First, I wish to appologize.

    While I am actually fairly familiar with the GPL,
I am not intimate with either the various forms of BSD License or the ISC. Somehow jumping back and forth between them all on wikipedia before my original post I missed the clause that appears to be in each of them require preserving the
   License/Permissions as well as the copyright.

I made an honest effort to look, and somehow read right through exactly what I was looking for. I went back over the ISC a second time before posting, but I read what I was expecting to see, not
   exactly what was writing.

   That fairly well obliterates the main point I was attempting to make.

   But many of the other issues are still valid.

The argument that you start with copyright and then add or subtract based on the license is
    correct.

But you can not expect copyright law to return, rights you cede in your license.

Yes, a License is a legal document, and MOST legal documents are immutable,
   but generalization is not the same as law.
The ISC and BSD Licenses are immutable, because although they cede alot, they do preserve that. They are not immutable, because all legal documents are inherently immutable.

Reply via email to