On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 3:30 PM, Brian Schweitzer < [email protected]> wrote:
> On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 2:20 PM, Kuno Woudt <[email protected]> wrote: > >> >> Someone else commented with this, but they didn't sign their name: >> > Oops sorry, that was me. > >> > +1 I also feel some additional examples of ETI would be helpful, or >> > at least a link to (a cleaned up version of) [[Clarify Extra Title >> > Information]]. >> >> The Clarify Extra Title Information page looks like a complete mess >> to me, it has been useful as inspiration for one of the examples, >> but other than that I was planning to just ignore it completely and >> have it removed when we're done. >> >> If you feel there is important information on that page, please please >> extract those bits for me and send them to me, If I missed something >> important it should definitely be included in the guideline. > > > i think the only really useful bit to come out of that was the initial list > of ETI words, which we also worked on back in Jan or Feb when I was working > on the Guess Case rewrite; I don't think it should be in the guideline, but > here was the list that I ended up with for the rewrite: > > 10", 12", 7", a cappella, acoustic, airplay, album, alternative, bonus, > bonus beats, clubmix, > composition, compositions, cut, cuts, demo, demos, dirty, dub, dubs, edit, > edits, excerpt, excerpts, > extended, feat., incomplete, instrumental, interlude, interludes, > interrupted, interview, intro, > karaoke, live, loop, main, maxi, medley, megamix, megamixes, mix, mixes, > orchestral, outro, outtake, > outtakes, re-edit, re-edited, re-edits, rehearsal, reinterpretation, > reinterpretations, reinterpreted, > remake, remakes, remix, remixed, remixes, reprise, reprises, rework, > reworked, session, sessions, > single, skit, skits, takes?\\d+, traditional, unplugged, version, versions, > vocal, vs. > > plus, when they're not alone at the end of a title (or the entire title): > > clean, club, dance, dialogue, disco, extract, house, long, original, radio, > short, studio, take, video > I would like to see a list of these words in the wiki/documentation. I believe they provide value to both new and seasoned editors, if only to have a place to look at to reassure oneself that it should indeed be in lower case. If this list was included then I would group the words from the second list (clean, club, dance...) with the first list, as it wouldn't be guess case logic but human logic determining it. I mentioned in another email that I would like to see a glossary, that might be an ideal place to have a list of ETI words. On a side note, I would like to see "mono" and "stereo" added to any list that is created. Pavan Chander // navap
_______________________________________________ Musicbrainz-style mailing list [email protected] http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
