Hi,

On Mon, 14 Jan 2008, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

> First, I'd like to thank you for porting git to windows. I decided to 
> evaluate git in September for tracking the history of some scripts and 
> routines. I never used any revision control system before, and only 
> needed the local aspect of git (although I might use it to share with 
> colleagues in the future). I had reduced my choice to git, mercurial and 
> a third one whose name I forgot (probably related to subversion or SVK). 
> I tried Git first because it was the closest to my needs (Free, easy to 
> use, not big to install, developed and supported). I never actually 
> tried the others because I found git good enough.

Thank you!

> I have noticed what I think is a little bug with git-gui. It is easy to 
> work around it, but it may be frustrating for new users, so it may be 
> worth fixing for the final version. When launching git-gui, the first 
> window allows to create a new repository, open a new repository, etc. It 
> seems that if you have an existing folder with files and you want to 
> create a repository to track this folder, it is not working: "Create New 
> Repository" will complain that the directory already exists, while "Open 
> Existing Repository" will complain that it is not a git repository. The 
> solution is to use the command line and "git- init" into that folder.
> 
> I have seen this with the last 3 or 4 git previews, and never tried
> before, because I had only one repository created at the time git-gui
> did not work yet.
> 
> I think "Create New Repository" should accept to work on an existing
> folder (only doing git-init in that case).

Ah, that is right, we do not have an "Initialize Repository" button.  And 
you're right, it could be just detected when trying to create a new 
repository and the directory exists already.

Shawn?

Ciao,
Dscho

Reply via email to