> But  Gafa's  point  is that it used to support booleans and abstracted
> dot-property, then changed.

And IMO the clearest parallel to

    name : value

is  dot-property, since the same format accounts for both cases, while
setAttribute/removeAttribute would be better abstracted something like

    name : value
    !name

which is obviously not supportable using object literals.  The null is
not  something  that has much place in DOM and I think it's strange to
encourage  it  in  frameworkland.   As  you probably know, even though
within  browsers  set(value,null)  ~=  remove(value),  this is only by
happy  accident  and  *not*  standard  (it's  deprecated by individual
browser  vendors, but isn't even in the spec enough to be deprecated).
When  you  more clearly follow the DOM spec, there would be no obvious
way   for   set(value,null)   to   be   coerced   into  remove,  since
set(value,null)  could  just  as  well be coerced to set(value,"null")
which is not the same as remove.

BTW,  I  do  see  the dot-property emulation as working in IE8/Moo1.3,
though not in IE7/Moo1.3!

-- S.




Reply via email to