There is bound to be a paradox in an elite producing a fair and egalitarian state for all. The concentration of power in marxism was supposed to be temporary until the state withered away. I suppose all we can say to that is 'get real'. Foucault fixated on the panopticon of Bentham for a while - the question here being who supervises the gaolers who get to see all. Bentham suggested public scrutiny by an interested public. Russell was convinced our existing politicians were worthless and that world government was the only real option for a peaceful world. I think the neo-cons harbour an alternative, which would be to take out the rest while we are ahead. I haven't seen a plan that looks viable. Work has been around at least since the Plato of 'The Laws', 'Republik' and Aristotle's 'Politics'. They can't help directly now. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_government gives some of the history. Some find transparency very threatening and see the panopticon as a kind of warning. I think we hide too much, broadly behind politesse and etiquette in Elias' 'Mannered Society' - perhaps producing the fetish of those who want to peer into the lives of celebrities? I think we can put forward structures that would produce the kind of responsibility that produces freedom alongside. We could even try them out in a computer game (at least as a way to spread the debate). There are such games at trivial levels already. I'd guess you have a lot right on size Justin.
On 4 Nov, 15:50, Justintruth <[email protected]> wrote: > According to Focault its the key. Its all a question of who's in jail > and who is the jailer. The one who gets to observe the other... that's > the jailer. Its them or us. > > The problem is how to get all of them at once. If we made the > politicians and the police powerless organized crime would just surge > or perhaps corporations or the churches. The bad guys are always > posing as the good guys who are going to protect you from the bad > guys. We must attack all forms of hierarchy and frame the laws that > way. If you are involved in a dominance heirarchy of any kind, any > kind of coordination of action where the decision to go one way or > another for the entire group is set by a single leader or small set > "at the top" and that organization is greater than say 500 people, > then you *must* loose your privacy. And if not then you *must* have > it. No private surveillance. We can graduate the access with the top > leaders literally on camera on the internet unless with his wife or in > a bathroom that is swept for illicit comm gear and then he can have no > communication outside. No private papers at all. Everything > transparent mandatory with very severe criminal penalties if it is > violated. We should have very severe penalties for "covert > organization" and strict and severe penalties for any kind of > surveillance to which the public does not have immediate access to the > raw data and any data mining results. Perhaps two police forces - one > to do the policing and the other - they ride in the same cars and sit > in the same offices and are one to one onto man for man, desk for desk > - this last force for policing the police. This latter force should > have a dual role of "crime reporter" in the newspaper sense and > "arrest authority" in the police sense. They should be elected and > have term limits. They should be required to file reports weekly. If > that happens we have a shot at going international and not causing a > gulag. Without it the nation to nation checking is probably better, > although I see signs already of the "club at the top" forming and > sometimes think that politicians are representing their class and not > their constituency. The "power elite" they are the danger. We have > been trying to play one off against another and what freedoms we have > are due to that but with modern communications and data processing > infrastructure and increasing globalization we need a new synthesis. > We need some political scientist to put it together using a game > theoretical approach and then we need consciousness raised and only > then political action. They will never surrender their power > willingly. It is just too addictive. There are strong biological > motivations in primate communities. Dominance hierarchy is a > biological fact. Unfortunately, I think that right now the question of > how to form a political legal system that is international and non - > totalitarian is unsolved. At least I have not seen a description of > one. And once we have the description of the end system we still need > to know how to transition it. The last synthesis of this time, > Marxism, failed dismally and resulted in a concentration of power > rather than an attenuation of it. > > On Nov 4, 2:53 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > If only the polygraphs worked. If our great leaders actually had to > > face genuine public scrutiny the system would change. That they have > > managed to prevent any realistic scrutiny is the problem. > > > On 4 Nov, 10:09, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > "....Wire them up and lets see where they > > > are lying ! ;)" - JIT > > > > Since often there is a real time graph at the bottom of the screen > > > showing the attracted/not-attracted attitude of the audience, one > > > would think it would be equally easy to have a graph showing the > > > movements from truth to fiction and back of the speeker. > > > > On Nov 4, 12:30 am, Justintruth <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Now there is the kind of great idea that I read this group > > > > for....Mandatory public polygraphs for world leaders. That would > > > > change the Sunday news circuit! Wire them up and lets see where they > > > > are lying ! ;) > > > > > On Nov 2, 7:20 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > “…I'd like to focus a bit on what technology is and