I think the key words in your approach is "we need", "we" meaning you,
Molly, Iam, and others who subscribe to religion.  I personally have
no need for it.

On Nov 9, 2:05 am, Vamadevananda <[email protected]> wrote:
> We've heard your antipathies, SD !  I just placed a mirror for you to
> see, too.
>
> "  And now to Vam who would ask me a question and then offer the
> answer
> the question to get the ball rolling down Van's path."
>
> Down my path ?  Why, have you already given up, even before the
> start ?
>
> " To suggest that religion is viable on account of those who are too
> dumb or too ignorant to find security in their world is again an
> absurdity."
>
> Dumb ?  Ignorant ?  aah,  your antipathetic but uncalled for
> descriptors ... then, ' insecurity ' ...  SD, I am speaking of you and
> I !
>
> " To say atheism is unnecessary to the situation is setting preclusion
> to the issue."
>
> Indeed. Because, right then, what we need is strength, something
> positive, and not the negations that atheism by definition stands
> for !
>
> " It is obvious that you engage discussion with precedent that your
> belief is concrete when we all know, as well as yourself, that it is
> as the clouds that pass over the sky, castles in the sand,
> ultimately and totally a fantasy without any tangibility.
>
> These are your thoughts and conclusions. I'd suggest :  Stop
> discussing me !  What I know, you do not even have an idea.
>
> Thank you.
>
> On Nov 9, 6:58 am, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > You are missing the point Molly. It is not that atheists are not
> > capable of violence, it is though, obvious that religion does not
> > preclude violence.  We're not talking about politics so don't waste
> > time bringing it up, especially that much violence in the world is
> > attributed to religion.  You are basically clouding the issue.
> > This is all so ludicrous because you are all in line with a belief
> > system and so have found a camaraderie in mystical fantasy belief.
>
> > No one said this, and your logic here is faulty. MB
>
> > Before you authoritatively deem my logic as faulty and further suggest
> > that I am being intentionally obtuse you should look at your own
> > assertions being presented as a "standard" to which everyone should
> > recognize and adhere to "without" question.  You have no basis other
> > than blind belief to support your position.
>
> > Sure we have many beliefs which form the foundations of our societies,
> > but clearly, simple observation of global societies easily
> > demonstrates that your belief, among the whole of beliefs, is just as
> > empty as the rest.  You have absolutely "nothing", "zero", to offer as
> > a viable reason that I should believe in such nonsense.
>
> > And now to Vam who would ask me a question and then offer the answer
> > the question to get the ball rolling down Van's path.  To suggest that
> > religion is viable on account of those who are too dumb or too
> > ignorant to find security in their world is again an absurdity.
> > To say atheism is unnecessary to the situation is setting preclusion
> > to the issue.  It is obvious that you engage discussion with precedent
> > that your belief is concrete when we all know, as well as yourself,
> > that it is as the clouds that pass over the sky, castles in the sand,
> > ultimately and totally a fantasy without any tangibility.
>
> > And now to Manfraco, who knows what I mean and understands that his
> > belief and the beliefs of all those throughout the history of mankind
> > is without foundation.  Stories in books written by men span a massive
> > spectrum of hypothesis, myth, superstition and idolatry but have yet
> > to establish themselves as anything more than just fantasy.  We tend
> > to believe we are above the mundane but in reality we are just as all
> > other animals on the planet, here to live, to experience life.  You
> > don't find any other animals trying to sell other animals some bill of
> > goods, trying to purport themselves as being above the rest in a
> > spiritual way and offering all sorts of redemption goods.  It's all
> > such emptiness, bullshit phenomenon.
>
> > So my point is that we should get back to the basics, back to just
> > living, enjoying life and sharing the bounties that the earth has to
> > offer.  We need to get away from ownership and greed, domination and
> > religion.  We can live without religion, the dichotomy of humanity,
> > the wedge driven into life.
>
> > Whether it is possible is another question, perhaps another thread.  I
> > personally live within a world that is all that I say it is without
> > religion.  There is much joy and happiness and a great deal of peace.
> > It is only when religious people enter the picture that I am all of a
> > sudden a sinner, unworthy, needing to be saved, and have a god that I
> > need to worship and give up my weekly tithing to so I don't do to
> > hell, another makeshift fantasy used as a fear tactic to get people to
> > believe.  Hey, it's all about the odds right, why take the chance in
> > not believing and risk burning in hell when all I have to do is
> > believe in the bullshit.
>
> > Let's get real.
