I would just like to place my module in the appropriate sensible place.
I understand very well that it is difficult if not impossible for people with existing modules to put them under a 'Framework' namespace, am merely suggesting that it would be a reasonable place for any such future modules to go.
If it is more desirable to place the module under 'App' I can certainly do that, but that seemed to be against the suggestions on the pause guidelines.
I have already altered all the module components to be under Framework::Core, and uploaded that version to my pause account. Unless there are any objections to the naming, this is still where I would like to place it.
-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: Module submission Framework::Core
From: brian d foy <brian.d....@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, April 24, 2013 9:52 am
To: codech...@cpan.org
[[ This message was both posted and mailed: see
the "To," "Cc," and "Newsgroups" headers for details. ]]
In article <20130423185355.67fa51f...@pause.perl.org>, "Perl Authors
Upload Server" <upl...@pause.perl.org> wrote:
> The following module was proposed for inclusion in the Module List:
>
> modid: Framework::Core
> DSLIP: adpOp
> description: Modular application framework
> userid: CODECHILD (David Helkowski)
Most people aren't looking to classify their frameworks by names. You
mentioned Catalyst and others; they didn't choose their names because
they didn't find a general noun to place their modules under. They
aren't trying to classify their modules in the era of "Search".
You can upload your module where you like, but I don't think other
people are going to follow you.
--
brian d foy (one of many PAUSE admins), http://pause.perl.org
PAUSE instructions: http://pause.perl.org/pause/query?ACTION="">
Archives: http://www.xray.mpe.mpg.de/mailing-lists/modules
Please send all messages back to modules@perl.org with no CC to me.-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Module submission Framework::Core
From: "Perl Authors Upload Server" <upl...@pause.perl.org>
Date: Tue, April 23, 2013 2:53 pm
To: modules@perl.org,codech...@cpan.org
The following module was proposed for inclusion in the Module List:
modid: Framework::Core
DSLIP: adpOp
description: Modular application framework
userid: CODECHILD (David Helkowski)
chapterid: 3 (Development_Support)
communities:
newsgroups, bug tracker
similar:
App::Core
rationale:
There currently exists no root namespace to contain application
frameworks on Cpan, despite there being a number of modules that
-are- application frameworks. Some of them are hosted under App (
such as App::Framework::Core )
Others are hosted at the root ( Catalyst, Jifty, etc )
I had originally chosen the name App::Core for this module, due to
it's dependence and creation around the features provided by the
Class::Core module. A preliminary version of the new module is
currently uploaded on my Cpan account under that name.
I would like to rename it to Framework::Core and register that
namespace, so that a root 'Framework' namespace can be created, my
module can go there as 'Framework::Core', and other Cpan module
authors could place their frameworks there as well, rather than
continuing to pollute the root namespace or other special purpose
namespaces such as 'App' ( which is specifically stated that it
should only contain actual applications, not components )
Thank you.
enteredby: CODECHILD (David Helkowski)
enteredon: Tue Apr 23 18:53:55 2013 GMT
The resulting entry would be:
Framework::
::Core adpOp Modular application framework CODECHILD
