All of the following are from the same link, http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/19961223.htm
In most of these words of Noam’s, I hear Neil’s words being echoed. “…Personally, I have no confidence in my own views about the "right way," and am unimpressed with the confident pronouncements of others, including good friends. I feel that far too little is understood to be able to say very much with any confidence…” – Noam Chomsky “…I tend to agree that anarchism is formless and utopian, though hardly more so than the inane doctrines of neoliberalism, Marxism- Leninism, and other ideologies that have appealed to the powerful and their intellectual servants over the years, for reasons that are all too easy to explain. The reason for the general formlessness and intellectual vacuity (often disguised in big words, but that is again in the self-interest of intellectuals) is that we do not understand very much about complex systems, such as human societies; and have only intuitions of limited validity as to the ways they should be reshaped and constructed…” – Noam Chomsky “…What would be the consequences of democratic decision-making? The answers are unknown. We would have to learn by trial. Let's try it and find out…” – Noam Chomsky “…My feeling, based in part on personal experience in this case, is that a decent education should seek to provide a thread along which a person will travel in his or her own way; good teaching is more a matter of providing water for a plant, to enable it to grow under its own powers, than of filling a vessel with water (highly unoriginal thoughts I should add, paraphrased from writings of the Enlightenment and classical liberalism). These are general principles, which I think are generally valid. How they apply in particular circumstances has to be evaluated case by case, with due humility, and recognition of how little we really understand…” – Noam Chomsky On Nov 3, 6:48 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > “…Don't get carried away with definition Orn - the constant scepticism > of institutions becomes the institution of constant scepticism if we > aren't careful….” – archy > > IF one wishes to find ‘security’ by giving up rights, perhaps archy. > On the other hand, an ongoing cycle of questioning institutions, > removal of those not justified…peace, then the questioning again seems > to be the active and vigilant process – not one that kills the spirit > as institutionalization does. > > “…We are finding deep biologies of consensus amongst animals and no > doubt we are all doing our 'waggle dances'…” – archy > > In the current case, I hope more for an analogy of the democratic > decision making process of animals…thinking of the one of birds at the > moment. When one more than 50% decide to change course, the entire > flock does. There is a revolution rising. > > “… My own guess on this is that it works institutionally and that > groupthink is a key to the madness of our politics. …” – archy > > http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtepuyvsGbg&feature=related > > “… Many people, quite rightly on history, think anarchy is just the > rule of the beast…” - archy > > http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TLD3Z6sJWA > > “…My own view is that we should generally have some grok of what we > want to build before we tear stuff down - though this isn't more than > a rule-of-thumb…” – archy > > Then you and Chomsky are at odds. > > “…We may all be capable to some sort of polite pretence on anarchy > Orn. Underlying this phoney crud (from which many make money) is a > biological institution that we need to understand and be able to > control…” – archy > > In a word, bollocks…and as many as Slip has too! Everyone with an > ounce of independence who is not fully in the trance of the moment > questions at the very least specific actions of institutions. Often > this goes deeper to the institution itself. Everything from a monarchy > to a theocracy is questioned. The ‘polite pretence’ is using words to > influence and drone a populous to sleep. > > “…The first questions for anarchy might well lie in what it is we want > to build, which suggests anarchy as a tool in thought, not a way to > be…” – archy > > What is built and continually being built is the ‘norm’ in any > society. What is required to retain any sort of rights and actual > democracy is not only some quickly muffled criticism but actions that > refresh the entrenched. Only in this way can we all be saved from our > own lassitude when it comes to looking to social structures for > solace. Of course, if one uses the drone as a model, this is all > wrong. > > On Nov 3, 3:57 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > LOL Slip - though I remind everyone this handle is in respect to my > > Uncle Archy (pub pianist) and the Italian guy who made steam pigeon > > toys for kids in 2500 BC and possibly the thought of having a cup of > > tea with them (une tasse de the - archy-tasse) or at least something > > that fits in cups. > > > Don't get carried away with definition Orn - the constant scepticism > > of institutions becomes the institution of constant scepticism if we > > aren't careful. Once you and Gruff have put enough rubber on the road > > it becomes pretty clear the differences still have a rubber base. We > > are finding deep biologies of consensus amongst animals and no doubt > > we are all doing our 'waggle dances'. > > > There is a fairly deep theory developed from Melanie Klein and Freud's > > 'Civilization and Its Discontents' (more or less - it's small book, my > > eyes fade on the exact title). The suggestion here is that we should > > opt for a "depressive position" in life (it's a bit of a mess, we > > should cut our cloth etc.) but end up in the "paranoid-schizoid" > > position, demonising others as enemies. My own guess on this is that > > it works institutionally and that groupthink is a key to the madness > > of our politics. I have no doubt now we are dealing with > > pathologies. I also believe a key element in traditional anarchism is > > pathological. It has the slogan 'all truth lies in the main > > destruction' - broadly that society itself is crap and smashing it > > will sort things out. This bit is actually OK with me at times - I'd > > have blown Parliament up yesterday (preferably with a raspberry- > > bomb). What then emerges is the pathology, not the fictional, > > wonderful, peaceful ..zzzz.. human. As Gruff pointed out somewhere, > > we even need a panoply of rules to cross the road. Many people, quite > > rightly on history, think anarchy is just the rule of the beast. > > There's an old joke in which the officer insists the squaddie salutes > > him. The grunt refuses and is told he must salute the uniform. 