Allright, so I get a little bored sometimes, and sometimes it is fun to
whine at random internet people, and while it usually don't result in much
amusement I think you all will find at least the last reply of this huy
quite amusing and perhaps you will feel that you have heard this somewhere
before.. =D
(I pointed out that Atheism is a belief system i.e a religion)
[Random Guy:]
Is it recognized that atheism is a religion? Really? By whom?
You're way off, mate. Atheism is NOT a religion, by definition it's just
that: a desbelief in the existence of deity. How is THAT a religion? Because
disbelief is also a belief? That's ridiculous, nothing more than word play.
[Me]
It is not word play, but rather the most basic philosophy. One must start
with a metaphysical assumption in any case, and metaphysical assumptions can
only be proved by other metaphysical assumptions - but no matter:
Atheism may not be an organized religion in the scale of Christianity or
Islam say, but as you say Atheism has a core belief - That there is no god
or anything like that - and this core BELIEF then links up with other
assumptions that follows from it: the most predominant one being that there
is an objective reality (or for that matter a subjective one) all of which
is beliefs, and banded together they constitute a frame of reference of the
world that is in essence no different in nature to religious views - both
are systems with which to categorize and handle the experiences that people
have.
[Random Guy]
ALL different in nature to religious views. Atheism is involved with science
(though by now I think you might think science "is a form or religion" too).
Anyway, if you're not sure that there is an objective reality and that there
is a systematic method to find out approximate truths of this reality,
called the scientific method, I suggest you jump out of a 50th floor, see if
gravity is just a belief pretty much like religious ones. Who knows, maybe
after the thump you'll wake up in an even wealthier country. Or you can test
Ohm's law with your own body if you happen to have a pair of electrodes. It
won't be so traumatic in the first low-voltage trials.
Anyway, it's all the more ridiculous since you DO lead your everyday life
under the assumption that there is an objective reality.
[Me, amused]
Haha, I've heard this argument a million times. It's always the same. "But
science can be proven!" - sure it can: within it's own realm. There is
absolutely no denying that science is based on metaphysical assumptions
however: and as for those "jump down a building and see what happens" kind
of "arguments" they are really just noise in the wind. It doesn't prove an
objective reality in any way: in truth you can't any way you try - because
the concept of an objective reality is a metaphysical assumption, and to
prove it you have to use the tools that that metaphysical assumption hands
you. To simplify: first you say that the world is made up of A, then you
prove this by using the tool AB. The problem is that this tool must be based
on A to work, and thus A can't be proven.
So, if someone says that the world actually consists of 1 and then tries to
prove this with the tool 1.2 - you are really doing the same thing.
(and to overly simplify A = There is an objective reality and 1 = God is the
originator of our reality)
So it's all beliefs you see: what it comes down to is perhaps what belief is
the most useful one: but then again if within the realm of assumption E
there is no value in this kind of usefulness.
[Random Guy]
Anyhow, I put it this way: in your GUT you know that it'd still be stupid to
jump off that building. And you don't dip your finger in boiled water
because you KNOW you'll get burned, every time you do it. That's a pattern,
but you choose to label that "A" as a metaphysical belief. Science is based
on this kind of patterns and therefore it is as real as anything can get.
But if you think this is all assumptions without basis, you may as well live
in a nut house.
- here I would enter and say: QUALITY. But I'm tired of missionary work and
have work to do.
Moq_Discuss mailing list
Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.
http://lists.moqtalk.org/listinfo.cgi/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org
Archives:
http://lists.moqtalk.org/pipermail/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org/
http://moq.org.uk/pipermail/moq_discuss_archive/
