This, along with RFC-91, RFC-92, and RFC-94, cleans up the rest of the AR
documentation in the wiki. It has no dev impact; this changes only the
docs.
I've done an audit of everything AR-related in the wiki. The only thing
I've not yet done is to check for any remaining ARs which have been created,
but never had a Relationship Type page created or Relationship Class
assigned (I'm waiting for a list of all active ARs to do that bit).
Otherwise, with this, and the other 4 RFCs, everything is set to clean up
the AR documentation. Having all that doc cleaned up will also make our
lives a lot easier when it comes time to look at all the doc/AR changes that
will be needed when the NGS final release comes near.
Rather than do each of these separately, I'm just doing them all at once
here. Unlike the other 3 proposals, any of these, by itself, has only a
small impact. These are all the ones where a Relationship Type never was
created for the AR, a Relationship Class assigned, redirected RT/RC stuff
for ARs/RTs/RCs/etc which were long ago renamed, ancient discussions on dead
AR proposals and concepts, etc. It also finishes cleaning up the mess that
had resulted in Relationship Classes from their being initially introduced,
then mostly ignored ever since.
* Create "Business to Business Relationship Class" as a subClass of
"Business to Business Relationship Class".
* Move all Relationship Types currently in "Business Association
Relationship Class" to "Business to Business Relationship Class".
* Make "Contract Relationship Class" a subClass of "Business Association
Relationship Class".
* Explicitly create "Compiling Artist Role Relationship Class" as a subClass
of "Compilation Relationship Class".
* Explicitly create "Compiled Material Relationship Class" as a subClass of
"Compilation Relationship Class".
* Explicitly create "Remixing Artist Role Relationship Class" as a subClass
of "Remix Relationship Class".
* Explicitly create "Remixed Material Relationship Class" as a subClass of
"Remix Relationship Class".
* Add "PureVolume Relationship Type" to "External Website Relationship
Class" (assuming RFC-91 passes).
* Add "Cataloguer Relationship Type" to "Musical Association Relationship
Class".
* Add "IMDb Relationship Type" to "External Website Relationship Class"
(assuming RFC-91 passes).
* Assign "IBDb Relationship Type" to "External Website Relationship Class"
(assuming RFC-91 passes).
* Create "IOBDb Relationship Type" for the IOBDb AR and assign it to
"External Website Relationship Class" (assuming RFC-91 passes).
* Add "Online Community Relationship Type" to "External Website Relationship
Class" (assuming RFC-91 passes).
* Add "Tribute Relationship Type" to "Musical Association Relationship
Class".
* Create a temporary "NGS Upgrade Class" to store ARs that exist only as
part of the process of upgrading to NGS (this Class, and its Relationship
Type, to be later removed when we upgrade to NGS).
* Add "Part Of Set Relationship Type" to "NGS Upgrade Class".
* Remove the following defunct AR-related wiki pages:
- AdvancedRelationshipTypeProposal - redirects to Advanced Relationship
Type Proposal, then redirects to Proposals
- Advanced Relationship Type Proposal - redirects to Proposals
- Cataloguer Relationship Type Proposal - passed, redirects to
Cataloguer Relationship Type
- CategoryProposedAdvancedRelationshipType - redirects to
Category:Proposed Advanced Relationship Type
- CategoryRelationshipType - redirects to Category:Relationship Type
- Co-Producer Relationship Type - redirects to Producer Relationship
Type
- CoProducerRelationshipType - redirects to Producer Relationship Type
- IMDb - redirects to IMDb Relationship Type
- InternetMovieDatabase - redirects to IMDb Relationship Type
- Member Of Band Relationship - redirects to Member Of Band Relationship
Type
- Member Of Band Relationship Style - redirects to Member Of Band
Relationship Type
- Performs As Relationship Type - redirects to Performance Name
Relationship Type
- Same Release Relationship Type - redirects to Earliest Release
Relationship Type
- SameReleaseRelationshipType - redirects to Earliest Release
Relationship Type
- Advanced Relationship Type Development - very out of date, has been
replaced several times over, most recently by the Proposals page.
- Proposed Advanced Relationship Type - redirects to Category:Proposed
Advanced Relationship Type
- Amazon - way outdated, everything here is covered by Amazon
Relationship Type, which is also far more up to date.
- Advanced Relationship - redirects to Advanced Relationships
- Release Transliteration And Translation - dead proposal, long since
replaced by Translation Transliteration Relationship Type
- Object Model/Artist Thoughts - ancient proto-proposal predating
Advanced Relationships and giving some thoughts on how they could possibly
be implemented
- How To Write Advanced Relationships Documentation - outdated and no
longer current or in use
- RelationshipTypeTemplate - redirects to Relationship Class Template
- Relationship Class Template - outdated and no longer current or in use
- RelationshipAttributeTemplate - redirects to Relationship Attribute
Template
- Relationship Attribute Template - outdated and no longer current or in
use
- RelationshipClassTemplate - redirects to Relationship Class Template
- Relationship Class Template - outdated and no longer current or in use
- SimpleAdvancedRelationshipsInterface - redirects to Simple Advanced
Relationships Interface
- FancyAdvancedRelationshipsInterface - redirects to Fancy Advanced
Relationships Interface
- Simple Advanced Relationships Interface - ancient history, from
figuring out the UI for the mason code. Anything useful has been
implemented now, and the switch to the NGS code makes it doubly uesless to
keep at this point.
- Fancy Advanced Relationships Interface - same as above
- What Is A Cover - old, unused now, and made redundant by Cover
Relationship Type
- Bad MoinMoin WikiName - only an AR-related page in that there's some
AR pages on there, but in any case, this is useless at this point, as we're
not even using MoinMoin anymore, let alone UseMod.
- Power Of AR - a useless stub
- Unresolved Style Issues - ancient and dead
This is RFC-96. Without objection, it will move to RFV on 2010-03-08.
Thanks,
-Brian
_______________________________________________
Musicbrainz-style mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
