Martin, all,
I went through the issues grouped under the RMA chapter (Chapter 12) and
found that some of them are issues in the I/O chapter: rows 228-259
(except for row 239) seem relevant for the I/O chapter and not the RMA
chapter. I guess there has been some confusion about document and PDF
numbers. I don't want to mess with the excel sheet but wanted to raise
this here so that the I/O CC can take a look at these points.
Cheers
Joseph
On 9/17/23 10:30, Martin Schulz via mpi-forum wrote:
Hi all,
First of all, thank all for a very productive and focused meeting last
week on our path to MPI 4.1 – both to those attending in person in
Bristol and to those online at often quite unfortunate hours!
As discussed, I compiled a list of all open points and consolidated
this into a single spreadsheet, which is here:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZpsyVTnfNHv85K9Mzi_3niNXdmQ67yV2iwSaoYBTGpI/edit?usp=sharing
There is a total of 380 points that we collected that we think should
be still addressed somehow. I placed them into five categories:
* MPI 4.1: This is more or less the default category and should at
the end contain all small changes that we still want to apply the
standard (and which will be voted on). For all items in these
categories, we will need Pull requests and Issue created.
* Editor changes: Small changes and formatting changes that Bill
will apply directly – no separate PR or Issue is necessary. Once
an item is in this category, please do not touch it (unless Bill
pushes it back to one of the other categories)
* Flow: Items covering bad page breaks, strange spacing, etc., which
do not change the contents of the document and which need to be
addressed at the very end during layout – Bill will go over them
at the end and these items are mainly meant as hints for him to
pay attention to
* MPI 4.2: Items we think are too big and which should be pushed to
the next version of the standard or separate erratas. For those,
we will eventually also need PRs and Issues and we could
technically start reading them in the next meeting if there is time.
* Reject: items we decided to drop
Note: this list all points individually as we recorded them – multiple
of them can of course (and should) be grouped into a single PR or Issue.
ACTION ITEMS:
* If you reviewed parts of the standard, please check the list and
make sure comments are properly recorded (if you noticed mistakes
in the page numbers, please let me know, as this means updates in
hidden parts of the spreadsheet)
* CC chairs: please take a look at all comments for your chapter and
ensure that they are consolidated correctly. By default you are
responsible for completing or shepherding all items in your chapter.
* If you have created PRs and Issues (or if you do so from now on),
please place them into the appropriate columns, so we can track it
and place yourself into the owner category.
* If the PR/Issue is complete and ready for review, please mark this
in the column “DONE”.
* If you think an MPI 4.1 issue should be moved to one of the other
categories, please move the checkmark and note the reason for the
decision in the “Comments” column at the end (together with your
name).
As Wes noted on Friday, we have a short time line here – all items we
want for 4.1 must be in the DONE column by September 26.
I hope this all makes sense and covers all steps forward – if you have
any questions, comments or concerns, please let me know.
Thanks!
Martin
PS: This is a shared spreadsheet, so please be careful when editing
and please do not change anything structural. Also, mark any
decisions, observations or comments in the last column together with
your name, so we have a track record for the discussions next time.
Thanks!
--
Prof. Dr. Martin Schulz, Chair of Computer Architecture and Parallel
Systems
Department of Informatics, TU-Munich, Boltzmannstraße 3, D-85748 Garching
Member of the Board of Directors at the Leibniz Supercomputing Centre
(LRZ)
Email: schu...@in.tum.de
_______________________________________________
mpi-forum mailing list
mpi-forum@lists.mpi-forum.org
https://lists.mpi-forum.org/mailman/listinfo/mpi-forum
_______________________________________________
mpi-forum mailing list
mpi-forum@lists.mpi-forum.org
https://lists.mpi-forum.org/mailman/listinfo/mpi-forum
