It's good to see the shift in Mr. Meldahl's thought that non-profits operate in "secrecy" to a more specific thought that nonprofit housing providers allegedly don't provide sufficient information to get government funding.  If there is any doubt about the length to which anyone seeking public subsidies must go to obtain housing finance, check out just one or two of the forms MHFA requires for multifamily development applications:
 
 
They look for it all, just like (and likely much more) than a traditional lender does for a private developer.
 
As for Form 990, it's a valuable public disclosure source. Just picking a nonprofit that most folks think does good work--Minneapolis-based Center for Victims of Torture--and you learn the salaries of its most senior executives, officers, and employees, the amount it spent in postage ($75,000), how much it receives in speaking fees each year ($12,852), total lobbying expenses ($28,799), the value of an abandoned copier ($756), and so on and so on.  Vague?  Perhaps if you are looking for a smoking gun that ultimately does not exist.  As for disclosing donors, imagine the chilling effect on contributions if all donors must be disclosed publicly.
 
On top of that, any nonprofit worth its salt must be audited each year if it relies on charitable funds from established donors.  So, whille I may understand the desire for more upfront financial information about a particular housing development, concentrating the battle against the alleged evil and shadowy nonprofit world isn't worth engaging, as I'd like the same information about, say, the Urban Village, the Carriage House Grant Program, and other primarily private developer driven projects.
 
That'll be all for me on this, as its gotten beyond Minneapolis at this point.
 
Gregory Luce
Project 504/Minneapolis (North Phillips)
 
Steve Meldahl wrote:
Greg Luce indicates that the Web site with the Attorney General's office is just loaded with information on non profits and their finances.  These form 990s do not disclose anything of substance or value.
 
Can you imagine going to a bank to borrow money and all you brought was the same information as contained on the 990 form?  Of course not!  Since we taxpayers in the real world are one of the lenders (ie banks) , the non profits involved in building and or renovating housing should disclose the same information to the lender (ie taxpayers).  This would include proforma cash flow statements, balance sheets, and profit and loss statements on each and every project that they have in inventory and on all proposed projects - just like us in the real business world.

Reply via email to