Hello Charles... On Thu, 2007-08-23 at 13:24 -0700, Charles Iliya Krempeaux wrote: > Hello Martin, > > On 8/23/07, Martin McEvoy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > [...] > > > > Just because you can identify someone (or some group) by a phone > > > number doesn't make that their "name". > > > > > > It's like... you can identify someone by their SIN (... or Social > > > Security # in the USA)... but that does NOT make that their name. And > > > thus you would NOT put a "fn" on that. > > > > FN [1] represents the name of the object not a person so to speak > > > > so the use of fn in Andys example is fair use I would say. > > In the example we had, as I understood it, this is a telephone number > of a person or a company. > > So... the "object" is either a person or a company.
so you dont think the telephone number is the object ? I see your example http://enumquery.com/lookup?e164=%2B43+780+004711 could be marked up as <div class="vcard"> <h2>ENUM lookup results for <span class="fn"><span class="adr tel">+43 780 004711</span></span></h2> email:mailto <a class="email" href="mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]"> mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] </a> sip <a class="url" href="sip:[EMAIL PROTECTED]"> sip:[EMAIL PROTECTED] </a> web:http <a class="url" href="http://q.nemox.net/";> http://q.nemox.net/ </a> </div> > > And given that, I would say that it isn't "fair" to apply the "fn" to > the telephone number, since it is NOT the name of a person or object. I understand you Charles it doesn't seem appropriate to use fn in this way but the telephone number here does not represent a person does it? it seems to be many people or an organisation. > > I do understand what you are saying... that the telephone number if > the object (and not a person or a company)... but I don't think that > is what the website that that came from is shooting for. Correct me > if I'm wrong though... but seems that the number is suppose to belong > to some person or company. > > > See ya > Thanks Martin _______________________________________________ microformats-discuss mailing list microformats-discuss@microformats.org http://microformats.org/mailman/listinfo/microformats-discuss
