On Thu, 01 Nov 2001 15:25:06 GMT, Carl Ellison <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> allegedly 
wrote:

> To secure against this worst problem, we found that PGP had an
> advantage over S/MIME, because S/MIME calls for the transmission of a
> certificate chain with any signed message 

I don't think the inclusion of the certificates is a mandatory requirement, 
although I'm going from memory here :)

> If, instead, you accept incoming
> certificates, you are accepting certificates from the attacker,
> chosen by the attacker to fool you into acting some way you shouldn't

I would like to see an option to import the certificate into the local 
database, instead of it happening automatically as it does with Netscape 
4.7.  That way I choose which certificate I trust to belong to the entity 
that sent me the message.

In addition, upon receipt of subsequent messages, I would like to be 
alerted if the certificate has changed for the same entity, and given the 
option to trust (and import) the new certificate, or reject it.

> It would also be very good if the e-mail agent would have PGP support
> built in alongside S/MIME, sine PGP users outnumber S/MIME users.

I'd like that too.

- Dave.

Reply via email to