Michael,
great expositon, and a good example of what I was thinking about. However
I
am still failing to parse the language used to square with what would be
the
normally understood meaning in the english language. If I may quote your
analysis here and there.
Let me put it this way - New Orleans is a recent example of an
unwitnessed hammer that is considered a fall.
Got it.
In this particular case, nobody directly witnessed the fall or the
damage
being done.
Understood.
if it is a
hammer in the true and accepted sense, then it could be called a
"hammer fall" or "witnessed fall" or "observed fall" or just a "fall"
Having cognitive issues at this juncture. If it isn't witnessed, but it is
considered a 'hammer fall', then how can 'hammer falls', in their
entirity,
be a subset of witnessed or observed falls. Surely the definition of fall
must therefore include unobserved meteorite arrivals (i.e. unobserved
hammer
falls).You cannot have a witnessed unwitnessed event. Well not in my book
anyway. Then again I am not Orwell.
Personally, I think it's bad nomenclature, but I can easily imagine how
this
sort of stuff arises. A few weeks ago after reading some of the many
Sutters
Mill accounts from the field I went for an idle stroll along a deserted
track in rural Ukraine. I noticed in the distance some semilustrous
subspherical objects, and for a while on my approach my imagination was
giving rise to mild tachycardia. On intimate inspection I found some
nicely
dimpled droppings from a deer or something. After recovery from this
crushing disappointment, I thought it would be appropriate to propose a
new
subclass of Leaverite called 'Meteorshite'. However thinking on this now,
all meteorshites would not necessarily be leaverites. A bedouin coming
across the wrong sort of Camel Donga (ok mixing continents here but give
me
some latitude please), might not be thinking leaverite, he might be
thinking
campfire for barbeque.
Regards,
John
----- Original Message -----
From: "Michael Gilmer" <[email protected]>
To: "John Hendry" <[email protected]>
Cc: "Meteorite List" <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 10:09 PM
Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] Hammer fall term (this poor poor horse)
Hi John and List,
Good question. Let me attempt to answer. If I fail, perhaps Capt.
Blood will chime in or another hammerhead will jump to the rescue.
All hammers are falls, because if a hammer falls and nobody is around
to notice it, it will never be discovered....and is therefore not a
hammer or a fall.
Let me put it this way - New Orleans is a recent example of an
unwitnessed hammer that is considered a fall. When the New Orleans
meteorite fell, penetrated the house and left a path of minor
destruction (writing desk, etc), nobody was home. The owners were out
and did not come home to find the cosmic damage until later. In this
particular case, nobody directly witnessed the fall or the damage
being done. If I recall correctly, there were no indirect witnesses
as well - no radar track, no fireball video, no other witnesses on the
ground. The find was determined to be a fall based on - the freshness
of the material found, the testimony of the homeowners, and the
obvious damage caused by this material.
Met Bull states that the New Orleans meteorite is a fall, so it is
therefore a "observed fall" or "witnessed fall" in officially-approved
nomenclature and accepted use amongst the majority of collectors and
dealers. Additionally, some hammerheads may refer to it as a "hammer
fall". Also of note, New Orleans is a single stone fall, therefore
the New Orleans meteorite is a "hammer stone" because it struck a
house and manmade objects.
Under different circumstances, the New Orleans meteorite may have gone
unnoticed and unreported. The lower 9th Ward of New Orleans is
desolate today, as a result of lingering damage from hurricane
Katrina. Large stretches of homes and businesses are vacant and
falling into disrepair. There are squatters, homeless persons, gang
elements, and other transients that reside in the area. The same is
true for other areas of New Orleans to varying degrees. If the stone
had fallen in one of these houses, with no first-hand witnesses, it is
likely to lay undiscovered and be carted off to the landfill when the
city finally bulldozes the property. In such a case, the fall and
damage were never noticed, it is never reported, no material is ever
recovered, and the meteorite is never officially recognized or named.
Also keep in mind, the criteria for officially approving a meteorite
as a "fall" has changed to some degree over the years. Or could say,
the criteria was more rigidly enforced in some publications than
others. There are several cases of witnessed falls where the witness
reports are several years or more removed from recovery of specimens
on the ground. Some fall dates have uncertain dates or just a date
range (summer of 18xx, etc). Some finds could be regarded as falls
and there is some debate or uncertainty around the circumstances (or
find location) that resulted in a fall classification being rejected.
So, what I am getting at in a rambling fashion is this - if it is a
hammer in the true and accepted sense, then it could be called a
"hammer fall" or "witnessed fall" or "observed fall" or just a "fall"
- depending on whether or not the term is being used officially or
just casually.
Best regards,
MikeG
PS - I think this horse is now officially pulverized beyond
recognition. To continue this discussion line any further will
require someone to acquire a new horse for consideration and possible
flogging.
--
-----------------------------------------------------------
Galactic Stone & Ironworks - MikeG
Web: http://www.galactic-stone.com
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/galacticstone
Twitter: http://twitter.com/GalacticStone
RSS: http://www.galactic-stone.com/rss/126516
-----------------------------------------------------------
On 6/14/12, John Hendry <[email protected]> wrote:
Any hammer finds recorded? i.e. there's a big stone in the attic and a
hole
in the roof, but nobody saw it fall.
John
__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus
signature database 7222 (20120614) __________
The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.
http://www.eset.com
______________________________________________
Visit the Archives at
http://www.meteoritecentral.com/mailing-list-archives.html
Meteorite-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
