Educating the press is like singing to a pig -- It wastes your time and only irritates the pig.  Granted when someone of the media ilk wants to know more great, but most of them TV (especially), radio and print want to get a story out (on WHATEVER) and get on with the next thing on their list.  I guess they figure schools and universities are for education and they are there for entertainment.  We like to educate, because that is was we like to do and it does help.  Just don't expect a lot of response to your efforts at least on behalf of the press.  A bit cynical but that has been my experience in dealing with the media over astronomy issues.  If you want to prove my point, work up a "press release", invite the local media folks to a class, hell, serve refreshments and see how many show up.  If I'm wrong, you get to do your deal for a mess of media types, instead of hunting them down one-by-one.
 
From: Howard Wu
Sent: Thursday, August 14, 2003 1:48 PM
Subject: [meteorite-list] Meteorite Wrong from Washington-disinformation?

I recall an Andy Warhol story where he tells that he deliberately gave different biographical information about himself to different reporters so when he met people at New York social parties he would know what magazines they read. :<)
 
However, I agree ethically that we should not be the source of disinformation and support public education. Also knowledge may lead to more real finds. For example, I didn't know till I became involved in collecting that meteors stop "burning" high in the atmosphere before dropping in a terminal velocity decent.
 
Howard Wu

[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

There is also a case for NOT educating the press on the exact ins and outs of meteorite falls, phrases like ‘I burnt my hands’  ‘it set fire to my garden etc’, are excellent ways of distinguishing false falls from potentially genuine ones, as soon as all the press reports sound believable, we will be over whelmed with reports that would end up wasting all our time.


Wait a minute.  Stepping back from it a bit, I find it hard to believe there's a compelling reason for WANTING the press to report falsehoods as truth, no matter what the subject matter of the story.   If we can seriously justify allowing (much less wanting) the press to lie because we've decided that it helps meteorite-hobbysits distinguish between likely reports and unlikely ones, it becomes pretty easy for ANYONE to justify fraud in the press, for any and all convenient reasons that may come along.  Surely that's a direction we want to head AWAY from, not toward....and yes, even if it "ends up wasting our time".

       Gregory


Want to chat instantly with your online friends? Get the FREE Yahoo! Messenger

Reply via email to