First, let me commiserate with Steve #2 if this gets him down. "Man and
Impact in the Americas" is related to meteorites, though, and is competing
with Rocks from Space for shelf space, is advertised frequently here, has
even been sold in the Inn Suites in Tucson, so a balanced look under the
hood on the list isn't unreasonable!
Hi Eman,
I have three questions for you:
"OK sure Ed is an author and a critical review of his book is fair--....
over what looks like buyers remorse is not fair." (a moral line in the sand)
(1) Were you there or are you intimately familiar with what was promised
when the book was sold?
"...a whiny criticizing of his work..." (a negative characterization)
(2) Have you read the book from cover to cover, or, are you refering to the
late Friday night "attack"? *
"it was you who fired the first volley with your scathing attack" (an
allegation)
(3) Could you kindly review if a prior post provoked the "first" shot or
confirm it really materialized from the ether?
Comments:
For about $25 (?) spent almost a year ago, I disagree with you: NO buyer's
remorse at all! Furthermore, I find it hard to characterize an "attack" as
you have. (Scathing - yes, Attack - no). When buying a meteorite, we have
a certain set of standards. When reading a peer-reviewed article or book,
we have other standards. When buying any monumental self-edited book, we
are buying a pig in a poke (This means we are buying blindly and based on
recommendations, for those not familiar with the expression, it is a general
expression where you might get either a gem or a dud. I am not implying the
book is either).
We know the reader felt severely defrauded by the book, and we know the
reader screwed up in some of the criticism and then was man enough to admit
it. And the author screwed up in some parts of the book and tried to come
clean, too.
I have the book for almost one year, received as a gift from a kind friend.
Unfortunately, I still haven't read it. If I do find some time to go
through it, I would feel qualified to have a public opinion on the content
in this: "duel". Your interpretation is strictly a moral argument on who is
"right" and what the reader "should" do, have you noticed? :-) I suggest
we let this one run its course by itself. The reader already moved on and
had no wish to kiss the author. Have you ever been to Germany? OK, then
you might have seen some fine distinctions between how the the two cultures
hock their wares?
*Ironic, as you have had berserker responses on ocassion, too, after being
fed up by other listees whose posts annoy you. In this case, as scalding as
the opinion may seem, nowhere do I see where the reader was not restricting
his opinions to the merchandise. Unfortunately, in an emotional lapse of
judgement, the author was not so careful. But no moral crusader came forth
to explain to the author the meaning of the reader's post. For example, he
offered a refund provided the book be donated to a library, yet it was clear
to me the first 15 pages (30 sides) had been removed from the book for other
uses...and a donation to a library furthermore would be an implicit approval
of the book - which clearly was not acceptable to the reader. (Yes: Please
donate the Boggy Sogbottom meteorite to the National Museum meteorite
collection and then I will refund your money if you give me the donation
receipt). We are talking about a library in Hamburg, not an Banana Republic
tax write-off. I respect the difference of both duelers.
Best wishes, and Good health,
Doug
----- Original Message -----
From: "Mr EMan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Andreas Gren" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "'E.P. Grondine'"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: <meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 20, 2007 6:16 AM
Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] Dueling Keyboards
....wasHeidelbergensis-Zhamanshin dates
Well... Well.... My take... This looks like a duel
So "duelly" speaking, Andi, it was you who fired the first volley with
your scathing attack with what you later renounced as your mistakes.
Were this a duel you fired into Ed's back before even throwing down the
glove.
Ed, you've already been chastised for your blasphemy and offending the
creationists. Lucky for you they weren't the kind of zealots that put
out the fatwa on Simon Rustie. The only consolation is your stoning
would have been with sky rocks.
You've exchanged volleys now 5 or 6 times and now you've gone back to
the swords since you've run out of ammunition. The only damage you can
wreck upon each other is the indignity of insult--Like the rest of us
really care other than the entertainment value of watching zingers whiz
by our heads and the puffing and huffing after each go-round.
OK sure Ed is an author and a critical review of his book is fair--a
whiny criticizing of his work over what looks like buyers remorse is
not fair. Frankly, it has become a personal attack and the gentleman in
you should either kiss and make up or choose other weapons so long as
it is taken to the meteorite noise list which is set up to handle
duels.
Gentlemen, I(We) Thank You for your attention in this matter.
Eman
______________________________________________
http://www.meteoritecentral.com
Meteorite-list mailing list
Meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
______________________________________________
http://www.meteoritecentral.com
Meteorite-list mailing list
Meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
