I saw a similar problem and I got it fixed changing the frequency
channel of the wireless box. Did you try this already?


On 8/10/08, ropers <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> 2008/8/6 OpenBSD Misc <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
> > Hi.  I'm at my wits end.
> >
> > My original configuration:
> > I have a laptop (HP Pavillion dv9700).  It comes with an integrated Intel
> > Wireless WiFi Link 4965AGN adapter and is running Vista Home Premium.  I
> > have a D-Link DWL-2200AP wireless access point.  I have an old Gateway
> > computer with a P3 processor running at 650 MHz and five NICs that was
> > running FreeBSD 7.  I have a Westell DSL modem with 3000/768 service through
> > Verizon.  The Gateway is set up as a firewall with ipf.  The notebook
> > connects wirelessly to the WAP, which is cabled into a NIC in the firewall,
> > which is cabled to the DSL modem through a different NIC.
> >
> > The problem:
> > I noticed that my wireless was running slowly.  Verizon has a speed testing
> > website, so I test my speed with it.  My upload speed nearly maxes out at
> >>700 Kbps no matter what my configuration is.  My download speed doesn't
> > typically get above 90 Kbps.  BUT, I have a PC running Windows XP Pro
> > connected to a third NIC in the firewall, and the speed test nearly maxes
> > out both upload and download speeds.
> >
> > What I did:
> > Okay, something's wrong with the wireless link.  I connect the WAP directly
> > to the DSL modem and retest my speed.  I'm running at FULL speed, so the
> > problem isn't with the wireless connection between the laptop and the WAP.
> > So I reconnect the WAP to the firewall with a different (new, prefab,
> > unopened) ethernet cable and retest.  Download speed sucks again; it's not a
> > cabling issue.  So I move to a different NIC and retest.  Download speed
> > still sucks; it's not the NIC.  So I move to the NIC to which my XP PC was
> > connected (which got fast download speeds) and retested.  Download speed
> > STILL sucks.  I buy a D-Link DAP-1522 wireless access point and replace the
> > DWL-2200AP.  I retest and get sucky download speeds.  I've been wanting to
> > move to OpenBSD and pf for some time now, so I install OpenBSD 4.3 on the
> > firewall, set up my DSL connection, DNS service, and DHCP service.  I
> > configure pf with a minimal configuration that basically lets all outbound
> > traffic pass and blocks all inbound traffic from the internet.  I test
> > connectivity, and my Vista laptop and XP PC both connect to the Internet and
> > can talk to each other.  The firewall can talk to everything.  I put all
> > cables back to their original configuration; everything's connected as it
> > was when I first noticed the problem except for the new WAP, the new OS, and
> > the new cable.  I retest my speeds.  I'm back where I started: XP PC gets
> > full speed internet service, laptop gets sucky download speeds through the
> > wireless link.  So with OpenBSD on the Gateway I retry everything I just
> > described above with the new WAP and new cable and get the same results.  I
> > put everything back to the original configuration again except the WAP, OS,
> > and cable.  I test the speed over the wireless link again and get sucky
> > download speeds.  I copy a large file from my XP PC to my laptop (which is
> > still connected to the firewall wirelessly all this time) and I get GREAT
> > transfer speeds.
> >
> > Conclusion:
> > So I can talk through my WAP and through my firewall to anything else on my
> > side of the internet connection at full speed, and everything that's not
> > wireless can talk through the firewall to the internet at full speed.  But I
> > cannot talk through my WAP and through my firewall to the Internet at full
> > speed.  I can talk through my WAP to the Internet (not through the firewall)
> > at full speed.
> >
> > Can anyone please offer some assistance?
> >
> > Thank you...
> >
> >
> > Additional information:
> > The three NICs in the firewall that I tried use the vr, xl, and ne drivers.
> > The vr has a VIA Rhine or RhineII chipset.  The xl is a 3Com 3c905, and the
> > ne is a generic card using the Realtek 8029 chipset.
> >
>
> <snip />
>
> I'm clueless as to your actual problem, but I did have the following thoughts:
>
> The question is whether this problem is
> OS/software/configuration-specific. The fact that you've encountered
> the same problem with FreeBSD and OpenBSD seems to suggest that it's
> not OS/software-specific, but there are some commonalities between the
> various *BSDs, and there is more common code between Free- and OpenBSD
> than between Linux and OpenBSD. I don't know^W^W^WAccording to
> http://www.freebsd.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/books/handbook/firewalls-apps.html
> , FreeBSD uses IPF, IPFW and PF. Which did you use when you tried
> FreeBSD? If you used PF both on OpenBSD and FreeBSD, then it might be
> a PF problem. This may be a bit of work to even try, but are you
> encountering the same problems with the other firewalls under FreeBSD?
> If yes, then you could try to rule out problems because of common code
> in the OpenBSD and FreeBSD OSes by trying Linux/IPtables and checking
> whether you're having the same problems there.
> Obviously, what you also haven't changed is the mainboard (you only
> tried different NICs), though it would be really really really weird
> if such a problem turned out to be related to a specific mainboard.
> I'm not sure if things like MTU problems might come into play in your
> scenario, maybe someone more knowledgeable may be able to say if these
> can be ruled out.
>
> Just my two eurocents; sorry I can't be of more help.
>
> --ropers
>
>


-- 

Alex

Reply via email to