 
after a set time, is a work in progress, too. An industrywide hardware 
standard that could immobilize remote controls, and the related Philips 
pay-to-surf proposal, are also in the mix of possible responses to the 
industry's quandary.

I have not paid close attention to the online offerings of single 
television episodes because my DVR works well and the fast-forward function 
on my remote works very, very well. (The button I've programmed to perform 
a 30-second skip is holding up beautifully, even though it is pressed as 
emphatically as a hospital button connected to a morphine pump.) Why would 
I ever buy what the DVR effortlessly records at no cost? Even if I were to 
feel a twinge of concern that by skipping ads, I am violating an implicit 
contract that Mr. Kellner asserted exists between broadcaster and viewer of 
ad-supported television, I take comfort in the knowledge that no such 
contract exists.

James Boyle, a law professor at Duke University, said that broadcasters 
offer a program knowing that only a fraction of the audience watches the 
commercials. Advertisers, he added, buy nothing more than "an option on a 
probability," and the viewer is no more obligated to watch every commercial 
than a driver is obligated to read every billboard.

The trickiest legal issue posed by DVR's is not ad-skipping, but something 
even more basic: the right to freely make a copy of a program for personal 
use in the first place. My assertion of an inalienable right to 
fast-forward through commercials would be rendered moot if the creators of 
the program that I am racing to rejoin were permitted to fully exercise the 
protections of copyright and impose control over the copying of their 
creative work.

Since the dawn of the videocassette recorder designed for home use in the 
mid-1970's, we have copied copyrighted television programs with impunity, 
enjoying the "fair use" exemption granted for this, a private, 
noncommercial purpose. The legality of home copying based on "fair use" was 
enshrined in a Supreme Court decision, Sony Corporation v. Universal City 
Studios Inc., handed down in 1984.

That decision addressed copying with a Betamax videocassette recorder, and 
it remains the key decision that protects copying with DVR's today. But the 
more one looks at how the court arrived at its decision in the Sony case — 
a 5-to-4 squeaker — and at how recording technology has changed and new 
business opportunities have opened since then, the more difficult it is to 
see how a majority of the court could possibly uphold the same position today.

The courts uphold "fair use" only when it doesn't harm the commercial value 
of the copyrighted work. At the time the suit was brought, skipping ads 
during playback on a clunky tape machine was hardly worth the considerable 
trouble. At the trial, survey data showed that only about 25 percent of 
recorded ads were skipped. In the face of testimony by Fred Rogers of 
"Mister Rogers' Neighborhood" on PBS, who welcomed home copying of his 
program, the movie studios that brought the lawsuit failed to convince the 
judge that VCR copying of televised movies was hurting their business.

WOULD indisputable evidence that DVR's facilitated ad-skipping make a 
difference if the Sony case were decided today? Paul Goldstein, a professor 
at Stanford Law School, thinks that it might. "If you were working with a 
clean slate, and everything was the same except for the ad-skipping rate — 
that's a compelling fact that could have made a difference," he said.

Randal C. Picker, a law professor of the University of Chicago, pointed to 
the commercial availability of network programs at places like iTunes as 
another enormously important change to be considered by the court if a case 
like Sony were litigated today.

How to pay for free television is the overarching but unanswered question, 
Professor Picker said. Speaking as a viewer, he said: "I want the other guy 
to watch advertising. But we can't all not watch."

---------------------
Randall Stross is a historian and author based in Silicon Valley.


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu



Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_____________________________

MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to