On Mon, Mar 19, 2012 at 1:48 AM, Gilles Chehade <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi, > > On Mon, Mar 19, 2012 at 01:20:30AM -0700, Shawn Wallbridge wrote: >> I am setting up a new mail server using OpenBSD 5.0. Initially this >> was the smtpd.conf I went with, based on the guide on calomel.org >> (https://calomel.org/opensmtpd.html) and this post on daemon forums >> (http://www.daemonforums.org/showthread.php?t=6228). >> > > Please forget that calomel website... I beg you... > > It is inaccurate from the very first paragraph, there is nothing in the > OpenSMTPD page that you cannot find in the man pages ! > > >> # cat /etc/mail/smtpd.conf >> <snip> >> map "virtual" { source db "/etc/mail/virtual.db" } >> <snip> >> accept from all for domain "domain1.com" alias "virtual" deliver to maildir >> accept from all for domain "domain1.org" alias "virtual" deliver to maildir >> accept from all for domain "domain1.net" alias "virtual" deliver to maildir >> <snip> >> > > That is three primary domains using a map called "virtual" to resolve > aliases, definitely not what you want. > > >> # cat /etc/mail/virtual >> >> # Tried both with and with out : separators >> [email protected] user1 >> [email protected] user2 >> [email protected] user3 >> [email protected] user4 >> > > Your virtual map is incorrect also, keep on reading. > > >> When I telnet in to send mail to the virtual domains (the primary >> domain works fine), I get a rejection... >> >> Mar 19 02:27:35 mail smtpd[31255]: 344f0d39: from=<[email protected]>, >> relay=xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx.socal.res.rr.com [xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx], >> stat=LocalError (530 5.0.0 Recipient rejected: [email protected]) >> > > Yup, both conf and map are incorrect, so it just won't work. > > >> So I did some more research. >> >> On this page (http://www.openbsd.org/cgi-bin/cvsweb/src/usr.sbin/smtpd/makemap.8 >> ), for Revision 1.10, it states that... >> >> - they no longer need an explicit rule in smtpd.conf for EACH domain >> >> instead we introduce the: accept for virtual map "mapname" [...] syntax >> which refers to a map that can be manipulated at runtime. >> >> Which matches the man page for smtpd.conf. So, I have tried this in my >> smtpd.conf file... >> >> <snip> >> # tried with type db and using makemap, switched to plain as a test >> map "virtual" { source plain "/etc/mail/virtual" } >> <snip> >> accept from all for virtual "virtual" deliver to maildir >> <snip> >> > > Now the smtpd.conf is correct (and matches the man page) ;-) > > >> Same problem, mail is rejected. >> > > The map is still wrong. > > >> I have tried a bunch of different things, with no luck. I am guessing >> I am missing something very basic. I wish their was more documentation >> out there, but I think I have read every page out there. I can't wait >> for the book. >> > > Ahem... > > So since reading smtpd.conf(5) helped you fix smtpd.conf, let's give a try > at fixing the virtual map with makemap(8). > > Jump to the section called "VIRTUAL DOMAINS": > > VIRTUAL DOMAINS > Virtual domains are kept in maps. To add support for a virtual domain, > ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ > add a domain key ``example.com whatever'' to the virtual map. > ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ > To create single virtual address, add ``[email protected] user'' to the > virtual map. To handle all mail destined to any user at example.com, add > ``@example.com user'' to the virtual map. > > In addition to adding an entry to the virtual map, one must add a filter > rule that accepts mail for virtual domains, for example: > > map "vdomains" { source db "/etc/mail/vdomains.db" } > accept for virtual "vdomains" deliver to mbox > > The second sentence explains what you have to do to enable a virtual domain, > and which is precisely what's lacking from your map. > > The second paragraph also documents what you found in smtpd.conf(5) regarding > the format of the rule for a virtual domain. It was documented in two places. > > >> Anyone out there have virtual domains working that would be willing to >> share their config? Or help point me in the right direction? >> > > Done ! > > Gilles > > PS: please forget that calomel site. > > -- > Gilles Chehade > > https://www.poolp.org | http://pool.ps @poolpOrg
Thank you very much, your email and Marcus helped fix the problem. Just wondering, how do you get that version of the makemap man page? I tried the openbsd site, as well as man makemap 8 on my machine. They are all sendmail based, which is probably why I didn't catch that. Again, thank you very much. I was about to switch back to Postfix. shawn
