Gruff, even though you are using a fallacy here, argument by question,
I will respond to your implied tenets.

“…Let me ask whether we should we disband all our military in times of
peace (should they ever actually occur?) by example…” – gruff

Yes.

“…What if we had no standing army on September 11, 2001?...” – gruff

The USA would have not killed countless people for no reason and had
thousands of its sons and daughters killed for no reason. Also, the US
would not be trillions of dollars in debt nor would it be reliant on
China as it’s banker. In other words, ‘we’ would be much better off.

“…Likely there would have been a series of similar attacks against us
on our own soil, as well as on other nations around the world with no
military to prevent it….” – gruff

This tenet of yours is right out of the neo-con playbook. I have given
examples of similar use of fear mongering by governments over the
centuries, in particular, the Nazi leaders a while back.


[Goering] “Oh, that is all well and good, but, voice or no voice, the
people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is
easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and
denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country
to danger. It works the same way in any country.”

The existence of a standing army did nothing to prevent 9/11 nor did
it have anything to do with preventing further attacks here. So few
ignore that fact that ‘we’ knew of the existence of the perpetrators
long before they implemented their acts and we HAD a standing army at
the time!

“…If we disbanded our military how long do you think it would be
before Iran or North Korea began to lay waste to our nations?...”
gruff

I think that Iran would not be so inclined if ‘we’ hadn’t been messing
with their country. So if anything, having a military along with
today’s Bush Doctrine created the Iran view.

North Korea, if one follows the history of that region, can be
analyzed quite similarly. So, again, my response to your question
(again, which is not an argument) is that North Korea wouldn’t even
exist as a separate state if the US had not had a standing army and,
as a result, would pose no threat at all of ‘laying waste’ either to
our or other nations.

“…How would we have responded?...” - gruff

We wouldn’t have needed to respond. QED

“…Do you think we could assemble a military, trained them, equipped
them and deployed them fast enough to prevent further attacks, repel
actual attacks or retaliate?...” – gruff

Again, it was the US global military industrial complex that brought
about all of your examples gruff. So, there would have been nothing to
do if ‘we’ hadn’t had a standing army. And, again, since we HAD a
standing army and were still ‘attacked’ there is no guarantee of
prevention, in the past or the future. Also, it was the very existence
of having a world-wide military, bases in about 86 countries at last
count, that attracts this type of thing.

“… But the truth is, there are a lot of whacked out people, leaders
and nations left in the world which would love nothing better than for
the developed nations of the world to lay down their military forces…”
– gruff

Yes, and for good reason! ‘We’ were glad when the USSR laid down their
military. I’m sure other countries would have preferred that Bush
hadn’t talked to god about the use of military forces too. Talk about
‘whacked out people, leaders and nations’!!!


On Oct 30, 10:36 am, gruff <[email protected]> wrote:
> "... On Oct 30, 6:50 am, Chris Jenkins <[email protected]>
> wrote: ..."
>
> > The founding fathers were certainly against having a standing army in times
> > of peace, so you're not far off the mark there.
>
> I can't let this go unchallenged.  While the FFs may have been against
> having a standing army in times of peace, that was then and this is
> now.
>
> Let me ask whether we should we disband all our military in times of
> peace (should they ever actually occur?) by example.  What if we had
> no standing army on September 11, 2001?  Likely there would have been
> a series of similar attacks against us on our own soil, as well as on
> other nations around the world with no military to prevent it.  If we
> disbanded our military how long do you think it would be before Iran
> or North Korea began to lay waste to our nations?  How would we have
> responded?  Do you think we could assemble a military, trained them,
> equipped them and deployed them fast enough to prevent further
> attacks, repel actual attacks or retaliate?
>
> Believe me, I am as much against a military force as anyone.  It
> disgusts me that we need such forces in what we consider our modern
> times.  But the truth is, there are a lot of whacked out people,
> leaders and nations left in the world which would love nothing better
> than for the developed nations of the world to lay down their military
> forces.
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to