Hey, I'm working with Mike Kaply on microformat support in Firefox 3,
and I would love to get feedback from this group on the user
interface design.
To answer a few questions that have been raised in this thread:
if you could tell me the correct
place to let the Mozilla folks know about this - they should be
careful about changing the cursor for a microformat - sometimes an
hCard, for example, will be the whole page
Yeah, Mike Kaply and I have been thinking about edge cases like
this. One possible solution would be to create some heuristics for
determining if a microformatted content area is too large to change
the cursor, and also provide a way for Web sites to directly control
if the cursor changes or doesn't change.
I'm still waiting for someone to come up with the
"perfect" microformats UI.
Changing the cursor isn't perfect, but it is the only way for the
browser to provide a visual cue of contextual action without directly
modifying the page itself, which is why this is the best solution I
have heard so far.
I think there are a few things we could do to improve the interface
further include outlining the microformatted content on hover
(Operator 0.7 and later tried this), and possibly flashing the
microformatted content areas on page load. I also like the user
interface for viewing tagged sections of images on Flickr: http://
flickr.com/photos/titanium-white/379894665/
If an on-hover cursor change could indicate microformats for mouse-
users, how might keyboard access to microformats work?
We will need to provide a keyboard interface in secondary UI for
accessibility. Overall, microformats are great for accessibility due
to the number of steps they eliminate for tasks like adding something
to your calendar.
The cursor thing could be in addition to other ways (that don't
exhibit MMN) of getting at Microformats.
The cursor change isn't technically mystery meat navigation, since
you can hopefully see what you are hovering over, and the icon of the
application that is going to launch is appended to the cursor.
However, I have heard this UI compared to a mid 1990s adventure game :)
We will likely have some type of interface to view all of the
microformatted content on the page, but we haven't decided on what.
A rather comprehensive list of various options is here:
http://wiki.mozilla.org/Microformats/UE/ideas
I hope that the Operator will show the Firefox crew that
Microformats isn't clitter.
The creator of Operator, Mike Kaply is also writing the microformat
implementation for Firefox 3, so technically "Operator" and "the
Firefox crew" are the same person.
In terms of clutter, the right side of the location bar is quickly
turning into the equivalent of the Windows system tray: the random
place where you stick your extra stuff (locks and RSS icons and
microformat icons, etc). As we start to rethink the overall browser
UI, we will hopefully find a better place to put these types of
notifications.
only if the users don't use it it becomes clutter
If the user is viewing a page with microformats and RSS through a
secure connection, they will have a yellow location bar containing a
favicon, lock icon, feed icon, and microformat icon. We are worried
that this is too much visual clutter. Options include things like
merging the feed icon and microformat icon, taking security UI out of
the location bar, moving some of these things to secondary UI, etc.
what would clutter Firefox is when it intrudes into my webpage
In a lot of cases it is easier to directly interact with information
in the page than it is to find it in a menu somewhere. For instance,
if you want to map a single item in a list of 100 items, you don't
want to do a visual scan for the same item in a menu, you just want
to click on it.
We are of course going to allow Web sites to provide their own UI for
interacting with microformats as well, but I personally think we
should provide a good default interface.
Discussion of microformat support in Firefox 3 in the Mozilla
community is going on here: http://groups.google.com/group/
mozilla.dev.apps.firefox/browse_frm/thread/19660ddf0589e15e/
d600f125dcc8b845#d600f125dcc8b845
-Alex
On Jun 5, 2007, at 1:24 PM, Pelle W wrote:
On 6/5/07, Montgomery, Mike <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
I like the idea of an icon that is activated when microformat
content is
available as mentioned by Paul. It would provide an immediate visual
cue that information is available without direct user interaction
such
as having to hover of content or right-clicking. It would also
provide
a way to indicate information that may be hidden on the page. I
picture
it being similar to the RSS feed icon. Maybe it is something that
also
appears in the address bar.
I also agree with Mike, Paul and others here. I read that someone
raised the question about keyboard navigation and the only real
solution to that problem I think would be to lift microformats out
of the actual webpage and into the the browser UI.
Mike Kaply wrote:
I'm considering experimenting with putting a microformats icon on the
URL bar similar to the RSS icon, but that would be Operator only. The
Firefox folks specifically don't want to clutter up that bar.
That would be the absolutely best solution - I hope that the
Operator will show the Firefox crew that Microformats isn't clitter.
Mike Kaply wrote:
The basic problem with Firefox is that they don't want to clutter
the UI
with something that might not be used a lot (this is a statement
about
all microformats in the UI)
What they referrer to here is whether the users will actually use
the microformats and not if the developers will support it - right?
Because if the developers don't support it it won't clutter the UI
- only if the users don't use it it becomes clutter.
I personally think that microformats support would be more popular
than RSS-support. The latter has only been adopted by some people
and have a bit of a learning curve - a microformat almost doesn't
have a learning curve because it is information in a way we've all
already worked with.
I personally would say that what would clutter Firefox is when it
intrudes into my webpage. What wouldn't clutter Firefox is a
friendly notification of the presence of some hidden data.
/ Pelle
_______________________________________________
microformats-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://microformats.org/mailman/listinfo/microformats-discuss
_______________________________________________
microformats-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://microformats.org/mailman/listinfo/microformats-discuss
