--On 19 September 2005 11:14 +0200, Stephan A. Rickauer wrote:

I've read "PF: Issues with FTP" carefully and tried to setup
ftp-proxy(8) on the firewall. Now it seems I have a fundamental
misunderstanding on how it should work.

   My client is 172.16.3.99
   An example FTP server is 195.135.221.132

What filter and rdr rules do you have?
Is ftp-proxy(8) in NAT mode?

You have the rdr sending outbound 21 to the ftp-proxy service, but
you  also need to let traffic back in to the service:

As far as I know, this only applies to _active_ ftp, about which I am
not concerned at the moment.

This depends on how you're running ftp-proxy. It might be working slightly differently to how you expect.

Reply via email to