BUT i don't see how its phishing.
I suspected it because its literally the exact same text but two completely different addresses and names.
You can scrape all the addresses to this list off the web
true enough
or by just subscribing.
Exactly :) Any posts, and especially replies are logged as valid addresses, perhaps.
Otherwise the odds that two people, just a day or so apart, are that dumb and lazy *and* would choose exactly the same text (verbage *and* capitolization no less) are astonomical.