what it could > > > > > offer. One area would be how we might use it to stop the kind of > > > > > political farces of our everyday.” – Archy > > > > > > I hold little hope for being able to implement anything of substance > > > > > here in the USA along these lines. Having watched all of the public > > > > > initiatives that passed the vote in California only fall shortly to > > > > > legal challenge, I’ve become cynical. One was attempted to limit the > > > > > number of staff members a congressional member had…they got it > > > > > overturned! So much for the will of the people. > > > > > > Even worse, our laws requiring drug testing before and during a > > > > > worker’s tenure in all sorts of trades, including bus driver, train > > > > > driver, taxi driver and countless other corporate positions where it > > > > > is used for….well, I’m not sure why…anyway, these tests are used for > > > > > ‘the masses’. To date, I have not even heard of a suggestion that the > > > > > leader(s) of the free world might need to be tested now and then…one > > > > > can only guess… > > > > > Perhaps some type of truth serum as well as lie detector machines > > > > > would aid in ‘our’ trust?...just a few ruminations and fantasies based > > > > > on idealism. > > > > > > On Nov 2, 5:32 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > > John Wheeler had the universe as a single electron through history > > > > > > at > > > > > > one point, and Feynman wondered on a single positron going backwards > > > > > > in time. There are many ways we attempt to grok, including > > > > > > metaphor. > > > > > > I have long wondered like Justin in the post above. One of my three > > > > > > books in progress is really about a time when the problems have > > > > > > withered away for those who survive us. We are hopefully more than > > > > > > a > > > > > > chattering class fiddling whilst the planet burns - though in one > > > > > > version, even this old metaphor makes a hero out of the unlikely > > > > > > Nero > > > > > > (a pet name for me in an old pub-corner 'putting the world to > > > > > > rights' > > > > > > sect). > > > > > > We have long had socio-technological analysis along the lines of > > > > > > Justin's definition (Woodward, systems and contingency theories ...) > > > > > > and, of course, Habermas, Rawls and whatever turn of grand theorist > > > > > > we > > > > > > choose. I wouldn't suppose we are unaware. They leave me feeling > > > > > > my > > > > > > own inadequacy and how hapless they all are too ... not quite > > > > > > despair, > > > > > > but I feel it unlikely the analysis here extends beyond Justin's 'I > > > > > > think the politicians have no problem with opinions that differ from > > > > > > theirs as long as they are expressed in a politically meaningless > > > > > > way.... as long as they do not sway people in numbers'. > > > > > > It's hard to be abstract here. Years of teaching leaves me with a > > > > > > cold view of our inadequacy in critical reasoning. In a current UK > > > > > > situation, our Home Secretary has sacked Professor Nutt who has > > > > > > dared > > > > > > to tell the truth (alcohol and cigarettes are more dangerous than > > > > > > cannabis), claiming he was free to have his views but not to make > > > > > > them > > > > > > public as a government advisor. It was his behaviour in doing this > > > > > > that led to him being sacked. The Home Secretary is in charge of > > > > > > 'justice'! Currently the behaviour of MPs is regarded as at a new > > > > > > low > > > > > > following expenses scandals, the bulk of which is being covered-up. > > > > > > The politician is clueless and we have a current public information > > > > > > film as stupid as many from the 1950s. The Home Secretary could > > > > > > only > > > > > > shout on television and bully. Nutt is portrayed as campaigning > > > > > > against the government when all he has done is be a scientist and > > > > > > lecturer. Somehow, we need to combat the madness and I believe > > > > > > technology could help - and not least in Justin's definition the > > > > > > dismantling of the spin technologies. > > > > > > > I'd like to focus a bit on what technology is and what it could > > > > > > offer. One area would be how we might use it to stop the kind of > > > > > > political farces of our everyday. > > > > > > > On 2 Nov, 12:16, Justintruth <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > > > ..... - now the politicians are > > > > > > > > > back to the fascist ethics and seek the slaughter of anyone who > > > > > > > > disagrees. > > > > > > > > I think we still have a window of time before we get to that... > > > > > > > also.... I think the politicians have no problem with opinions > > > > > > > that > > > > > > > differ from theirs as long as they are expressed in a politically > > > > > > > meaningless way.... as long as they do not sway people in > > > > > > > numbers. But > > > > > > > for me the problem is earlier than worrying about what the > > > > > > > politicians > > > > > > > say or even whether people will accept ideas. The problem is which > > > > > > > ideas. We still do not have a coherent expression of what should > > > > > > > be > > > > > > > done politically. At least I do not know of one. I am sure that > > > > > > > war > > > > > > > needs to be eliminated and some form of safety net should be put > > > > > > > in > > > > > > > place but how does one implement political structures in a global > > > > > > > world in a way that concentrations of power do not evolve to > > > > > > > totalitarianism? Just how should the government be configured? How > > > > > > > should the police be configured? > > > > > > > > I think that privacy for citizens and no privacy for anyone in > > > > > > > power > > > > > > > is one key. But how to attain it? How to enforce it? > > ... > > read more » --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
