Knowing we appear to have great difficulty coming to agreement, I will simply say that Buddhism, like any other historical set of tenets, may have ‘holes’ in the sense that said tenets use words and words, as I’ve been saying all along are subjective in nature. So, in that sense, ‘it’ (even though Buddhism is in no way monolithic) has ‘holes’. On the other hand, you appear to be saying (implying) that some thoughts and/or concepts do not have ‘holes’…this is something I don’t understand in this context at all. Somehow you appear to not see enlightenment as something which is fully knowable, that is, IF I’m accurately understanding your posts.
Again, as I’m reading your written words here, you appear to be equating notions and concepts that you are not fully conversant with and/or see disagreement about among other humans as having ‘holes’. IF this is what you are saying, by extension, every thought has ‘holes’. As to your question about dogma, again, using my perpetual, (for many years now), declaration that all words and concepts are subjective, yes, “authority” can be seen as being associated with being dogmatic in the sense that differing subjective views of the term are proffered. Again, this is the case for all words, so to me I don’t see much of a point here, consensus or not. When it comes to Noam’s utterances about the principle of universality, I don’t see how hubris is applicable even philosophically. That is, unless one holds the view that we cannot know anything. Since it is obvious that few are aware of that principle and perhaps fewer still know how Noam has used the principle for decades now, here is one of numerous pieces by him that clarifies its use. He sets the tone at the start. http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20040806.htm I see little difference between this principle and other philosophical notions like the Golden Rule etc. So that I’m not accused of cherry picking, Noam is well known for his work in linguistics and associates this idea of universality with language too. For those who have the time, here is a lecture by him on that topic. “The Idea of Universality in Linguistics and Human Rights” – Noam Chomsky http://mitworld.mit.edu/video/257 I purposefully am not attempting to delve into this much more complex topic, including linguistics, beyond the one simple observation I’ve made above about words and concepts being subjective. I only include this video for those who wish to go beyond our current overview of the topic. On Nov 5, 7:26 am, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > "... On Nov 4, 1:44 pm, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> > wrote: ..." > > > Yep gruff, any sort of dogma by definition implies holes, right? Of > > course, even the nature of what is a religion and what is not remains > > contentious. > > I'd have to say yes to that question. If I'm not mistaken the basic > core of Buddhism is enlightenment and liberation attained through > insight into the true nature of reality and within that definition the > definitions of enlightenment and liberation both have numerous holes > (sort of like black holes) and what IS the true nature of reality > since it can be said that each of us have our own. > > > I find little dogma in the indictive to > > question authority. The principle of universality does require some > > deeper principles than are adhered to by more arbitrary types of ethos > > though. > > As regards the entire conversation that has gone before, is there not > dogma in each individual's perception of authority? And were we to > adopt a consensus of what authority is, would there not be dogma in > that? But I believe this is playing word games. We are human > beings and therefore, almost by definition, cannot avoid dogma and it > seems to me to speak of universality is simple hubris. > > > I do appreciate the opportunity to review Noam’s thoughts because, he > > like Neil (and me for sure) know just how little we know when it comes > > to social engineering or even analysis of systems. > > Aye, and how little we know about anything else either. --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
