Thanks for the info!!

El 28/01/18 a las 14:20, Peter Danninger escribió:
I've downloaded and testet.

look at attachment.

In short-form:
-----------------------------------------
really good, comparable with the
USGS-NASA .hgt-files.

 N74E018, N74E019:
   Bjornoya (Bäreninsel) missing,
   only "0", files deactivated

 N52E006, N51E005, N51E008, N50E005:
   some void's, easily correctable

comparisation with USGS-NASA files
only in the Alps-area and
only regarding min/max-values:

majority are nearly identical,
some differ by 20-30m
regarding the min/max-values,
but which are "better" ???

regards Peter

Am 27.01.2018 um 17:50 schrieb Carlos Dávila:
Thanks for sharing your results. Have you tested data from http://opendem.info/opendemeu_download_4326.html ?

El 27/01/18 a las 15:56, Peter Danninger escribió:
Some results from my .hgt-tests:

I wanted to find usable .hgt files for my
web-application zu add height data to .gpx

http://peter.myds.me/HDS/Tipps_Tricks/GPS/GPXclean/GPXclean.html
 ==> look at: "Spezialisten-Funktionen per Aufrufparameter"
 ==> sorry, only German ...

 ==> The results are in the attachment.

In short form:
-----------------------------------------------------
Viewfinderpanoramas Medium Europe 3sec:
  ==> lots of voids and too low height values.

NASA_USGS 1sec:
  ==> no voids, but some too low height values.
  not too bad, but easily correctable by
  directly adjacent height values.
  BUT only up to N59 in the north.

Viewfinderpanoramas Northern Europe 1/3 sec:
  ==> some voids in Island in the overlay
  row/col, but easily correctable by
  directly adjacent height values.

To sum up:
More then 3100 .hgt files without real problems.
As far as available these are 1sec files.
Only in the very north 3sec .hgt files.

I'm happy with the NASA_USGS 1sec .hgt files :-)

Peter

http://www.danninger.eu

Am 27.01.2018 um 15:06 schrieb Carlos Dávila:
El 27/01/18 a las 14:57, Carlos Dávila escribió:
I have no objective method to compare hgt sources (is there any?)

Well, a method I have already used is to get the number of voids in a hgt file using QGIS.




_______________________________________________
mkgmap-dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.mkgmap.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/mkgmap-dev

Reply via email to