Norbert,

Thanx for correction as always.

This does answer reinforce the Mars material late arrival notion? Still too 
complicated is a start... 

Time, time, time...

JD
> Hi Mark, John, and List,
> 
> Since Eric already addressed an error in the first answer regarding 
> the absolute ages of Martian, and lunar meteorites, let me address an 
> error in the second answer:
> 
> > Q: How long have these planetary meteorites been on earth?
> > A: Probably all less than 25,000 years. So we know the rate of finds 
> > from  material found that probably fell in recent times. 1 to 1
> 
> Humm, this isn't true, at least not for several lunar meteorites
> in our collections. More recent studies show that some lunaites
> exhibit remarkably long terrestrial residence ages. For example,
> the terrestrial age for the lunar breccia Dhofar 025 (and pairings, 
> e.g., Dho 301, 304, and 308) is estimated at 500ka (yes, that's
> 500,000 or half-a-million years!). Some Antarctic finds are also
> much, much older than 25ka, such as MAC 88104/88105 that shows a
> terrestrial age of about 200ka. In fact, most lunaites have
> terrestrial ages of 10ka (10,000 years) or more, and only a few
> are thought to have fallen in more or less recent times.
> 
> I'm not sure regarding the Martian meteorites of which at least
> four represent witnessed falls - a fact that raises even more 
> questions...
> 
> All the best,
> Norbert 

______________________________________________
Meteorite-list mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list

Reply via email to