Yes, it would. At that point, it really would become something greater than a matter of personal liberty, as it infringed in a substantial way on the lives and liberties of others.
On Fri, Oct 30, 2009 at 1:27 PM, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > > A reply to the series of posts by Chris and Ornamentalmind, my two > favorite independents, on the "nanny state" you both so vociferously > protest .... > > Liberties need to be cherished because they are limited, though in > actuality we have far more liberties today than at any time in past > history. Granted, in that past you may have been able to live the way > you wanted but that was only because certain behaviors were not > recognized as dangerous, expensive, exploitative, and stepping on > others' rights and liberties. > > The state has a certain interest in each and every one of us which is > defined in public law and policy and when conflicts arise between a > state's interest and the Constitution, the U.S. Supreme Court rules on > it. Rather than try to paraphrase it, I'll simply copy the entry from > West's Encyclopedia of American Law. I don't know what the citation > would be in other nations but it is likely very similar. I doubt > anyone would deny that the state has an interest in each and every one > of its citizens. > > ======= > > "State interest" is a broad term for any matter of public concern that > is addressed by a government in law or policy. > > State legislatures pass laws to address matters of public interest and > concern. A law that sets speed limits on public highways expresses an > interest in protecting public safety. A statute that requires high > school students to pass competency examinations before being allowed > to graduate advances the state's interest in having an educated > citizenry. > > Although the state may have a legitimate interest in public safety, > public health, or an array of other issues, a law that advances a > state interest may also intrude on important constitutional rights. > The U.S. Supreme Court has devised standards of review that govern how > a state interest will be constitutionally evaluated. > > When a law affects a constitutionally protected interest, the law must > meet the Rational Basis Test. This test requires that the law be > rationally related to a legitimate state interest. For example, a > state law that prohibits a person from selling insurance without a > license deprives people of their right to make contracts freely. Yet > the law will be upheld because it is a rational means of advancing the > state interest in protecting persons from fraudulent or unscrupulous > insurance agents. Most laws that are challenged on this basis are > upheld, as there is usually some type of reasonable relation between > the state interest and the way the law seeks to advance that interest. > > When a law or policy affects a fundamental constitutional right, such > as the right to vote or the right to privacy, the Strict Scrutiny test > will be applied. This test requires the state to advance a compelling > state interest to justify the law or policy. Strict scrutiny places a > heavy burden on the state. For example, in Roe v. wade, 410 U.S. 113, > 93 S. Ct. 705, 35 L. Ed. 2d 147 (1973), the state interest in > protecting unborn children was not compelling enough to overcome a > woman's right to privacy. When the state interest is not sufficiently > compelling, the law is struck down as unconstitutional. > > West's Encyclopedia of American Law. > http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/State+Interest > > ========= > > While on occasion and at times too frequently the state oversteps its > bounds in these matters, the place to turn for redress of any injury > sustained as a result of an imposed state interest is a court of > law. > > Regarding your final statement that cigarette smoking kills 350,000 > babies a year is ludicrous, if that number could be proven would that > change your position at all? > > On Oct 30, 5:20 am, Chris Jenkins <[email protected]> wrote: > > What pisses me off is this nanny state sense that government needs to > tell > > me how to live in order to be healthy. One can lead a perfectly sedentary > > lifestyle filled with high fat and cholesterol foods, and this is not > > regulated, while every bit as dangerous as a smoking habit. I cherish my > > liberties, even those which may cause me some personal harm. I choose to > > drink alcohol, smoke cigarettes, and engage in other lifestyle choices as > > old as humanity. This is my right. I accept that there is a risk > involved. I > > don't need government intervention in my personal choices, and I resent > the > > endless barrage of messages trying to tell me why it's a good idea. The > > taxation schemes disproportionately punish the poor, (regressively, I > > believe Orn would note). The propaganda campaigns use figures so > ridiculous > > it insults my intelligence ("Cigarettes kill 350,000 babies a year! > > BABIES!!!!"). It's ludicrous. > > > > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
