hi,

On Tue, Jun 07, 2005 at 02:33:35AM -0500, Walter Goulet wrote:
> One minor point that befuddled me at first was the fact that ifconfig 
> and wicontrol use different terms when referring to the SSID. 
> Specifically, if you use ifconfig to set the SSID, you have to use the 
> 'nwid' option. However, if you use wicontrol, the man page has a 
> seperate option 'q' used to set the SSID.
> 

please don't use wicontrol anymore. most of it's functionality except
some dubious buttons have been added to ifconfig.

> - Change ifconfig's interface to replace 'ssid' with 'nwid' at the risk 
> of breaking existing scripts etc (Note that NetBSD changed 'nwid' to 
> 'ssid' to resolve this issue).

breaking scripts for nonsense? uhh...

ssid is a wrong, but commonly used, term and the essid (extended
service set id) is the IEEE name for the "network id". we're fine with
nwid because it's a generic name which also applies to non-802.11
protocols and it's less cryptic.

> - Change ifconfig's manpage to indicate that nwid is really the same as 
> the ssid.
> 

you mean the ESSID ;-). a hint in ifconfig(8) is probably the better
idea.

> I personally think the second option is the better option; I'd be glad 
> to submit a patch once I finish building userland. I'd like to get some 
> opinions before I move forward with this effort.
> 

no. we won't replace nwid with neither ssid nor essid. same for nwkey.

> Thanks,
> Walter

reyk

Reply via email to