> But is the criticism valuable when it is nonspecific? Does it change the
> position of the sun to criticize a clock for being an hour off? In what
> way does your critical comment in any way help the project? In no way.
> It is worthless because it can change nothing and offers no value to the
> project.
I wasn't the one with the critical comment. I was just saying that just
because you "can't do better" doesn't mean you can't comment. Example: I
can't make a skin for Mozilla but I do have LOTS of ideas and comments on
the current ones. If I write a long post about how to improve a skin or
even if I take the tone of "hey, this sucks.. this should be fixed!", it
shouldn't trigger "shut up or make a better one yourself" comments. It
should be received as any feedback from anyone - participating in working
on the project or not. Participation is not what makes a comment valid or
not.
Peppe
S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