'You > > take it off and I'll salute it', says the grunt. There may be > > something about institution that is OK and only screwed by the gets > > who use legitimate authority for illegitimate reasons. > > > My own view is that we should generally have some grok of what we want > > to build before we tear stuff down - though this isn't more than a > > rule-of-thumb. The British Parliament just needs a bomb - we need to > > know how unimportant it has become by hardly noticing that it has > > gone. Many 'institutions' are concealed. We don't 'fuck, shit > > bastard' much in here, though as 'anarchists' (pages of argument here > > that the logo 'anarchista' is so much more cool?) we should as there > > is an institution there to attack and even the precedent of Orwell's > > 1984 in which our honest toil makes it impossible to speak to the > > politicians without honestly 'fucking them off'. I think I can argue > > that 'bad language' holds some keys in the analysis of how we are > > institutionalised. Its prohibition excludes huge numbers of people > > from diplomacy. Anyone else, incidentally, a fan of 'Deadwood' in > > which bad language is raised back to the Shakespearian fine-art now so > > denuded and polite in order to appeal to middle-class nerks dressed as > > upper-class turds? Anyone else watching 'The Thick of It'? > > > My brother, something of a scholar of the Spanish Civil War, points > > out that the anarchists really did go on holiday en masse when it was > > time to go over the top. They also fought with mad courage. Some of > > the US anarchists were hung after years of legal pisswitter, for > > refusing to take part in WW1 (what relevance has this capitalist war > > got to us?). Courageous English Jews managed to have conscientious > > objection to fighting the war against Hitler and were not hung (even > > by their own). Israel is using religion to get its own to fight. > > > We may all be capable to some sort of polite pretence on anarchy Orn. > > Underlying this phoney crud (from which many make money) is a > > biological institution that we need to understand and be able to > > control. Animals are autopoetic; there is no bee without the hive. > > Pack dogs create alphas and omegas without great literature. Ants > > take 'slaves' with no great moral posing, Kharzei (definitely Khazi) > > promises to expunge the stain of corruption and is barking. I'd even > > guess there are biological human defaults. The first questions for > > anarchy might well lie in what it is we want to build, which suggests > > anarchy as a tool in thought, not a way to be. Even postmodernism is > > supposed to 'pre-date' modernism, come postmodo before we structure. > > > On 3 Nov, 08:09, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > “…I take a guess too that anarchy is actually genetically impossible > > > for humans…” – archy > > > > One last small reflection: Anarchy as I’ve been presenting it and as I > > > understand Noam to use the term is a process…an attitude that is a > > > constant skepticism of institutions…the process is a never ending > > > questioning of their existence. This seems all to possible for us. > > > > On Nov 2, 4:56 pm, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Anarchy translates from the old Greek as 'leaderlessness'. Much of > > > > the talk and action back then concerned small states. A fair bit has > > > > been written on 'Stoneage Economics' - enough to tell us there is > > > > always something governing relations. I take a guess too that anarchy > > > > is actually genetically impossible for humans - we are not amongst the > > > > creatures that manage without hierarchies in collective social action > > > > - like termites and some spiders. Most small societies did find ways > > > > to limit the acquisitional powers of the leaders - I think we miss a > > > > beat here. > > > > > On 2 Nov, 21:22, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > "... On Nov 2, 9:39 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: ..." > > > > > > > I'm not feeling so good either Gruff - made the mistake of watching > > > > > > our Parliament in 'action' - like being in traction. Whatever they > > > > > > are, it ain't democracy and I just ended-up physically nauseous. I > > > > > > found my hands starting to go through the motions of breaking down, > > > > > > cleaning and reloading my old Walther P5. I rather like purposeful > > > > > > castles-in-the-air, but what I can't stand is putting off forever > > > > > > what > > > > > > we think is real by making debate or story-telling all that can be. > > > > > > I understand and feel much the same when watching, listening and > > > > > reading our own politicians on this side of the pond. I don't believe > > > > > all politicians are bad but they all do seem to have the same > > > > > inability to answer a simple question with a straightforward answer.- > > > > > Hide quoted text - > > > > > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text - > > > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
