Hi All,

I've noticed one or two postings on here from people wanting to using 
MClient to play flac files.

My main music repository is also in flac format. Playing individual 
tracks through the file browser is fine, but that's obviously a bit 
limiting if you want to play a whole album.

I tried a slightly different tack to get around this. My music is 
organised by artist, with album title folders at the next level each 
containing a set of tracks (named "<track no.> - <track title>.flac" so 
they appear in the same order as the original album).

I produced a simple bash script to create a playlist structure, 
mirroring the music structure with one folder per artist at the top 
level, each containing an m3u file for each title. The m3u files 
contain a complete list of tracks for the album, pointing back to the 
flac file in each case.

This works really well. I can make the bash script available to anyone 
else who is interested. I have one or two thoughts arising from this 
relating to the file and m3u browsers, in particular some points around 
intuative use for my less technical girlfriend - interested to hear 
what others think / any suggestions:

1) It doesn't appear to be possible to default the file browser path to 
anything other than root, without entering the file browser at 
start-up. It would be useful to set the default path such that it shows 
the top level of the playlist structure. Even better, make it possible 
to create a dedicated menu entry where the user is only able to see 
what is under a specified top level path, (e.g. a Music menu option 
which displays the contents of /music/playlists)

2) I tend to find the method of navigating up the folder structure 
slightly unintuative (selecting ../ at the top of each folder navigates 
up, Back/Exit navigates back to the main menu, whereas within the 
MythTV screens, Back/Exit always takes you up one level). I can see the 
logic behind why it is the way it is and this comment is perhaps more 
about the way that I'm using the functionality, but even replacing ../ 
with [Up] or [Back] would make it easier to understand for the 
non-technical user.

3) It gets more confusing when you consider that Back/Exit takes you 
out of an m3u track listing, back to the file browser (effectively 
taking you back up a level from track to album), but pressing Back/Exit 
again takes you out to the main menu, rather than back up to the artist 
level.

4) When playing a track within m3u, the OSD panel shows the name of the 
m3u file rather than the track name - minor point, but displaying the 
track name would seem to be slightly more logical.

5) Another minor point - having the option to hide extensions within 
the file browser would also be quite useful - the only files within my 
structure are .m3u files, an extension which means nothing to someone 
who doesn't understand the internal workings.

I accept that most of this arises from the way that I've chosen to use 
the functionality. So no critism implied by any of this - indeed the 
option to be able to do this at all is a bonus, since I set it up 
mainly as a cheap front end.

-- 
Mark Smith - Surrey, UK
http://www.chez-moi.org.uk/


-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by DB2 Express
Download DB2 Express C - the FREE version of DB2 express and take
control of your XML. No limits. Just data. Click to get it now.
http://sourceforge.net/powerbar/db2/
_______________________________________________
Mvpmc-users mailing list
Mvpmc-users@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/mvpmc-users
mvpmc wiki: http://mvpmc.wikispaces.com/

Reply via email to