Now to me Task Scheduling is a different area to just a Calendar - which to me ultimately contains a view of appointments/time blocks. I know these sorts of things are/can all be interlinked - but Task Scheduling makes me think of things like Above&Beyond/TimeTo - a calendar makes me think of Outlook, Intellect etc. Obviously to 'Task Schedule' a calendar is a fundamental requirement - to me though it would have to be an integral requirement and major part of MLO if 'Task Scheduling' is going to be anything more than very basic.
Again terminology wise I think there needs to be a distinction made between a Schedule and a Calendar. Well at least a definition of both terms as far as MLO is concerned. Also whether people are after Task Scheduling or a Calendar to store appointments etc, with the ability to view tasks that have been 'scheduled' for a specific day. To build an application around Task Scheduling would to me be a different beast than the inclusion of a just a 'simple' calendar in MLO. All the best Steve ----- Original message ---------------------------------------- From: Greg.O <[email protected]> To: MyLifeOrganized <[email protected]> Received: 17/12/2008 16:22:28 Subject: [MLO] Re: Calendar >We've been through this discussion a few times already >but hey, there >we go again :) >To me a calendar could be simply a graphical display of >the upcoming >week/month with an overlay of items scheduled for each >day. I know it >is now possible to configure the filtering to group tasks >by day - >while it does the trick to some degree as far as I'm >concerned a >"proper" calendar layout would work much better. >The thing I struggle most with when using MLO is >scheduling and re- >scheduling tasks. Most of the time I will brainstorm and >add new tasks >using the outline view. When it comes to scheduling each >of them >things can difficult. I highlight a task and assign a due >date, then >goes to the next one and next one. The problem is I >can't really see >how my week is shaping up (what I've already >scheduled) and, >therefore, setting due dates is more or less a guess. I >get to a task, >think about when I want to do it and assign it a due >date. I'm not >aware, however, that I'd already scheduled 10 more >tasks on that day >and, therefore, I end up heavily overscheduling my day. >So the day >comes, I can't complete all the tasks, I need to re- >schedule tasks I >haven't been able to complete - again I can't easily >assess when they >should be scheduled for. So I guess again ("let's >schedule the lot for >Friday") and again when Friday comes I realize I've >scheduled too much >stuff. >It would be really nice to be able to dock a calendar so >when I'm >scheduling my tasks I can quickly see what day I still >have some room >left to squeeze a few things in and what days are "fully >booked". If >the calendar could also sum up all "Time required for >the task" values >and display it for each day (e.g. Wednesday - 7.5 hours' >of tasks >scheduled) my life would be so much easier. >Regards, >Greg Osimowicz >On Dec 17, 12:41 pm, "Steve Wynn" ><[email protected]> >wrote: >> Define 'simple' calendar? >> >> As the champion of the 'no calendar in MLO group' >(self proclaimed ) I would be interested in the >interpretation of simple. If you search the previous >messages in the group on calendar you will see we have >had some interesting debates on this topic. Though I >don't ever think we reached a resolution. I think the >majority consensus (though I may be wrong) is to have >more of a time-line function within MLO to link more >into the project related aspects. >> >> Saying that I think we probably still have two >entrenched camps, those for a calendar and those >against. Personally I am not opposed to a calendar as >such, but it is such a generic term that has a multitude >of meanings that I think from a development point of >view specifics are required. I am not so sure the >specifics have yet to be defined - though many people >have put forward their own take on the requirements. >> >> What the 'for calendar' group need is a champion, to >bring together all of the information so far received. >Then personally I think somebody needs to come up with >a technical specification that can then be posted for >review. There also needs to be some solid justification, >people using MLO at the moment are obviously using >something else for this function (I use Chaos Intellect). > So how is MLO going to draw users away from their >current application? Is the answer to have a calendar >or closer integration with existing calendar >applications? Calendars link to scheduling, which links >to contacts - which link to more of a PIM based app - >personally I already have a PIM so see no advantage in >MLO becoming one. >> >> I can always come up with more questions than answers >on this one, a simple plug-in calendar module might suit >the requirements. If that could be done with minimal >development time and would be taken 'as is' then I >would give a yes vote. But my concerns is that focus >will be directed to the 'calendar' and the development >of this feature, in other words it will not be a static >component. Do we really want MLO Development to be >spent on calendar functionality? Especially when to me, >Time&Chaos, Intellect, Outlook, Google, Sunbird - to >name just a few - do this well at the moment. >> >> I also think 'simple' might translate as being pretty >useless for the bulk of MLO users - without added >functionality. I think there is a feeling, more than a >proven certainty, that a calendar in MLO is going to be >an improvement. Being able to visualise the workload as >a main consideration. Personally I am not so sure a >calendar meets this requirement. A list of tasks on a >given day to me does not really aid that much with >planning or workload balance. I think other things >might be instigated to better achieve this - graphical >progress bars on projects - percentage completion >scores more visible - gant charts - pie charts - better >reporting. >> >> Anyway, thought I better chime in before the 'for >calendar' momentum started to get overwhelming. I >think there is a lot to think about with regards to this >overall. >> >> All the best >> >> Steve >> >> ----- Original message -------------------------------- >-------- >> >> From: Ciaran >> >> To: MyLifeOrganized >> >> Received: 16/12/2008 15:31:51 >> >> Subject: [MLO] Calendar >> >> >A simple Calendar function in MLO would be a >distinct >> >> >advantage, >> >> >containing dated tasks. Without a calendar, it is very >> >> >difficult to >> >> >track appointments when completing a week's tasks, >for >> >> >example. >> >> All the best >> >> Steve >> >> >> >> big_grin.gif >> < 1KViewDownload > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "MyLifeOrganized" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/myLifeOrganized?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