>
> >  Nov 8, 11:09 am, Molly Brogan <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > > "Reiterating that a convention of atheists would not lead to a violent
> > > situation simply because the congregants are void of religious
> > > belief. "
>
> > > So, they would never disagree on politics, leading to violence?
>
> > > "To suggest that religious belief is equatable with ethical behavior
> > > implies that Atheism in unethical."
>
> > > No it doesn't.  Atheist groups simply agree on beliefs other than
> > > religious, such as politics or any other belief of their choosing.
>
> > > "I must stop at red lights and pay
> > > for my merchandise therefore I must have religion?"
>
> > > No one said this, and your logic here is faulty.  I was only
> > > suggesting that religious groups agree on belief, and making an
> > > analogy that in communities, there are many social agreements outside
> > > of the religious.  It is an analogy, not a dependency.  Are you
> > > purposefully being obtuse in order to argue? Because honestly, this
> > > seems to me like a no brainer.
>
> > > We have many beliefs that are not religious.  Belief in democracy, for
> > > instance.  Belief that the sun will rise.  Belief that my fellow man
> > > is basically honest, or not.  Beliefs allow us to trust, respect,
> > > assert or follow authority, and many other basic human processes.
>
> > > On Nov 8, 11:57 am, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > > > The inevitability may be a valid factor but does not establish
> > > > necessity.  With that logic we could assume that it will be inevitable
> > > > that man will always be violent and kill for nonsensical reason or as
> > > > a remedial solution towards peace accomplishment, quite the dilemma.
> > > > People being social creatures naturally leads to some sort of group
> > > > organizational process and in doing so many times a common belief will
> > > > serve as the adhesive and identification of the established group.
> > > > Reiterating that a convention of atheists would not lead to a violent
> > > > situation simply because the congregants are void of religious
> > > > belief.  Insisting that we "need" "somekind" of religion is a personal
> > > > perception or an attempt to describe Atheism as a religion in and of
> > > > itself.
> > > > To suggest that religious belief is equatable with ethical behavior
> > > > implies that Atheism in unethical.  I must stop at red lights and pay
> > > > for my merchandise therefore I must have religion? That would be
> > > > absurd.  I go back to Ayn Rand's comment that man must first start
> > > > with himself before he can mix and mingle with others on any
> > > > altruistic level which in a sense includes religious belief systems.
> > > > I don't see that any belief system in needed.  We simply need to adopt
> > > > on an individual basis a melioristic attitude to make things better.
> > > > It is not a system but a personal consciousness.   If we as a group
> > > > till the field, nurture the crop to harvest we will eat.  It's that
> > > > simple, no religion, no mystical or magical anything.
>
> > > > On Nov 8, 6:38 am, Molly Brogan <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > > > > I agree with Manfranco that some kind of religion is probably
> > > > > inevitable because many of us actually choose to pray and exchange
> > > > > ideas on faith together.  In the coming together, some sort of
> > > > > organization is also inevitable to provide the site of congregating
> > > > > and means of exchange.
>
> > > > > We all have belief, it is a basic component of human psychology.
> > > > > Religious congregations agreeing on belief is along the lines of
> > > > > communities agreeing on ethical behavior - the same social agreements
> > > > > keep us stopping at the stop lights, not bumping those in front of us
> > > > > in line at the register with shopping carts, returning our library
> > > > > books, not shooting the people that walk down our streets.  More
> > > > > severe infractions of the social agreements require laws and
> > > > > enforcement of them.
>
> > > > > There are many of us that find no purpose in organized religion.  Many
> > > > > do.  And many do and don't in different periods of our lives.  Such is
> > > > > life.  We choose our beliefs and groups to express them, that is,
> > > > > until the One and the many in us express in unity.
>
> > > > > On Nov 8, 4:49 am, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > > > > > On Nov 7, 3:44 pm, Manfraco Frank the Elder <[email protected]>
> > > > > > wrote:> Hi SD!
> > > > > > > So you think that I am a religious fanatic right? But I believe I 
> > > > > > > am
> > > > > > > not because I see things this way: If one day there is a new 
> > > > > > > religious
> > > > > > > order
>
> > > > > >  [Must we even have a "religious" order?  Can't you imagine a world
> > > > > > without religion?]
> > > > > > it must be very tame compared to what we have today, and it must> 
> > > > > > be constructed in such a way that it would be very hard for people 
> > > > > > to
> > > > > > > use it to promote violence.
>
> > > > > > [Constructed?  That is the whole
>
> ...
>
> read more »
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to